Deborah Lee Tomlinson.*

Deborah Lee Tomlinson was born on October 15, 1957 in Bitburg, Germany to Arthur and Sandra (nee Roup) Tomlinson. Arthur Vernon Tomlinson was born on September 22, 1937 in Modesto, California, and Sandra Lee Roup was born on December 31, 1939 in Livingston, Montana. According to the Tomlinson family tree, the couple had three daughters together: Deborah and her twin sisters, Jean and Joyce (b. 1958). At some point they divorced, and Mr. Tomlinson was briefly married again in 1968 (they quickly parted ways; he went on to have a relationship with Sally Morphis and in 1969 they had a son together named Daniel. He got married to Shelley Williams on August 30, 1975 in Orange, CA but their union also didn’t last long, and they split up in February of the following year. Mr. Tomlinson was married for a fourth time, and the couple had a son together. Sandra got remarried to Henry Nelson on May 10, 1963 in Billings, Montana.

After their parents parted ways Deborah, Jean, and Joyce went to live with their father and stepmother in California, and Sandra relocated to Oregon.  Because of their parents’ divorce the girls were separated from their mother at a very young age, which Joyce felt prevented them from forming a strong bond because she wasn’t given a chance to raise her own babies.

According to most reports online, Deborah Lee Tomlinson disappeared from Creswell, Oregon** on her sixteenth birthday on October 15, 1973. Creswell is an incredibly small town with only one high school, and according to the 1970 census the reported population was made up of a mere 1,199 people (it went up to 5,031 in 2010). Referred to as ‘Debbie’ by family and friends (per Joyce, she hated being called ‘Deb’), Tomlinson had brown eyes, stood at 5’5” tall, and weighed 140 pounds (Joyce felt she may have been slightly heavier); she wore her golden-brown hair at her shoulders and had a ring of moles around her neck. In the initial days following her disappearance investigators strongly believed that she was a runaway, which most likely explains why I couldn’t find any newspaper reports or media coverage on her. One of the only other real takeaways I could find regarding her case was that she disappeared with an ‘unidentified teenage friend.’

** After I initially wrote the article on Deborah in April 2024 I was contacted by her sister Jean, and more recently Joyce. Both sisters were kind enough to help fill in some of the gaps in their family background and were able to provide me with some of their thoughts regarding her disappearance. According to Jean, their Aunt Helen told them in more recent years that Deborah had ran away from Eugene, not Creswell, and at one point the family had been contacted by a friend that claimed they had seen her in Santa Rosa, CA with ‘a black guy,’ which was a big deal as their father didn’t approve of people of color (Joyce also said she was there visiting a friend named Lyn). The family member also volunteered that they thought she may have been pregnant at the time as well, but nothing ever came out of that. About this alleged sighting, Joyce doesn’t feel it’s true, as that’s where their grandmother lived and Deborah would never have left the area without paying her a visit, especially if she had been pregnant (the two were especially close). 

According to Jean, after their parents split up the girls were raised by their father in California, but because Deborah’s didn’t get along very well with their stepmother she had moved to Oregon to live with their mother (who she also clashed with). She also said that at the time her sister disappeared she seemed mostly happy but had been in a bit of a transition period in her life and may have been under the impression that moving out of state may have resulted in more lenient rules, but that wasn’t the case.

According to Joyce, Debbie was simply acting like any other teenager, doing things like sneaking out at night and smoking: one evening in a quick moment of anger their dad announced that he was pulling a ‘Pontious Pilot’ and was ‘washing his hands of her.’ When she left home Joyce said somehow she knew it would be the last time that she ever saw her, and to this day she struggles with her feelings towards her father about that event. Additionally, she strongly suspects that a missing person’s report was never filed in the days after she was last seen, as she never came across one after contacting local Oregon law enforcement. Because of this, I strongly feel that Debbie didn’t disappear exactly on October 15, 1973, and most likely vanished sometime around it.

Jean shared with me that in the years following her sister’s disappearance neither one of their parents wanted to talk much about her, as it brough up too many painful memories. Because of this she told me that she doesn’t know as much about her as she would like to, but she does know that Debbie loved rock n ’roll music and had gotten caught sneaking out at night several times while she still lived with them in California.

Shortly after Deborah disappeared Joyce told me that their stepbrother had reached out to let her know about a formerly missing woman had been found murdered that happened to have some moles around her neck in a pattern similar to Debbie’s (which she said appeared to be ‘almost like a spaced apart, like a necklace’); it obviously turned out not to be her.

When I asked if perhaps Debbie had run off with a guy, Jean shared with me that was what most likely happened, despite the fact the sisters weren’t allowed to date until they were sixteen. Regarding her feelings on the recent ‘genetic genealogy’ craze and if she thought it could help solve the mystery of what happened to her sister, she said that she has never been contacted by LE about it, however at one point she was told by the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children that any records possibly related to Deborah were destroyed in a fire.

In 1984 Joyce and her husband took a road trip with their grandkids to visit their great-grandmother and Hank, and while there her stepfather shared that he caught Debbie sneaking out one night and she had been smoking marijuana. He told them that this freaked him out and he tried to do a ‘scared straight’ type intervention and had reached out to the local county sheriff (who had happened to be a friend of his), who had come to the house and had a conversation with his teenage stepdaughter; Debbie disappeared shortly after that.

At the time Tomlinson disappeared in October 1973, Ted Bundy was living at the Rogers Rooming House on 12th Avenue Northeast in Seattle, and where it was a five-hour drive (one way) from his residence to Eugene/Creswell, we know he had no problem with traveling long distances to look for prey. Despite being in a long term, (supposedly) monogamous relationship with Liz Kendall, while on a business trip with the Republican Party to California in the summer of 1973 he rekindled his romance with one time girlfriend Diane Edwards. Ted’s former flame visited him in Seattle on multiple occasions in the latter part of the year, and the couple at one point were even briefly engaged… but the happy times didn’t last long, and in January 1974 he abruptly and without reason cut off all contact with her.

On top of juggling two women, in September 1973 Ted enrolled in law school at the University of Puget Sound, and according to the ‘TB MultiAgency Investigative Team Report 1992,’ on Monday, October 15, 1973 when Tomlinson disappeared, he was in class. Additionally, at the time he was in between employment: in September 1973 he was the Assistant to the Washington state Republican chairman and remained unemployed until May 3 of the following year when he got a position with the Department of Emergency Services in Olympia.

In addition to Ted Bundy multiple other serial killers roamed the Pacific Northwest in the early to middle 1970’s: the first one (aside from Ted) that popped in my head was Warren Leslie Forrest, a double murderer that has been sentenced to two life terms in prison for the murders of Krysta Blake and Martha Morrison in 1974; he is also considered the prime suspect in at least five additional murders and disappearances going back as far as 1971. He has been in police custody since 1974 and on February 4, 2023 he was convicted on another murder count after DNA linked him to the murder of Martha Morrison. 

On June 8, 1961, Portland police received a call from a housewife whose dog had returned home with a human foot in a paper bag, and when detectives went to her home the animal came back with a hand. Upon investigating, LE found several additional body parts around the woman’s neighborhood, and all of the appendages were deemed to be fresh and were completely drained of blood. Police went through local missing people’s reports and came across the file of twenty-three year old Joan Caudle, a housewife and mother of two that had recently been reported missing by her husband (who of course was an immediate suspect). 

Joan’s husband told detectives that where she wasn’t normally a big drinker she had been a bit depressed recently because her mother had been sick, therefore there was a chance she had been at a bar having a few. Police then tracked down a barfly that had a string of arrests for public drunkenness and she told them she had been in a bar on the night of June 7 and met a man going by the name Marquette. The pair had seemingly hit it off when a woman approached them and stole his attention away, and when detectives showed the eyewitness a photograph of Joan Caudle, she said that was definitely the same woman from the bar.

Upon his arrest Marquette admitted that he raped and murdered the Portland housewife then he drained her blood, dismembered her body, and left her head to rot in the woods. Despite being found guilty of first degree murder the jury recommended leniency, and Marquette was sentenced to life in prison.After serving only eleven years of his sentence (during which he was described as a model prisoner), he was released on parole in 1973.

Not even two and a half years after Marquette was released on parole in April 1975, a fisherman discovered a mutilated corpse floating in a Willamette River slough in Marion County, Oregon; it had been bled dry and had been dismembered. Detectives determined the remains were those of thirty-seven-year-old Betty Lucille Wilson (one report said she was thirty-five), a North Carolina native who led a life of extreme poverty and had seven children since marrying her abusive husband at the age of 16.  At the time she was killed she was living in an abandoned school bus.

While he was confessing to Wilson’s murder, Marquette also shared with detectives that he killed a second woman in a similar fashion sometime in 1974, and he led them to two shallow graves where he had disposed of the bulk of the remains. Unfortunately because the head was never found, there was no way the victim could be identified, and Marquette admitted that he didn’t know who she was. Her identity remains unknown.

Within a five-month period in the latter part of 1973 five young women went missing in Oregon, and three more were found murdered: first was Rita Lorraine Jolly, who disappeared on June 29 while taking a nightly walk in her West Linn neighborhood; her remains have never been found. On July 9, 1973 the body of Laurie Lee Canaday was recovered in the middle of the road at the intersection of Southeast Scott Street and McLoughlin Boulevard in Milwaukee, OR. Next was seventeen-year-old Susan Wickersham from Bend on July 11; her body was discovered in January 1976, only five miles south of her hometown; she had suffered a gunshot wound to the head. Additionally, sometime in July 1973 fifteen-year-old Allison Lynn Caufman of Portland died as a result of head injuries after she was shoved from a car moving at a high rate of speed.

On August 20, 1973 twenty-four-year-old Illinois transplant Vicki Lynn Hollar was last seen getting in her black 1965 Volkswagen Beetle (with the running boards removed) after she left her place of employment at the Bon Marché in Eugene, where she had been working as a seamstress for about two weeks. It’s thought that she was headed home to her apartment, as she had plans of meeting up with a friend to attend a party in her neighborhood later that evening (she never showed up). Friends shared with police that she had a habit of picking up hitchhikers; her VW and personal belongings have also never been recovered. Just three days later on August 23, 1973, Gayle LeClair was found stabbed in her apartment in Eugene, OR. The twenty-two year old had recently moved to the area after she got a job at the Eugene City Library.

Just six days after Deborah Tomlinson was reportedly last seen, thirty-two-year-old Virginia Erickson disappeared from Sweet Home on October 21, 1973; although it’s never been proven, evidence points towards her husband being her killer and that it most likely took place while the two were ‘out on a hunting trip.’ Lastly, we have twenty-three-year-old divorcee Suzanne Justis, who went missing on November 5, 1973. From Eugene, Justis had hitchhiked to Portland (despite owning her own car), and had called her mom from a payphone outside of the Veterans Memorial Coliseum to let her know that she would be home the next day to pick up her son from school; she never showed up. Not one case has been solved.

Strangely enough, there was another young woman with the same first and last name as Deborah that had been brutally killed a little over two years after she was last seen in Colorado: nineteen-year-old Deborah Kathleen Tomlinson was murdered in her apartment complex on Belford Ave in Grand Junction on December 27, 1975. In the days that followed her murder, detectives quickly exhausted all leads and the investigation quickly went cold. Forty-five long years went by. In an article published on December 3, 2020 by the website ‘WesternSlopeNow,’ the Grand Junction PD announced a break in the case: they had partnered with a DNA Technology Company called Parabon to analyze the unknown semen and blood that had been found with the victim at the original 1975 crime scene.

About the process, Parabon’s Chief Genetic Genealogist CeCe Moore said that they analyze ‘the DNA, so we can look at 850,000 genetic markers that will allow us to predict relationships that are distant.’ Also, just as a side note, Moore is the scientist that helped solve the 1971 murder of Roman Catholic schoolteacher Rita Curran out of Vermont (who up until recently was also an unconfirmed Bundy victim). After the samples that were collected from the original 1975 crime scene were processed, Parabon built a family tree using public records in an attempt to identify the unknown person-of-interest, and it was concluded that a man named Jimmy Dean Duncan killed Deborah K. Tomlinson. As of April 2024, law enforcement has found no connection between Duncan and Tomlinson, but found that he had a family member that lived close to the college she was attending at the time of her death. Detective Sean Crocker from the Grand Junction Police Department commented that ‘we believe Mr. Duncan visited this relative, and that’s how possibly he could’ve encountered Ms. Tomlinson.’ Jimmy Dean Duncan passed away in 1987.

Arthur Tomlinson died at the age of sixty-four on January 29, 2001 in Las Vegas, NV. Deborah’s mother Sandra Lee Nelson passed away from lung cancer at the age of sixty-three on February 2, 2003, and according to her death certificate, she had been the owner/operator of a café. Sandy’s husband Henry died on March 16, 1994 at the age of 54, most likely in a medical facility in Spokane, WA. Deborah’s brother Daniel Sean Tomlinson died in 2022 at the age of fifty-three in California.

Deborah’s sister Jean retired after almost twenty years in the RV Business in November 2023, and she currently lives in Henderson, Nevada with her husband of almost twenty years, Dave. In 2019 Joyce retired from the Bureau for Child Support Enforcement with the State of West Virginia, and was married to the love of her life until he passed away on May 26, 2003. She currently resides in St Thomas, Pennsylvania. If Deborah was anything like her sisters, she was a kind, compassionate person that would have done a lot of good in this world.

In the years following Deborah’s disappearance the twins remain close, although Jean admitted her disappearance has been incredibly hard on their family. She also confessed that a small part of her always thought her big sister would reach out to one of them when they were adults, after everyone had grown up. More than anything they want closure, and at the very least wish they had a body to properly lay to rest so their sister could be with the rest of their family. Debbie would have been an aunt and great aunt multiple times over, and it’s heartbreaking to think of her never getting to meet either of her brother-in-laws, or nieces and nephews. As of October 2025, Deborah Lee Tomlinson’s case remains open and she would be 68 years old. Joyce said that the family’s DNA is on file with the NCMEC website.

* In October 2025 I finally came across the Tomlinson family’s Ancestry page, which helped give me a lot of background into Deborah’s family life and background. I also updated the article with information from an interview that I did with her sister Jean in February 2025 as well.

Works Cited:
Namus. Retrieved April 3, 2024 from namus.nij.ojp.gov/case/MP11096
Websleuths. ‘OR – Deborah Tomlinson, 16, Creswell, 16 Oct 1973.’ Retrieved April 3, 2024 from https://www.websleuths.com/forums/threads/or-deborah-tomlinson-16-creswell-16-oct-1973.319290/
Westernslopenow. December 3, 2020. ‘Cold case murder of Deborah Tomlinson solved after 45 years.’ Retrieved April 3, 2024 from https://www.westernslopenow.com/news/local-news/cold-case-murder-of-deborah-tomlinson-solved-after-45-years/

A missing persons poster for Deborah.
The girls standing with their dad and Aunt Jean, who Joyce said they were all especially fond of; sadly right after this picture was taken she moved to Virginia. Photo courtesy of the Tomlinson family archives.
The three sisters in a picture during their time in the Bethlehem Lutheran Church Chancel Choir that was published in The Rohnert Park Cotati Clarion on June 26, 1968.
Deborah (on the far left), Joyce, and Jean. Photo courtesy of the Tomlinson family archives.
Some members of the Tomlinson family; it looks like Deborah and her sisters are in the front. Photo courtesy of the Tomlinson family archives.
Tomlinson before she disappeared in 1973.
What Debbie Tomlinson might have looked like at the age of 53 using age progressing technology, photo released on July 21, 2011.
What Debbie Tomlinson might have looked like at the age of 58 using age progressing technology, photo released on June 28, 2016.
According to the ‘Ted Bundy MultiAgency Investigative Team Report 1992,’ on October 15, 1973 when Tomlinson disappeared Bundy was supposed to be in class at The University of Puget Sound in Tacoma. 
Bundy’s fall 1973 law school schedule from the University of Puget Sound.
Bundy’s route from where he lived at the Rogers Rooming house to Creswell, OR.
Warren Leslie Forrest.
A more recent picture of Warren Leslie Forrest.
Warren Leslie Forrest’s van.
Richard Laurence Marquette.
A list of some other missing girls from Oregon from 1969-78. Tomlinson isn’t even listed.
A comment on a Websleuth’s page about Deborah’s disappearance made by Joyce Sparks on October 16, 2013.
A comment on a Websleuth’s post about Deborah Tomlinson made by user ‘Caring1.’
A Websleuth’s comment on a post about Deborah made by a user named ‘theshadow45’ on August 27, 2017.
A Websleuth’s comment on a post about Deborah made by a user named ‘Alleykins’ on August 27, 2017.
Deborah Kathleen Tomlinson.
An article about the murder of Deborah Kathleen Tomlinson published by The Daily Sentinel on January 14, 1976.
The Tomlinson family tree, courtesy of Joyce Tomlinson.
Deborah’s grandmother Nora and her father, Arthur. Photo courtesy of the Tomlinson family archives.
Deborah’s father, Arthur Vernon Tomlinson. Photo courtesy of the Tomlinson family archives.
Deborah’s mother listed in the 1940 census.
Arthur Tomlinson from the 1951 Westwego High School yearbook.
Deborah’s father listed in some Baptism’s that took place in New Orleans, Louisiana in 1951.
An article about Mr. Tomlinson’s time in the military in Great Falls, Montana published in The Malmstrom Minuteman on May 25, 1956.
A passport log for Deborah’s mother Sandra dated August 5, 1959.
A passport log for Deborah, dated August 5, 1959.
A passport log for Deborah’s sister Joyce dated August 5, 1959.
A passport log for Deborah’s sister Jean dated August 5, 1959,
Arthur Tomlinson in a list of people applying for a marriage license published in The Press Democrat on January 11, 1968.
Mr. Tomlinson’s address; according to this, he was employed at Sonoma State Hospital at the time.
Arthur Tomlinson and his second wife listed in the CA Divorce Index, 1966-1977.
Jean and Joyce Tomlinson. Photo courtesy of the Tomlinson family archives.
Some of the Tomlinson family at Jean’s wedding. Photo courtesy of the Tomlinson family archives.
Some members of Deborah’s family at Joyce’s wedding. Photo courtesy of the Tomlinson family archives.
Mr. Tomlinson’s second wife, Shelley.
Henry Nelson’s obituary published in The Montana Standard on March 17, 1994.
Deborah’s mothers death certificate.
Deborah’s half-brother, Daniel Sean Tomlinson.
Deborah’s half-brother, Daniel.
Deborah’s baby sisters, Joyce and Jean.
Deborah’s sister Jean and her husband, Dave.

Donna Ann Lass.

Donna Ann Lass was born on November 3, 1944 to James ‘Peter’ and Frances (nee Kukar) Lass in Beresford, South Dakota; when she was born her mother was 43 and her dad was 47. Mr. Lass was born on August 25, 1897 and was the second of three children. He served in WWI and spent most of his career farming in the areas of Beresford and Worthing in South Dakota. He married Frances Mary Kukar in Aurelia, Iowa and the couple had eight children together: two boys (Raymond and Eugene) and six girls (Donna, Marjorie, Mary, Karen, Joan, and Patricia). Mrs. Lass was born on November 24, 1900. They eventually divorced, and on October 18, 1951 James married his second wife, Petrine Horstad, in Worthington, MN.

In high school, Donna was a member of the Future Homemakers of America and sang in the mixed chorus. In an interview during her senior year, she shared that her future plans were ‘to go college or be a nurse,’ and after graduating from Beresford High School in 1962 (there were only 52 kids in her graduating class!) she went on and earned her RN. Described by friends as ‘quiet and shy,’ Donna had blue eyes, was 5’4” tall, and had light brown hair that she dyed blonde and wore short and parted on the side. At the time she disappeared in the fall of 1970 she weighed 139 pounds, wore contact lenses, and wasn’t in a committed relationship; she wore size eight shoes and a size 13 dress. Donna didn’t smoke or imbibe in any drug use, and drank infrequently and very little. She was Roman Catholic and attended church every Sunday at St. Mary’s of the Pines. According to her sister Mary, she had perfect teeth and took excellent care of them. She had pierced ears, a white gold wrist watch with a ‘small chain’ and wore a ring on her right ring finger. Lass was reportedly saving for a trip to Europe she planned on taking in 1971.

In May of 1970 Donna had moved from 4122 Balboa Street in San Francisco to Stateline, Nevada, settling down in the South Lake Tahoe area. She previously worked as a nurse at the Letterman General Hospital in the Presidio Army Base (it’s worth mentioning that the base was north of the site where Zodiac victim Paul Stine was murdered). After relocating she briefly resided with friends Ann and Larry Lowe before getting her own place at the Monte Verde apartments; when she disappeared on September 6 she had only spent one night there. Mrs. Lowe worked with Donna from 1967 to 1969 in Santa Barbara but relocated to South Lake Tahoe with her husband, and it was her that encouraged Donna to move there. After Lass disappeared the young couple set their plans of moving and returning to college aside so they could stick around and help LE with the investigation.

In early September 1970 Lass had recently moved into her new apartment located on 3893 Pioneer Trail Road, which was just a three minute drive from her new POE. On June 6 she started her job as a nurse at the Sahara Tahoe Casino in South Lake Tahoe, Nevada (now called the Golden Nugget Lake Hotel & Casino). On September 5, 1970 Donna was scheduled to work an overnight shift at the first aid station  from 6:00 PM to 2:00 AM, although her last notation in the nursing log was right it was scheduled to end at 1:50 AM (I’ve see a lot of back and forth about the exact time, I’ve seen it vary from 1:15 to 1:50). A pen mark dragged from the last letter of the final word she wrote (which was ‘patient complains of’) and went all the way down to the bottom of the page. I did read on a Reddit comment that Donna’s sister Mary said that the handwriting didn’t belong to her. That entry was for a San Francisco resident named Joan Bentley, who was also the last confirmed person to see Donna alive (at approximately 1:15 AM). A Websleuths user suggested that the ‘drag mark of her pen indicates being grabbed from behind, by perhaps the person who tore out two pages of her notebook, which may have held his name, and then adding the name Joan Bentley.’ I think they were on the right track, however Joan was a real patient that LE spoke with. Ms. Bentley shared with them that she enjoyed making small talk with her pretty young nurse, who appeared to be in a good mood and was ‘very congenial.’ Donna shared with her that she was looking forward to skiing that upcoming winter and that she enjoyed her new job and had plans on staying there for a while.

After Donna left Mrs. Bentley she was never seen alive again, and reportedly no one ever saw her leave the Casino grounds. Her red, 1968 Chevrolet Camaro convertible was found undisturbed in its assigned parking spot at her apartment building, although it’s speculated that she walked to work that day, as it was just a 8-10 minute walk away. ​If Lass walked to work the night that she disappeared it was less likely that her left behind car would attract attention from concerned coworkers. Donna’s vehicle was completely paid for and it appeared that she had an impressive wardrobe and little to no debt. Her uniform was found stuffed in a bag in the nursing office and had mud all over it, and it’s speculated that she may have changed into a blue pants suit with white stripes and a rust colored raincoat. Does Donna changing out of her work outfit and into her street clothes hint at a planned meet-up with someone after her shift was over, maybe a date? Was it with the same person that would ultimately take her life? Since Lass was abducted at the end of her scheduled shift when she wouldn’t be missed as much, was this evidence that her abductor knew her routine and schedule? On a semi-related note, in a press release from the Douglas County Sheriff’s Department, in the weeks prior to Lass’ disappearance two female employees at the Sahara Tahoe were physically assaulted in the parking lot, although there were ultimately no connections established between the incidents.

Unfortunately police didn’t seem very interested in investigating Lass’ disappearance and her case wasn’t taken very seriously in its early stages. On September 25, 1970 Sargent Bezanson from the South Lake Tahoe PD reached out to her friend and former roommate/coworker from San Francisco Jo Ann Goettsch, who shared that she made plans with Lass to visit on September 7th but when she arrived was unable to get in contact with her. The friends made plans for Goettsch to meet up with Lass at her POE and from there she would follow her back to her new place. I should note, there does seem to be some uncertainty on the exact date Goettsch arrived: I’ve seen it reported as the 7th or 8th, but according to a PI report (more on that later) it’s the 7th so I’m going with that. After Donna vanished without a trace, multiple members of her family as well as her friends, acquaintances, and coworkers were interviewed and polygraphed, but unfortunately nothing of value was obtained. After she vanished Lass’ family flew in from Sioux Falls for a week to help look into her disappearance (her sister Mary stayed for two). According to her loved ones, Donna had a lot of friends and ‘would never just run off without telling someone.’

After searching a bit for Donna with another friend, Jo Ann eventually went spoke with one of her coworkers Victor Johnson, who was unable to provide much helpful information about her missing friend. The two stayed with him until around 4 AM, and he kept repeating over and over that he knew nothing about where Lass was or what happened to her. After no luck in finding her friend, Goettsch booked a motel room for that night and drove back to San Francisco the following day. After interviews with friends, family, and acquaintances of Johnson, investigators determined he had an ‘evasive manner,’ which left him as the individual they felt was most likely responsible for Lass’ disappearance as far as motive, opportunity, and reason were concerned. Despite multiple interviews and a polygraph examination, the suspect was never charged in relation to Donna’s disappearance.

Investigators spoke with Dorothy Cullison, who was employed at a local storefront called ‘Tahoe Paradise. She shared with them that she saw Lass the day after she was supposedly last seen on September 7th at roughly 3-4 in the afternoon. She was walking south on Pioneer Trail and was in the company of a young, clean shaven blonde man. Mrs. Cullison was unable to give LE any additional information regarding either individual, however she was insistent that the woman she saw was Donna Lass. She also claimed that they briefly spoke as well. If this is true, then Mrs. Cullison would be the last known person to see Lass alive. According to PI Miller’s report (again, more on that later), on October 21, 1970 the South Tahoe PD spoke with Joe Hershey from the Des Moines FBI office, who reported that he helped expedite a civilian stop order for Lass’ ‘file in Washington.’ Roughly a week later on October 27 a long distance call was made from LE to Jeremiah Murphy, a lawyer in Sioux Falls. Mr. Murphy shared that he was in contact with former FBI Director Herbert Hoover with the request that he help intervene on behalf of the Lass family in order to put the case more in the spotlight; no return call was ever received, however it does appear that Hoover did at one point attempt to help with her case (although I’m not exactly sure what he did).

On September 21, 1970 law enforcement contacted Tahoe National Bank, where Lass had an account and spoke with Clarise Chapman. Mrs. Chapman reported that they received no checks from Donna after September 1 and flagged her account for activity. She also had an account at the Bank of America in Tahoe, and there was no suspicious activity related to that one either (it was flagged as well). Additionally there was no suspicious activity before or after September 6, 1970 that had shown up on her credit card; her drivers license was flagged for activity as well.

George Victor Johnson, a security guard that worked with Donna during her final shift at the Casino, shared with investigators that he interacted with her on multiple occasions the evening she disappeared. Despite no criminal record, there is a notation in the private investigator’s report that he was ‘unstable and a heavy drinker, also not to be believed all the time.’ Another new acquaintance of Donna’s from the casino said that they were friendly and went out for drinks on occasion after work but she didn’t consider her a ‘close friend.’ The unidentified woman also shared that she saw Lass on September 9, 1970 when she went with Lass and another friend Dwight Stogsdale to take a third friend named Teke Holland to San Francisco to join the Army, but investigators determined that she had her dates incorrect and meant to say September 2nd. Additionally, two days before the friends went to San Francisco Lass was seen with two males that were employed at Barney’s Department store. Mrs. Tooker, who worked for the Lake Tahoe Ambulance company, looked into her log from September 6 to the 23rd and didn’t come across any reports of Jane Doe’s that matched Lass’ description.

The Lowe’s shared with law enforcement that the last time they saw Donna was on September 4, 1970 at around 11:30 PM. They also said that she was newly acquainted with a young man named ‘Dave’ that was employed at a local Chevron Station in Stateline. She reportedly went to see him a few times while on her way to work dressed in uniform, and that he went to her POE to visit with her on multiple occasions, but the pair never dated. The couple also volunteered that their friend dated a Maitre D named Ramon Vasuez that also worked at her POE. Apparently at one point during their time together the young man ‘went in for a kiss’ but was rejected; he did apologize to her the next day. Vascuas told investigators that he saw her ‘several times’ that Labor Day weekend but was ‘very busy at the time.’ He also said that he ‘never took her anywhere outside of their place of employment’ and his relationship with her didn’t go beyond a friendly occasional drink and conversation after their shift ended. Just as a side note, I was reading some comments from an interview posted on YouTube that an amateur true crime sleuth did with Larry Lowe, and some viewers pointed out that they felt his demeanor was suspicious and that he appeared to be visibly nervous. Although another commented that these were signs of Parkinson’s disease, so who knows? Lowe was looked into by LE but was eventually cleared.

Before she disappeared Lass briefly dated a writer from Keno, Oregon named Tony Chapman. When LE tracked him down Chapman shared with them that he never really ‘dated’ her but they did get together a few times to talk after she got out of work (on occasion they would end their night at around 5 AM). They went out on three different occasions but never even kissed. The last time he saw Donna was on September 2, when he and another friend named Vern Lauflin went out with her after work for about two hours.

There was a popular rumor floating around (and it was reported on by The Bee) that the day following Donna’s disappearance an unknown male made sinister telephone calls to her employer and landlord claiming that she had returned home to South Dakota due to a family illness (or emergency, I’ve seen it reported as both) and would ‘not be available.’ However, it was eventually determined that no such call was ever received by the landlord, and it cannot be confirmed nor denied whether or not a misleading call was ever received by her employer. Where this story originated from has yet to be identified, and there was no illness in the Lass family at that time. On page three of the Millers PI report there is a notation that a security guard named Gordon Petrovich at the Sahara received a call from a ‘Mr. Davis’ related to Lass. Petrovich claimed that he left a note on the security desk regarding the call; he did not recognize the voice and didn’t remember what time the call came in. When investigators searched Donna’s apartment it was tidy and undisturbed with no signs of a struggle, and there was a pile of neatly folded clothes on her bed, waiting to be put away.  The only unusual thing worth mentioning about the scene was there was a light left on in her bathroom. All of her personal belongings were left behind, including her purse, expensive clothing, and cosmetics bag. No fingerprint samples were taken from Donna’s apartment or vehicle.

A security guard that worked at the same casino as Lass filed a missing persons report for her three days after her disappearance. Less than a month after she disappeared on October 2, 1970 her sister Mary Pilker contacted a Private Investigator named John Miller to help look into her sister’s disappearance. According to the PI report, earlier in the day Lass disappeared she walked through her new apartment with both its old and new managers of the complex (a Nick Davis and Frank DeSimone, respectively) and completed a general move-in checklist. The two men reported her living space was neat and clean, with her bed made and her nurses hat on her dresser. On September 11 DeSimone went into her apartment and noticed it was in similar fashion to the first time he was there, and the only thing unusual was that the bathroom light was left on. After Donna disappeared Sargent Turker picked up her mail at the post office and gave it to Pilker, who drove her car back to California, taking with her Donna’s possessions from her apartment: ‘we drove her convertible home, packed all her things, and we were scared the whole way home.’ A few personal items that belonged to Donna were discovered in a shallow grave, but where that site was and what those items were I don’t know.

In September 1970 when Lass disappeared it looks like Bundy was employed as a delivery driver for Pedline Supply Company, a family owned medical supply company; he worked there from June 5, 1970 to December 31, 1971. In mid-1970, he re-enrolled in the undergraduate psychology program at the University of Washington and was living at the Rogers Rooming House on 12th Avenue. Additionally he was in the early stages of a long-term, committed relationship with Liz Kloepfer at this time, so he had a lot of established roots in the general Seattle area. Although attractive, Lass didn’t really fit Bundy’s typical victim profile: she had blonde hair that she wore short, which obviously doesn’t fit the whole ‘long brown hair parted down the middle’ narrative we are all familiar with (which I think it all just a coincidence and was simply a popular hairstyle in the 1970’s). She was also 25, which (although not entirely out of the question) is definitely on the older end of Bundy’s victims. Additionally, she was taken from her apartment that was in no way related to a college campus. But at the same time, we have to keep in mind that Donna was attractive and well educated, which we ALL know is absolutely Bundy’s type.

When analyzing the logistics of Bundy killing the pretty young nurse, the scene of the abduction was about 12 hours and 55 minutes away (or 764 miles, one way) from where he lived in Seattle… but let’s think about it, he had a lot on his plate at the time Donna disappeared, did he really have time to drive all the way to Nevada to commit a murder? Well, in this instance, it turns out he may have: although not on the ‘the FBI TB Multiagency Investigative Team Report 1992,’ according to Redditor ‘triddy6,’ Ted got a speeding ticket in Lake Tahoe a week before Lass was abducted. At first I was hesitant on believing this, because I could’t find it anywhere else, then I found the following in Rob Dielenbergs ‘Ted Bundy: A Visual Timeline,’ for the date August 20, 1970 ‘Jerry Thompson logged a call from Detective Pat O’Neil from the Sheriff’s Office in Sacramento, California on October 21, 1975. He informed Thompson that Mr. Bundy had a traffic citation on August 20, 1970 in Marin County, the Bay area, and he was driving an old white pick up truck. Liz stated that ‘he purchased a white Ford pick up truck he has presently in the SLC area around one year ago before he left for SLC.’ (Ira Beal report post Liz Kloepfer interview, September 17, 1975).’ So he was at least in the same area in the general time frame that she disappeared. A few entries down in the same text, on September 4, 1970 it’s reported Bundy returned home to Seattle with Liz after returning from vacation: they traveled all over the place, first to the Watastch Mountains in Utah, then to Ogden, then to Yakima, WA then Baker, Oregon then back to Ogden again. His whereabouts for September 6, 1970 seem to be unaccounted for. September is the most popular time of the year to go to Lake Tahoe, and it is a popular area that skiers flock to as well, and we know at least one of Bundy’s victims was abducted from a ski resort (Caryn Campbell on January 12, 1975 from The Wildwood Inn in Snowmass Village near Aspen). Playing devil’s advocate, we know he was an avid night person and had no problem driving long distances when looking for prey. As we know he didn’t mind traveling far to help throw police off his trail, and it didn’t hurt that he was aware that police agencies were reluctant to share information with each other. Was Donna just another one of Ted’s ‘murders of opportunity?’ It’s worth noting that not only do we have confirmed kills from Washington, Colorado, Utah, Oregon, Florida, and Idaho, I’ve also written about numerous other states he could have been active in as well (New Jersey, Arizona, and Vermont). I will say that September 1970 is definitely on the early side of when Ted may have started killing: he told psychologist Arthur Norman that he killed two girls in New Jersey in 1969 (most likely the Garden State Parkway Murders, Susan Perry and Elizabeth Davis), but when he was doing his death row confessions he told Dr. Keppel that he committed his first murders in 1972. Before his execution Bundy was never questioned about Lass’ disappearance.

It’s often wondered if Lass is the final victim of the Zodiac Killer, and she is included in the list of his potential 37 victims. Although I’ve seen that number as high as 48, law enforcement have only confirmed four attacks took place: five victims were killed and two survived. I mean, the Zodiac wasn’t known to abduct his victims, but he was known to contact LE to taunt and anonymously take responsibility for his crimes, as he wanted recognition for what he did. There was a possible link though to Donna and the very first majorly suspected Zodiac suspect: William Joseph Grant, who (like Ted Bundy) got a speeding ticket in his white Chevrolet at roughly the time Lass disappeared. Grant (who is referred to as ‘Andrew Todd Walker’ in Robert Graysmith’s true crime classic, Zodiac) was fifty-seven in September 1970, had glasses, and wore his dark hair combed into a pompadour. He served in the military from January 1942 through November 1945 and allegedly taught cryptography and received code training. Walker lived in Suisun, California and was employed as a real estate salesman in Fairfield. According to a report by the Solano County Sheriff’s Office, he was seen ‘hanging around the rest stop area on Hunters Hill engaging in homosexual activities.’ Sergeant Les Lundblad, who investigated the Zodiacs first confirmed ‘Lake Herman Road murders’ that occurred in the outskirts of Benicia, spoke with the suspect and noted his ‘hostile manner towards a CHP officer.’ Sergeant Lundblad reported Walker to authorities after he played a game of ‘cat and mouse’ with his vehicle on a freeway one evening. One-time California Highway Patrol Officer Lyndon Lafferty was the first to suspect Grant, and he later published his own book titled ‘The Zodiac Killer Cover-Up (aka The Silenced Badge).’

Another serial killer suggested in the strange disappearance of Donna Lass is Joseph James DeAngelo, who is also known as the Golden State Killer. Looking into DeAngelo it appears that he began ransacking homes in 1968 but he didn’t begin his murder spree until April 1974, plus he operated mostly in California’s Sacramento County, so Donna disappeared quite a bit before he started.

A popular name I saw thrown around in relation to the disappearance of Donna Lass was Richard Joseph Gaikowski. A newspaper editor at the time of the Zodiac murders in the late 1960’s, Gaikowski was initially considered a person of interest largely because of his training as a medic in the Army. This is because victim Paul Stine’s shirt was ripped, which was a common bandaging technique taught to medics in the military. In addition to this, Stine’s sister also remembers seeing him at her brother’s funeral. He also had a tendency to shorten his surname to ‘Gike’ or ‘Gyke,’ the latter of which was used in several Zodiac cyphers. Police dispatcher Nancy Slover, who the Zodiac spoke with after his attacks on Darlene Ferrin and Mike Mageau (Ferrin was killed but Mageau survived), claimed that the voice of Gaikowski matched that of the caller. Strangely rough, in 1971 Gaik was involuntarily committed to a psychiatric ward, and the Zodiac communications ceased for roughly three years. Redditor ‘AllyNC’ commented that he ‘had a widows peak, knew about codes, and had been questioned by police.’ Nothing official has ever linked Richard Gaikowski to Donna Lass’ disappearance.

On March 22, 1971, Paul Avery from the ‘San Francisco Chronicle’ received a postcard (with no postmark) from a person claiming to be the Zodiac and insinuated that Donna Lass was one of his victims (Avery was a well known reporter that frequently wrote about the murders). The postcard was an altered advertisement for ‘Forest Pines at Incline: Lake Tahoe’s Forest New Condominiums located in Include Village, Nevada.’ The correspondence contained five phrases glued onto the advertisement: 1. ‘Sierra Club’ 2. ‘Sought Victim 12’ 3. ‘Peek through the pines’ 4. ‘pass Lake Tahoe areas’ 5. ‘Around in the snow (pasted upside down).’ The meaning behind the messages have yet to be determined. It’s thought that it was designed and sent by the Zodiac sometime in between March 19 and March 21, 1971, and was mailed out either on March 22/23.

The Pines postcard never made any direct reference to Lass, and only hinted at a possible connection through the ‘Lake Tahoe’ and ‘Sierra Club’ references. If she was murdered by the Zodiac and this was set by him then the correspondence may hold an important hidden message… or, it may simply be a hoax. Additionally, if the postcards creator was in fact the Zodiac, then there’s always the possibility that he was a resident of the South Lake Tahoe area at the time of Lass’ abduction and that he was connected to her somehow or knew her in some way. The authenticity of the correspondence has divided the true crime community ever since it was received, but according to the creator of the website ‘zodiackiller.com,’ ‘in 1999 a retired detective revealed to me that a former Zodiac investigator had admitted to forging the Lass postcard.’ I want to point out that I only found this information in a single source, and there was nothing of substance to back that up. I mean, there’s so much back and forth with this case, who knows what’s truth and what’s fiction.

Donna’s sister Mary got a strange Christmas card on December 27, 1974 with the signature ‘Best Wishes, St. Donna and Guardian of the Pines.’ The card’s picture was an array of snowy pine trees on a beautiful winter’s day, and its postmark was 940, meaning it was mailed from San Mateo County or an adjacent section of Santa Clara County. Pilker immediately turned it over to law enforcement, and it was eventually determined to be a fake. It was a hoax sent from a couple who read about the Lass case, and had no connection to the Zodiac.  

Before she moved to Nevada Lass lived in the same area where the Zodiac operated out of, and even worked at a hospital in Presidio Park close to where their final (confirmed) victim Paul Stine was killed on October 11, 1969. Did he stalk Lass while she lived in San Francisco but maybe she moved away unexpectedly and prematurely, and he followed her to Nevada to finish what he started? I did read somewhere that if Donna was killed while employed on a military base then her case may have become Federal and would have been under a microscope even more. But on the flip side, there is always a chance that the Pines postcard wasn’t sent by the Zodiac, and was designed by a different assailant in an attempt to deflect attention away from the South Lake Tahoe region and towards the San Francisco Bay area where the Zodiac operated out of?

The search for Donna Lass would be negatively affected by the poor weather conditions in the months following her disappearance: South Lake Tahoe experienced record breaking amounts of snow in November and December 1970. From the onset, former South Lake Tahoe PD Chief Ray Lauritzen said that: ‘we don’t know where we’re going to begin. There’s a four or five foot pack of snow out there and it’s still snowing heavily.’ The Pines postcard made a reference to snow, in an almost sinister way by putting the phrase ‘around in the snow’ at ground level and upside down. By doing this, the creator may have hinted that Lass was buried under snow. A newspaper article stated that ‘the site depicted on the ‘Pines Card’ was from an advertisement published last Sunday by several newspapers. It was an artist’s rendition of houses among the trees at a Boise Cascade Company project at Incline Village, where construction has just begun on the development. While much of the Sierra area is under several feet of snow, Incline Village has only two feet on the ground. Police went to the area to determine if a search is possible.’ ​Chief Lauritzen added that ‘there’s no point to a search at this time. It’s unlikely a victim would be uncovered before spring.’

In his book ‘Zodiac,’ Robert Graysmith interviewed Jo Anne Goettsche, a former roommate of Donna Lass when she was living at 225 Malorca Way in San Francisco. They worked together at Letterman General Hospital at the Presidio Army Base, and lived together until June 1970 when Donna moved to South Lake Tahoe. Just as a side note, the ‘Presidio’ is close to where taxi driver and Zodiac victim Paul Stine was killed on October 11, 1969, and it was where a man that was strongly suspected to have been the Zodiac, was seen walking away immediately afterwards. Goettsche said that she and Donna used to go flying with two men from Riverside when they lived in San Francisco (a bit more on that later). There’s also a comment on a podcast about the Zodiac made by user ‘Sandy Betts’ that Lass ‘feared the dark, and would stay up all night gambling. Before walking home. But then we have the PI who said she walked home when it was dark.’ I didn’t listen to the podcast itself but this is the only source I’ve come across that mentions Donna gambling, but maybe it was fairly new behavior, as she had only recently begun working at a casino. Maybe she was just experimenting.

In August 2000 ​former detective Harvey Hines began to investigate the abduction of Donna Lass. Retired from the Groveland, California police force since 1992, Hines had an avid interest in the Zodiac case and has studied it since 1973. He even became friends with the Lass family, and along with Mary and Don Pilker (Donna’s nephew) became convinced the Zodiac was responsible for Donna’s disappearance. In an interview with The Tahoe Daily Tribune, Hines stated that ‘there was a lot of evidence inside Sahara Tahoe Casino that she left directly from there. She was a very personal person and she left a lot of personal items behind; an opened letter, a dirty uniform and on her log, a pen was dragged from the last word she wrote to the bottom of the page.’

Hines firmly believes that Lass was abducted from her place of employment right at shift change: according to her friends and colleagues, she was a conscientious and reliable worker and would never just take off. This coupled with the strange pen mark (and unusual handwriting) on the nursing log suggests that she was either physically assaulted here, or was possibly distracted and lured away with the ruse of needing help in the casino’s car park (where she was most likely abducted from). Despite the overwhelming evidence that suggests Lass walked to work the evening she disappeared and never left the Hotel on her own, many true crime fans strongly feel that she may have made her way back to her apartment in her Camaro, where her abductor was waiting for her. Or, maybe he followed her from the hotel to the Monte Verde apartments and attacked her there, or even en route. Hines strongly speculated that Lass was buried on the Donner Ski Ranch, which was actually searched after an anonymous tip was mailed in about a suspected dump site. Bomb sniffing and cadaver dogs were taken to Mount Diablo near Donner Canyon to comb the area, but came up with nothing. The following is from an unreleased, 120-page investigative report completed by Hines: ’after studying the card, I drove to Nordin, located on old Highway 40, north of Lake Tahoe, and found the SIERRA CLUB. I learned the club was not called the Sierra Club. It was named the Clair Tappaan Lodge and it was a private club for Sierra Club members only. I believed if I followed the directions on the postcard I would find Donna Lass’ grave. I believe she was buried near the Sierra Club and most likely on the Donner Ski Ranch. I would later have the pictures of the Sierra Club developed. Then using a copy of Zodiac’s card, I cut out the phrases he had pasted on his card. Using these phrases, I overpasted them on the copy of the Sierra Club picture. It was strikingly similar to the original card.’

On April 20, 1970, a cipher was sent to the San Francisco Chronicle that contained only 13 letters, widely known as the ‘My Name Is…Letter.’ Hines felt that he successfully solved it, revealing the name ‘Lawrence Kane.’ Looking into him, Kane worked with Donna at the Letterman General Hospital at the Presidio Army Base, and lived next to her in San Francisco. He was a known peeping Tom and was in the Navy. According to Redditor ‘MozartofCool,’ he moved to Nevada around the same time as Lass and even got a job at the same hotel that she was employed at. Hines also claimed that Kane sold Arizona real estate from an office located across the street from the apartment building where Donna lived. I couldn’t find any proof of any form of relationship between the two, but there is a theory that he became obsessed with her after seeing her when they worked together in California, and ‘grabbed her when he knew she would be alone.’ The former detective drew additional parallels to Kane and the Zodiac, including similar penmanship styles and physical appearance. A former military man, Kane suffered a traumatic brain injury in 1962 and as a result was diagnosed as being able to control his urges and related to ‘self-gratification.’ Nothing of substance ever linked him to the disappearance of Donna Lass. Zodiac killer or not, Kane was a career criminal, even going so far as to rob a bank at one point in his life. Reading through the Zodiac Reddit pages, it seems that he is one of the more heavily discussed suspects. An interesting tidbit about him: in 1992 suspected Zodiac victim Kathleen Johns picked his photo out of a line-up and identified him as the man who attempted to abduct her and her baby in March 1970.

In a YouTube video made by the creator ‘BlackBoxOnlineRadio,’ user ‘captainj1339’ mentioned a possible suspect of James Richard Curry. Curry was a rapist and serial killer that murdered either four or five people in California and Nevada from 1982 to 1983. A few days after he was arrested he hung himself in his cell. He was most famous for posthumously being Id’ed as the killer of Mary Silvani, who was formerly referred to as the Sheep Flats Jane Doe. Looking into him it does appear Lass’ disappearance took place quite a bit before he was active, as his earliest suspected murder took place in 1978. Another YouTube video discussed another potential Zodiac suspect I never heard of before named Don Harden. A school teacher by trade, Harden broke the Zodiacs first (and longest) cipher, the 408 code (sent on July 31, 1969). The code was split into three pieces of equal length: two were mailed to newspapers in San Francisco and one to a paper in nearby Vallejo. He demanded they be printed or he would go on a ‘kill rampage.’ I mean, most of the information I found related to Harden was related to the fact that he solved the cipher, and there’s just a few small niche groups of amateur Zodiac researchers that suspect he created the cipher and is also the best suspect. It doesn’t hurt that his wife Bettye was a graphologist. Yet another new name I came across is Joseph Stephen Holt, a murderer and suspected serial killer who in 2019 was posthumously linked via DNA to two murders committed in South Lake Tahoe that occurred between 1977 and 1979. He was a real estate agent and died in 2014 without ever being considered a suspect. Since he was identified, authorities have been investigating whether he could be responsible for more violent crimes that were committed in the state, including the disappearance of Donna Lass.

I came across another potential suspect one night scrolling through Facebook looking for anything additional I might have missed. A Facebooker named Randall Higgins claims that it was his father, Robert Melvin Higgins that was the Zodiac and the killer of Donna Lass. On his page he goes over a few reasons why he feels this is the case, it’s all mostly cipher related and how he feels they’re particular to his Dad and his life (I’ll include screenshots below), but in a different post he claims that his dad became a much kinder and more caring  person after he quit using amphetamines in 1980. Higgins also said that both of his parents were users of the prescription drug Thalidomide, which he felt might have contributed to his Dads altered mental state and what turned him into the Zodiac. He said his mother took the drug for 2-6 weeks when she was pregnant with him but his Dad took it anytime he could get his hands on it. Looking into it, Thalidomide is used to treat and prevent ‘erythema nodosum leprosum,’ a painful skin disease associated with leprosy and when paired with dexamethasone treats multiple myeloma. It works on the immune system and helps to reduce inflammation. So, I don’t really understand the need to take it with such urgency, it’s not a narcotic and won’t get you high. I was also able to find a TikTok video Mr. Higgins made where he broke down his rationale as to why he feels his dad was responsible for Lass’ death: apparently the weekend she disappeared in September 1970 he sat his entire family down and told them that he was going to Modesto to help take care of his adoptive parents, as his ‘father’ had recently been diagnosed with colon cancer. However Higgins suspected that his father never made it to Modesto and instead went to South Lake Tahoe and killed Donna Lass. He also said his father is DB Cooper so… I don’t know. At this time I’m taking this guy’s tale with a grain of salt.

On one of my final days of doing research, I came across a YouTube Channel of a PhD named ‘David Gold’ who claims to have found the body of Donna Lass in an unmarked grave on some uninhabited land in Lake Tahoe. Looking into this guy, he’s absolutely hellbent that the Zodiac killer is a Alcatraz escapee named Frank Morris as well as DB Cooper, the guy who hijacked a Boeing 727 aircraft on November 24, 1971 (but oddly enough, he isn’t the only person that feels this way). It appears policing agencies didn’t take his claims very seriously and never even looked into the site. The grave, decorated with an array of glued together rocks and pine cones, was obviously deemed not to be the final resting site of Lass, as it was recently announced that her remains were actually recovered in early 1986 (but more on that later). As of January 2024 there is nothing linking Morris or Cooper to the disappearance of Lass (or any other Zodiac murder).

One time Orange County Sheriff’s Inspector Stanley Parsons said that ‘if the Zodiac claims he killed the missing nurse at Lake Tahoe, and if in fact he did slay her, then there is a very good chance he also killed Miss. Hakari and Miss. Bennalack.’ About six months before Lass disappeared on March 7, 1970 23 year-old Judith Hakari had just finished her shift at the Sutter Memorial Hospital in Sacramento. It’s suspected she was abducted shortly after pulling into the parking lot of the Markston apartments where she lived at around 11:30 PM. The young RN had made plans to see her fiance, Raymond Willis, who was planning on meeting her at her home at around 11:45 PM. Willis waited for Hakari and became concerned when she didn’t show up. It was around 1:45 in the morning that he walked around the complex’s parking lot to check if her Mercury Cougar was there. It was, and after seeing it parked in its usual spot he immediately contacted the police. Upon investigating, Hakari’s vehicle showed signs of a struggle: the passenger’s side door was left open, her keys were found on the floorboard, and ripped up strips of a Cannon-brand towel were strewn all over the inside. Her remains were discovered roughly 40 miles from her apartment by hikers in a shallow grave near Ponderosa Way in Weimar on April 25, 1970. The pretty young nurse experienced an absolutely brutal death: her nose was smashed in repeatedly and her hyoid bone was fractured. Her jaw was broken in two places and she had several teeth knocked out. She had also been strangled and raped.

Twenty-seven year old Nancy Bennallack was found stabbed to death in her residence at the Tahitian Apartments on October 25, 1970. She lived just one block away from the Markston Apartments where Judith Hakari lived before she vanished. The attractive young court reporter lived alone in an upstairs apartment and was last seen alive by her fiance on October 25, 1970 at approximately 11:30 PM. When she didn’t come into work the next morning, her coworker called her son to check on her. The friend’s son explained the situation to Nancy’s apartment manager, who was sympathetic and gave him a spare key. After letting himself in, the young man came across a gruesome sight: Nancy had been brutally murdered and was stabbed so viciously that she was nearly decapitated. In 2021 advancements in genetic genealogy helped to identify Bennallack’s killer as Richard John Davis, who lived in the apartment building across from her. Sadly, Davis will never face justice because he died of an alcohol related illness on November 2, 1997.

On July 24, 1977, Brynn Rainey vanished after she was last seen at the Bittercreek Saloon in Stateline, Nevada. Originally from Ohio and employed at the Sahara Tahoe Casino, when the 27-year-old didn’t arrive at work for her usual shift the next day she was reported as missing. After walking through her apartment, investigators determined that there were no signs of a struggle and nothing had been stolen. Rainey was missing for slightly less than a month when a horseback rider found her remains in a shallow grave near a South Lake Tahoe horse riding area called Stateline Stables on August 20. From the small amount of forensic evidence investigators were able to gather from the scene, it was determined that she had been raped and then strangled to death. Less than two years later on June 30, 1979 Carol Andersen traveled from her parents house in Stateline to a party at Regan Beach, which was close to South Lake Tahoe. When her good time was over she declined a ride home from her friends, and it’s speculated that the 16-year-old most likely walked for a bit before eventually thumbing a ride from a passing motorist. The following morning, someone driving by the Pioneer Trail (which is where Donna Lass lived before she disappeared) came across her lifeless body; her killer made no effort to conceal her corpse. After her remains were sent for an autopsy in Sacramento, the coroner determined that she had been bound, gagged and strangled to death by her assailant. Although these murders happened near to where Lass had recently moved to there was nothing linking them to her disappearance.

A name that came up fairly frequently in my Lass research is Charles Hollingsworth, a doctor with a successful practice that lived in South Lake Tahoe. In fall 1970, Dr. Hollingsworth was recently divorced with two young daughters, and his marriage had recently fallen apart after years of infidelity. His ex-wife remarried, but he found himself alone and experiencing financial concerns; members of his family shared that they felt he may have had undiagnosed Manic Depression. On October 26, 1970, Charles left his practice after a disagreement and was never seen or heard from again. His vehicle was found abandoned in a desolate area 24 miles away from where he was last seen; inside it were several of his personal belongings, including a gun and his running shoes. It’s strongly speculated that his case is somehow related to the disappearance of Donna: at one time they may have worked together at Letterman Hospital when she was still living in San Francisco. Charles was also a known gambler, and it’s speculated that he spent a good amount of his spare time at the casino where Lass worked. As I mentioned earlier, the young RN enjoyed going flying with her friend Jo Ann, and Charles had his pilot’s license and owned his own plane (although there is no proof they were ever on an airplane together). Aside from this, they both worked in the medical field and Donna’s new apartment was less than a mile away from where Charles lived (she resided at 3893 Pioneer Trail and he lived at 3840 Pioneer Trail), there really isn’t anything substantial tying the two disappearances together.

In July 2007 the Sierra Sun reported that amateur Zodiac sleuth Clifton Calvez went to South Lake Tahoe PD and told them that he may have located the final resting place of Donna Lass using satellite imagery. After initially being dismissed because of the ‘Angora fires’ that were taking place at the time, Calvez said ‘screw it. I was fed up,’ and took off to check out the site on his own. He brought with him two disposal cameras he bought from a local pharmacy and a printout of the Google Earth map he used in his investigation. A retired colonel in the Air Force, Calvez admitted that he wouldn’t mind receiving the monetary reward for solving the Lass disappearance. According to the article, ‘as he ventured into the woods, Calvez said he saw a baboon and satyr etched into the bark of two trees. The baboon is the guardian referenced in the message to Lass’ sister in the Christmas card that read: ‘Best Wishes, St. Donna & Guardian of the Pine.’ After relentlessly contacting authorities and media representatives via phone calls and emails, investigators gave in, and went to check out the site with him. Retired Lieutenant Marty Hale with the South Lake Tahoe PD said investigators remained interested in what Calvez had to say and were ‘planning on seeing what leads we have there.’

After waiting around for about an hour waiting to get permission to dig from the California Tahoe Conservancy, they started digging. Investigators dug a good four feet into the ground looking for the remains of Lass but sadly found nothing (except for a pair of sunglasses). It was then that Calvez shared that he knew of a second possible site nearby where Lass could have been buried, but this also resulted in nothing. Investigators quickly called off search efforts. Using a house built in 1976 as a reference point, Calvez still believes the young RN is buried somewhere in the same general area, and: ‘I was disappointed, but even at this point I think that’s the place. Somewhere around that tree, no doubt about it.’

On December 31, 1985 a jawbone complete with all of its teeth was found by a fisherman in a drainage ditch as he was traveling towards Lake Valley Reservoir near the I-80 and Highway 20, near the Yuba Gap in Placer County. During a follow-up search of the area conducted by (retired) deputy Lowell Carleton in January 1986, the rest of the skull was discovered near where the mandible was found. No additional body parts or evidence were found at the time. After its discovery investigators kept the skull stored away, waiting for the day where forensic technology would be able to identify the remains. In recent years the sheriff’s office teamed up with the Placer County District Attorney’s office to form a cold case team, and they sent the skull to the California Department of Justice for genetic testing. In December 2023 it came back a match to Lass after a DNA profile was created in 2018 when Mary Pilker gave investigators a sample.

So what took so long for the skull to be identified as belonging to Donna? South Lake Tahoe Police Chief David Stevensen said that at that time it was found DNA evidence just wasn’t advanced enough to get a sample. Despite the positive ID, LE aren’t any closer to solving who it was that took the young nurse’s life, and didn’t share if they think foul play is suspected or how Lass died. South Lake Tahoe police are still actively investigating the case.

One interesting thing I came upon in my research is a comment in a YouTube video by the creator ‘BlackBoxOnlineRadio:’ user ‘colonelreb12014’ said that in an interview on the Peter Turner podcast with the Case Breakers, it was shared that Donna Lass reportedly dated and then dumped their Zodiac suspect Gary Poste’s brother. Some background: in October 2021, a team of cold case investigators calling themselves ‘The Case Breakers’ named US Air Force veteran Gary Francis Poste as the Zodiac killer. The video’s creator replied that he heard the same thing but had to wonder about the authenticity because the same group reported that victim Paul Stine owed Poste some money and that’s why he killed him. The creator said they were going to look into this further but I never saw anything additional from them about this. Despite their ‘discovery,’ the Zodiac investigation remains open to this day.

Interestingly enough, at one point Mary Pilker wondered if maybe Phillip Craig Garrido was responsible for her sister’s disappearance. Although Garrido infamously kidnapped Jaycee Lee Dugard in June 1991 (which is almost 21 years after Lass disappeared), he had an extensive criminal history that began well before then. A frequent drug user (primarily crystal meth and LSD), in 1972 he was charged with sexually assaulting a 14-year-old girl, but the case fell apart after she declined to testify. The following year, Garrido married his high school classmate Christine Murphy, but they later divorced after claims that he was abusive. Murphy also alleged that her husband kidnapped her when she attempted to leave him. While incarcerated at Leavenworth Prison in Kansas, Garrido met Nancy Bocanegra, who was there visiting her uncle, who was another prisoner. He and Bocanegra were married at Leavenworth on October 5, 1981. In 1976, Garrido kidnapped 25-year-old Katherine Callaway in South Lake Tahoe. He then drove her to a warehouse in Reno, Nevada where he brutally sexually assaulted her for five and a half hours. When a cop noticed an unusual vehicle parked outside the unit as well as a broken lock on the warehouse door, he knocked and was greeted by Garrido. The young woman then emerged and asked the officer for help. He was immediately taken into custody and was convicted of felonies in both federal and state courts.

In a 1976 court-ordered psychiatric evaluation, Garrido was diagnosed as a ‘sexual deviant and chronic drug abuser.’ A court appointed doctor recommended he undergo a neurological examination because of his chronic drug use, which may have been ‘responsible in part’ for his ‘mixed or multiple sexual deviations. During the examination, he shared that he enjoyed masturbateing in his vehicle on the side of elementary and high schools while watching young girls. The diagnostic tests came back that he had a: ‘normal neurological examination.’ On March 9, 1977 he was given a 50-year federal sentence on June 30, 1977, and was sent to Leavenworth Penitentiary; he was released only ten and a half years later on January 22, 1988. From there he was sent to Nevada State Prison, where he served only seven months of a five-years-to-life sentence and was granted federal parole on August 26, 1988. Upon his release, Garrido wore a GPS-enabled ankle bracelet and lived with his wife and elderly mother, who had dementia. In an interview with the ‘Reno Gazette Journal’ on April 5, 2014, Pilker said ‘as soon as I heard the Dugard case last week I thought that this could have something to do with my sisters disappearance.’ As of January 2024 nothing has ever officially linked Lass to Philip Garrido. He was apprehended along with his wife on August 26, 2009 and was sentenced to 431 years to life in prison. Nancy was sentenced to 36 years to life in prison.

Just as an interesting side note, according to true crime researcher Tom Voigt fingerprint comparisons were made in February 1989 after Bundy was executed which eliminated him as a person of interest in the Zodiac murders. I’ve seen whispers and rumors about Ted being a possible suspect in the slayings, which took place in 1968-1969… but I guess this confirms it.

Both of Lass’ parents have passed away, as well as the majority of her siblings. Mr. Lass died at the age of 75 on March 30, 1973 and Frances passed away on August 5, 1982; she lived in a nursing home for the last seven years of her life. Donna was listed as a survivor in her dads obituary but was listed as deceased in her mothers. Her brother Raymond died on July 18, 1988 at the age of 69. He was a Master sergeant in the US Marine Corps in World War II and is buried in Riverside, CA. Marjorie (Bellach) died at the age of 77 on July 31, 2006. She loved spending time with her daughters and enjoyed cooking, gardening, and babysitting her grandchildren. Eugene Lass died on March 5, 2014 at the age of 90. He worked in farming and trucking, and enjoyed being outdoors. Mary (Pilker) passed away at the age of 85 on November 17, 2019. Like Donna, she was a nurse and got married to her husband Zane on August 29, 1959. They had four children together before he passed away from cancer only five years later on December 29, 1964 (Mary’s life is especially tragic). Karen (Lounsbery) passed away on February 10, 2020 at the age of 77. After graduating from cosmetology school, she ran a salon out of their home for several years. She raised a family with her husband Gary, and everyone loved her snickerdoodles and pie.

Donna Lass’ freshman picture in the 1959 Beresford High School yearbook.
Donna Lass in a group photo for debate club in the 1960 Beresford High School yearbook.
Donna Lass in a group photo for ‘inexperienced debators’ from the 1960 Beresford High School yearbook.
Donna Lass’ junior picture in the 1961 Beresford High School yearbook.
Donna Lass in an officers picture for the Future Homemakers of America from the 1961 Beresford High School yearbook.
Donna Lass’ senior picture in the 1962 Beresford High School yearbook.
Donna Lass’ activities from her four years at Beresford High School from the 1962 yearbook.
Donna Ann Lass.
Donna Lass.
Donna Lass at the age of 25; photo taken in 1970.
Donna Lass.
Donna Lass.
A picture of Donna Lass using age progression technology.
An article about Donna Lass published by The Sacramento Bee on September 22, 1970.
An article about Donna Lass’ disappearance published by The Sacramento Bee on September 24, 1970.
An article about Donna Lass published by The San Francisco Examiner on September 26, 1970.
An article about the search for Donna Lass published by The Sacramento Bee on September 28, 1970.
An article about Donna Lass published by The Lead Daily Cal on October 6, 1970.
An article about Mary Pilker beginning the search for her sister published by The Argus-Leader on October 9, 1970.
An article about Mary Pilker continuing the search for her sister published by The Argus-Leader on October 17, 1970.
An article about a reward for Donna published by The Sacramento Bee on February 6, 1971.
An article about Donna Lass published by The Oakland Tribune on March 26, 1971.
An article about the Zodiac that mentions Donna published by The Times Standard on March 26, 1971.
An article about the Zodiac that mentions Donna published by The Bryan Times on March 26, 1971.
An article about Donna Lass published by The Napa Valley Register on March 26, 1971.
An article about Donna Lass published by The Bulletin on March 26, 1971.
Part one of an article mentioning Lass published by The Times Standard on March 27, 1971.
Part two of an article mentioning Lass published by The Times Standard on March 27, 1971.
An article about Donna Lass published by The Sacramento Bee on March 28, 1971.
An article mentioning Lass published by The San Francisco Examiner on July 18, 1971.
A blurb about a reward for information leading to the whereabouts of Donna Lass published by The San Francisco Examiner on February 17, 1972.
An article about the Zodiac that mentions Donna Lass published by The Peninsula Times Tribune on March 27, 1972.
An article about the Zodiac that mentions Donna Lass published by The Times-Advocate on March 28, 1972.
An article mentioning Donna Lass published by The Sacramento Bee on August 8, 1972.
An blurb pleading for information leading to the whereabouts of Donna Lass published by The San Francisco Examiner on August 17, 1972.
An article about the Zodiac that mentions Donna Lass published by The Sacramento Bee on April 26, 1975.
An blurb about a reward for the recovery of Donna Lass published by The San Francisco Examiner on August 31, 1975.
An article about the skeletal remains of Donna Lass being found published by The Press-Tribune on January 2, 1986.
An article about Donna Lass’ skull being recovered published by The Press-Tribune on January 23, 1986.
An article about Donna Lass published by The Modesto Bee on September 2, 2000.
An article mentioning Donna Lass published by The Los Angeles Times on September 2, 2000.
An article about Donna Lass published by The Sacramento Bee on November 16, 2000.
A missing persons poster for Donna Lass featuring information about the Zodiac. It was created by a friend of the Lass family in 1997 as an attempt to draw the killer out.
A press announcement regarding the identification of Donna Lass’ skull that was published by the city of South Lake Tahoe PD in late December 2023.
The Lass family’s ‘MyHeritage’ page.
A map of Lass’s POE compared to her new apartment.
The front of the ‘Pines’ Postcard sent to Paul Avery from the ‘San Francisco Chronicle’ on March 22, 1971.
The ‘Pines Postcard.’ The text on the card read: 1. ‘Sierra Club’ 2. ‘Sought Victim 12’ 3. ‘Peek through the pines’ 4. ‘pass Lake Tahoe areas’ 5. ‘Around in the snow (pasted upside down).’ The ‘Pines’ postcards that was sent to Paul Avery from the ‘San Francisco Chronicle.’ The postcard was produced by the Zodiac killer, according to the California Department of Criminal Identification. It was delivered to the San Francisco Chronicle, addressed to reporter Paul Avery. The cross and circle is the symbol used by the Zodiac and the assumption is tat he may have buried a 12th victim under the snow near Lake Tahoe.
The original, untouched advertisement.
The envelope for a letter to Donna’s sister Mary that was mailed in 1974.
A Christmas card sent to Mary Pilker that was mailed in 1974 that was a suspected correspondence from the Zodiac Killer.
A Zodiac cipher from June 26th 1970. where he claims 12 victims. It was sent to the San Francisco Chronicle and the cipher at the bottom was never decoded.
A breakdown of Lass related Zodiac information.
Donna Lass Code Solution.
The Monte Verde apartments.
The Monte Verde apartments.
The Monte Verdi apartments. Photo courtesy of ‘ZodiacKiller.’
The Monte Verdi apartments. Photo courtesy of ‘ZodiacKiller.’
The insides of a Monte Verde apartment.
South Lake Tahoe police officer Chuck Owens digs into earth where a Zodiac researcher believes Donna Lass was buried by the serial killer in 1970. The early July 2007 dig did not reveal any human remains. Photo taken on July 27, 2007 and is courtesy of Sierra Sun News Service.
Another picture from the 2007 dig site. Sierra Club stone cross.
A red,1968 Chevy Camaro much like the one Lass drove.
The Sahara Tahoe Hotel & Casino.
Bundy’s whereabouts in fall 1970 according to the ‘1992 FBI Bundy Multiagency Investigative Team Report 1992.’
Richard Joseph Gaikowski.
Lawrence Kane.
Joseph Stephen Holt.
James Richard Curry.
Donald Gene Harden.
An older picture of Zodiac suspect, Don Harden.
A photo of Robert Melvin Higgins and his family (he’s the adult male). Photo courtesy of Randall Higgins.
The first part of Higgins explanation as to why he feels his father is the Zodiac. Screenshots courtesy of Facebook.
The second part of Higgins explanation as to why he feels his father is the Zodiac. Screenshots courtesy of Facebook.
The third part of Higgins explanation as to why he feels his father is the Zodiac. Screenshots courtesy of Facebook.
James P. Lass’ WWI registration card.
The Lass family in the 1950 census. It looks like Donna was child number 7 of 8.
An Obituary for James P. Lass published in The Argus-Leader on March 31, 1973.
An advertisement for an auction regarding the estate of James Lass published in The Argus-Leader on September 9, 1973.
An Obituary for Frances Lass published in The Argus-Leader on August 8, 1982.
A birth announcement for Raymond Lass published in The Argus-Leader on March 21, 1919.
Donna’s sister Mary Pilker.
An obituary for Donna’s sister Mary Pilker published by The Argus-Leader on November 20, 2019.
Marjorie Marie (Lass) Bellach.
The wedding announcement for Marjorie published in The Argus-Leader on December 2, 1948.
Marjorie Marie (Lass) Bellach. She passed away in 2006.
Eugene Lass, who passed away in 2014.
Karen Katherine (Lass) Lounsbery. She passed away in 2020.
The one time speculated gravesite of Donna Lass, thanks to amateur Zodiac researcher David Gold. Looking into him, most of his material is nonsense.
The crucifix on the site where David Gold at one time speculated where Donna Lass’ remains were buried.
Judith Ann Hakari.
Nancy Marie Bennallack.
Brynn Rainey.
Carol Anderson.

Cynthia ‘Cindy’ Lee Mellin.

Cynthia ‘Cindy’ Lee Mellin was born on December 3, 1950 to Leonard and Ardis (nee Mauseth) Mellin in Hennepin, Minnesota. Mr. Mellin was born on November 1, 1912 in Minneapolis, Minnesota and Ardis was born on December 15, 1912 in Brooklyn Center, MN. The couple were married in 1934 and had five daughters (Paula, Cindy, Janice Mae, Judith Mae, and Maryann) and eventually settled down in Ventura, California; Mr. Mellin worked as an engineer and draftsman for VETCO Offshore Industries, Inc. After Cindy graduated from Ventura Senior High School in 1968 she went on to attend Ventura College as a full time student majoring in education. She dreamt of becoming a teacher one day, just like her older sister Judith that lived in Pico Rivera; she was planning on transferring to the University of California at Santa Barbara in 1971. Cindy didn’t smoke, drink, or do drugs, and even though she was described as a shy and reserved girl by most people that knew her, she was well liked by her peers and seemed to get along with everyone. Her family members, friends, coworkers, supervisors, and teachers all said that she was an exceptionally kind person and not at all the kind of young woman that would just up and run off. At the time Cindy disappeared in early 1970 she lived at her parents house located at 258 North Linda Vista Avenue in Ventura and worked as a part time sales clerk at The Broadway Department Store at the Buenaventura Shopping Center. She had blue eyes and light brown, shoulder-length hair that she typically wore tied back in a ponytail; she was approximately 5’6” tall, weighed 105 pounds and wore contact lenses.

On Tuesday, January 20, 1970, Cynthia Lee Mellin went to class like she did every day, and when she got home in the afternoon received a call from her employer asking if she’d be able to come into work at 5:30 PM. She agreed, and the 19-year-old arrived at her employer without incident; like always, she parked her vehicle in the back part of the parking lot along Main Street. Cindy left work shortly after closing at 9:42 PM and it was then she discovered her left rear tire was flat. She was last seen a few minutes later by two coworkers standing next to her cream blue, 1960 Rambler sedan; the vehicle’s rear bumper was up on a jack and there was an unidentified man there helping her. He drove a small, light-colored car and appeared to be about six feet tall; he was thin in stature, had light-colored hair and appeared to be between 30 and 40 years old. She was last seen wearing a red ribbon in her hair, a navy-blue dress with red buttons going down the front, a brown corduroy three-quarter length coat, medium-heeled blue and red shoes adorned with gold buckles, and a gold ring with a single pearl. The night she disappeared Cindy only had five or six dollars cash on her and didn’t have her purse with her (in an attempt to curb employee theft, The Broadway Department Store didn’t allow their employees to bring in purses or book bags so she had her personal belongings in a clear, plastic bag).

A security guard that was assisting Mellin in changing her tire had to leave and take care of an alarm that was going off thanks to the foggy weather conditions. At around 9:45 PM, two of her coworkers drove past her vehicle and saw her open her trunk, and it was then that a man ‘stepped out of the shadows’ and offered her help. The women had been picked up by their husbands, who also offered to help her with the tire but she waved them away, indicating that everything was fine. After getting a cup of coffee at a nearby restaurant they drove by the parking lot again at around 10:10 PM; this time, it was deserted except for Mellin’s car, which was still up on the jack. They would later tell investigators that they ‘didn’t think anything about it because we thought the man was Cindy’s father and that she was just taken home.’

When she worked the closing shift Cindy usually got home around 9:50 PM, and when she didn’t arrive by eleven her father simply thought she went out for coffee with friends and went to bed. He left the front light on like he always did when one of his girls was still out, and although she was out the night Cindy disappeared Mrs. Mellin said that she ‘never could rest until they were all home.’ The next morning at 4:45, Mr. Mellin woke up and immediately noticed that the porch light was still on and his daughter’s vehicle was not parked in the driveway. It was completely out of character for her to stay out all night, especially since she had a final in her biological sciences class later that morning at 8 AM (which was the first of her scheduled final exams).

Mr. Mellin then went to her bedroom and saw that Cindy’s bed was still made and had not been slept in, meaning she never came home from work the night before. Within minutes he was dressed and out the door. He immediately drove to the Buenaventura Shopping Center to look for her and came across an ominous site: the parking lot was completely empty except for her car, still up on the jack with the flat tire still on; the spare was lying nearby on the ground. He said that his daughter wouldn’t have been able to operate a jack and had no idea how to change a tire. He was always the person that she called when experiencing car problems, and just a week before he had to come to her aid in the same parking lot when her battery died. The vehicle’s glove compartment box, doors, and trunk were all left wide open, and when he examined the flat it seemed to have been deliberately punctured with a knife, and ‘there was a large slit in one side.’ There was no sign of his daughter at the scene, and he immediately notified law enforcement of the situation. Mr. Mellin immediately suspected foul play, and according to him, ‘Cindy would not go away willingly with anyone.’ He also said that she was ‘practically without problems,’ and ‘would never willingly hurt anyone.’ In the early part of the case, Lieutenant Howard Peek of the Ventura PD said that they ‘were drawing no conclusions at this time. They have a few clues, but we are appealing to anyone who might have seen the girl or who might have information concerning her to get in touch with us.’

From the early stages of the investigation law enforcement immediately suspected that Cindy was abducted and not a runaway. She wasn’t in a relationship or have any problems with anyone in her life. She had stable employment and was a full-time student. Additionally, when she disappeared Mellin was wearing her contacts, which were the ‘old-school,’ hard contacts that weren’t designed to be worn for extended periods of time. Furthermore, she left all of her cleaning and maintenance materials for them at home. Lieutenant Ken Cozzins of the Ventura Police Department said that the department had ‘no evidence or witnesses that Cindy was kidnapped, but because of her background we must suspect she was met with foul play.’ In the beginning, the Mellin’s held onto a glimmer of hope that she was safe, but as the days ticked by their hopes quickly faded. Mrs. Mellin said that they were ‘just in a state of distress, near the breaking point. We just don’t know what to think. It’s just a blank, similar to a nightmare.’ Leonard Mellin said his daughter has ‘never done anything like this before’ and there ‘has never been any family conflicts.’

According to LE, Mellin had no mental health concerns, financial issues, or problems at home, and had never ran away before. Both of her parents said that she was a better than average student that dated only occasionally, and she never really had a serious boyfriend. Cindy had a busy schedule throughout the month of January and letters from friends further proved that there was nothing out of the ordinary in her life. Her savings account was untouched and no money had been withdrawn from it recently. In the beginning of the investigation, Lieutenant Cozzins said that it was ‘still too early to speculate what happened to the teenager, but evidence indicates the girl was apparently kidnapped. But, we are thoroughly investigating every angle possible.’ Regarding her daughter’s disappearance, Mrs. Mellin said ‘we think that she didn’t go willingly. She has a habit of always locking the car even when she leaves it at home. It’s not like Cindy to go off and leave it unlocked.‘ Her father strongly felt that the man that appeared to be helping her change the tire was the same one that abducted her, and that he most likely caught her off guard, grabbed her, then pulled her into his waiting car and sped off. After Cindy was reported as missing investigators spent the next two days canvassing the area around the shopping mall, talking to hundreds of people that worked and lived in the area; they came up empty. Mr. Mellin said that he ‘knew if she were physically able to she would have contacted us. I guess I’ll just have to go back to work and get my mind off of it.’… ‘If she was kidnapped I have no doubts that she will attempt to escape. If she is physically able. The man may have been lurking nearby after puncturing Cindy’s tire with a knife and when she arrived portrayed himself as a Good Samaritan by starting to change the tire to allude suspicion.’ About the nature of the young woman’s disappearance, Lieutenant Cozzins said that ‘we have no physical evidence or witnesses that Cindy was kidnapped, but because of her background, we must suspect she met with foul play.’

It was no secret that Leonard Mellin was unhappy with the way law enforcement handled his daughter’s disappearance: from the very beginning he labeled the investigation a ‘costly misdirected amateurish farce.’ … ‘We have accepted the fact that Cindy is gone, and perhaps spared the trials and troubles of this world. We also know that nothing we can say or do will bring her back to us.’ He further attacked the Ventura PD, saying that their attempts to find his daughter the morning after she vanished under the supervision of (former) Chief David Gerty was ‘just plain appalling stupidity.’ However, Lieutenant Cozzins disagreed with his harsh statements, and said that his department tirelessly searched for Cindy and had ‘spent thousands of hours working on the case and have talked to at least 400 people during the year.’ He also said that the investigation took them as far as Florida and they searched throughout all of California as well as Washington and Oregon. Despite the fact that her body was never recovered, both of her parents strongly felt that she was abducted and ‘undoubtedly murdered.’ They also said that anyone that knew her personally or that made an ‘intelligent investigation of the circumstances regarding her disappearance’ would agree with them.

All of Mellin’s girlfriends that were interviewed by LE were in absolute disbelief and shock over her disappearance, and all said the same thing: that she was not the type of person that would just up and run away or just disappear. Although she was described as a quiet girl that mostly kept to herself, it is still possible that the man who abducted her may have been friendly with her. Maybe he was a customer from her POE that thought she was pretty? Or, perhaps it was an (older) male classmate from her college that stalked her and learned her pattern, routine, and vehicle. I wonder if maybe that’s why she so casually waved her two coworkers along when they offered her assistance? But, there’s also a pretty good chance that she was simply a victim of opportunity, and the perp noticed her park her car in the beginning of her work day, stabbed her tire, then waited around until her shift was over to offer her help and get her alone. One article published by the Fresno Bee in February 1970 mentions that Cindy’s uncle Stanley Mellin strongly suspected that his niece was being held captive in the general Fresno area and was kept subdued and under the influence of drugs. I’m not sure what exactly would make him think that, as there was nothing that would hint that it was a possibility (I also couldn’t find the article).

Police waived the typical 24 hour mandatory waiting period and began investigating the young students’ disappearance immediately. But by March 1970, the case was pretty much at a stand still. It was then that a janitor from Ventura College came forward and shared with LE that before she vanished he overheard the young coed say that she was planning a trip to Oregon. At roughly the same time the Klamath, OR police notified the Ventura PD that several residents of their city came forward claiming they saw a girl around town that matched Cindy’s description. A police bulletin with her photo was subsequently aired on Klamath Falls television stations, and the Star Free Press out of Ventura felt so strongly felt that Mellin was in Oregon that they sent her dad and a reporter on a one day trip to visit the area. While there, they talked to a general store clerk, a sales girl at a department store (both in Klamath Falls) and the owner of a small grocery store about 60 miles away that all said that they saw a girl that resembled Cindy. Unfortunately, the young mystery woman was not a recognizable local and didn’t appear to live in the area.

After this incident, the leads on Mellins disappearance were few and far between, but are as follows: (1) an Ojai priest claimed that he had learned that a woman had been attacked in an Oxnard, CA parking lot. The incident occurred on a Tuesday evening around 9:30 PM. The attacker had approached the woman from behind and attempted to drag her away. (2) Three youths in Fillmore, CA reported they saw Cindy driving a purple sports car in the general area. They thankfully thought to get its license plates, and the vehicle was registered to a sailor stationed near San Francisco. However, he had a daughter that matched Mellins description and she happened to be in the area at the time. (3) The August 1970 edition of The LA Free Press contained a cartoon of a young girl dancing, and the caption simply read, ‘Cindy Lee.’ Looking into it, investigators determined there was no connection between the drawing and the disappearance of Cindy Lee Mellin. (4) A woman had psychic visions of Mellin being held captive against her will in a desert house. She described an area in San Bernardino County; a check came up with nothing. (5) Investigators made a trip to the LA Morgue to look into an unidentified female, whose body was never successfully identified. (6) Police made a call to authorities in Florida after they recovered the body of yet another unidentified girl. It was determined not to be Mellin. (7) In mid-January 1971 it was reported that Cindy’s dental records were finally sent to the Contra Costa Sheriff’s Department in Northern California, who had found the body of yet another unidentified female. It was not Cindy Mellin (The Ventura County Star, January 21, 1971). After this, Cindy’s case quickly went cold, and she quickly became just one more name in a long line of young women that disappeared in California during the late 1960’s/early 70’s. We’ll most likely never know what happened to her. Paula Mellin-Stoddard said that the investigation ‘took us nowhere. Nothing ever seemed to pan out.’ The family was so desperate for answers that they contacted psychic medium Peter Hurkos, but sadly nothing came from that either. 

An article published by the Ventura County Star on February 2, 1970 mentioned that Mr. Mellin was offering a $15,700 reward for any information leading to the return of his daughter. To me, what’s interesting is the breakdown of the distribution; there was a $5,000 cash reward for information leading to the safe return of Cindy, $500 cash for information that would lead to the recovery of her body, and $200 cash for the positive ID or information leading to the identification of the man seen at the scene. That same reward was retracted on September 3, 1970 after the Mellins said they realized it was useless because the people with information often would not discuss it with police. Leonard Mellin retained a private investigator but they too were unable to produce any trace of Cindy. The family released a statement saying they wanted ‘to publicly thank the private citizens, both friends and strangers, who generously gave their assistance and sympathy. We believe that time will reveal the whereabouts of Cindy’s remains and that the perpetrator of this cruel slayings will eventually be uncovered when he repeats his crime elsewhere.’

At one time in the investigation investigators thought they had a prime suspect in a convicted rapist that lived near the shopping center where Cindy worked and was employed at two different places that Cindy was known to frequent. But, he denied any knowledge of her disappearance. There was another incident where LE thought Cindy was alive after a janitor at Ventura College said that several days before she disappeared he overheard her talking about taking a trip to Oregon. At roughly the same time police in Klamath Falls, OR got reports of people seeing a girl that resembled Cindy, but nothing ever came from it. Paula Mellin-Stoddard said that it ‘took us nowhere. nothing ever seemed to pan out.’ The family was so desperate for answers that they contacted psychic medium Peter Hurkos, but sadly nothing came from that either. 

Early in the investigation detectives talked to a man named Edward Nelson Cole, who matched the description given by Mellins two coworkers. Cole, who went by the alias ‘Sam Roper,’ was suspected by many members of Ventura LE to have been the man that helped Mellin change her tire the evening she disappeared, and that he most likely abducted then killed her. I’ve seen two different reports as to where he worked at the time Cindy disappeared in January 1970: the first said that he was employed at a nearby gas station. The second (and to me, more legitimate and well thought out option) reported that he had a job digging trenches and laying pipes along the southern CA highway; Ventura PD strongly suspect that Cole discarded Cindy’s body somewhere along the developing highway. In later years of the investigation, detectives had trouble locating his whereabouts, but according to a true crime researcher (and public domain websites), he died at the age of 69 on February 5, 2005 in Florida. That researcher was also able to locate the real ‘Sam Roper’ who lived in South Carolina, whose ID Cole had somehow managed to swipe. Strangely enough, Edward and the real Sam Roper shared the same birthday. Just as a weird side note, a young female neighbor of Cole was killed at a lake, and it looks like her murder was never solved. I also want to add, the Cole this other researcher talks about didn’t seem to have any connection to California, and mostly lived his entire life in Florida (I looked into him as well). I’m wondering if they found a different man named Edward Nelson Cole? Just a thought.

Also suspected in Mellins disappearance is a man named Mack Ray Edwards, a serial killer and child sex abuser. He molested and killed three children between 1953 and 1956, and three more in 1968 and 1969. Edwards later confessed that all of his crimes were motivated by a deep desire for sex. In 1970, Edwards and an 15-year-old unnamed male accomplice entered the home of Edgar Cohen of Sylmar, CA, where they kidnapped three sisters: Valerie (12), Cindy (13), and Jan (14) Cohen, who were one time neighbors of his. After forcing the girls to write a note for their parents saying that they were running away from home, Edwards and his accomplice drove the sisters to remote Bouquet Canyon in LA National Forest, north of Newhall,CA. Thankfully, two of the girls escaped, and knowing they could identify him he released the third. Shortly after, on March 6, 1970 he walked into a San Fernando Valley police station and turned himself into the LAPD Foothill Division. He gave detectives his loaded handgun and confessed that he had planned to molest and then kill all three girls. He also confessed to having killed six other children. Although he was sentenced to death, Edwards hung himself in his prison cell. It’s speculated he was responsible for Mellins disappearance but so far there is nothing concrete tying him to her.

At one point in the investigation detectives thought they had a good suspect in an unnamed convicted rapist that lived near the store where Mellin worked that was employed at two different places that she was known to frequent. But during a police interview he denied any knowledge of her disappearance and he was eventually cleared.

At the time Mellin disappeared in January 1970, Ted Bundy was living in Seattle at the Rogers Rooming house on 12th Avenue and was in the early stages of his long-term relationship with Elizabeth Kloepfer. At this time he wasn’t a student, as he re-enrolled at the University of Washington in June 1970. At the time, he was a file clerk and courier for an Attorney Messenger and Process Service’ in Seattle (he was there from September 1969 until May 1970, when he was fired for unjustified absences, as he claimed that he was baby-sitting Liz’s daughter, Molly).

According to Robert A. Dielenberg’s book, ‘Ted Bundy: A Visual Timeline,’ in 1970 Ted spent time at 1252 15th Avenue located just north of San Francisco in Marin County. At this time, the closest physical address this can be associated with is 1252 15th Avenue in San Francisco, across from the SF Botanical Gardens. There is also a dubious claim floating around the interwebs that says Bundy worked at Electro Vector in Forestville (which is just northeast of Santa Rosa in California) for a short period in 1970… although no dates or proof of this could be found anywhere and it’s not listed anywhere on the ‘TB Multiagency Report 1992.’ It’s also reported that Bundy helped Liz find a new apartment on Green Lake in 1970 and in the early part of the year, Kloepfer said that they spent a lot of their nights together (which makes sense as they were in the beginning stages of their relationship). I know some people may have immediately jumped to Ted’s signature tan VW Bug when they saw that Cindy’s possible abductor drove a ‘small, light colored car,’ but he didn’t purchase it until the spring of 1973.

Strangely enough, one of the other unconfirmed victims I wrote about from the same year was also abducted from California: Robin Ann Graham was an eighteen year old student at Pierce College when she vanished from a LA freeway in the early morning hours of November 15, 1970 after her car had broken down. At the time of her disappearance, Robin weighed 125 pounds, had long brown hair, brown eyes, and was 5’6″ tall. California Highway Patrol officers had noted Graham stranded beside her vehicle earlier in the evening before she disappeared and even stopped to check on her several times. When they drove by her the final time they didn’t stop, as they observed her talking to a young man driving a blue Corvette (that is now believed to have been responsible for her abduction). Although they were technically in compliance with 1970 protocol, after Graham’s disappearance CHP policy was officially changed to help ensure the safety of all stranded female motorists.

So, would Ted really have driven the 1,143 miles/8+ hour trip ONE WAY (which is the exact distance from the Rogers Rooming house to the Broadway Department Store in Ventura) to abduct Cindy Mellin on the evening of January 20, 1970? During Bundy’s death row confessions he told Dr. Robert Keppell that he committed his first murder in 1972. But I mean, I’ve written about unconfirmed victims that were murdered as early as 1961 (eight-year-old Ann Marie Burr in 1961 from Tacoma), and it’s no secret he was a compulsive liar, so obviously nothing he says can really be taken as 100% truth. In a separate event, when asked when he committed his first murder the serial killer refused to answer. He did admit to killing one woman in California, but they have not been identified.

In addition to Bundy, another name frequently thrown out there in relation to Mellin’s disappearance is the Zodiac Killer. It seems like any woman that disappeared out of a certain 50-75 mile radius in Northern California in the late 60’s/early 70’s is automatically classified as a possible victim of the Zodiac. A glaring difference between Mellin’s disappearance and those of Zodiac murders is that she remains missing, whereas Zodiac’s known victims were all found where he killed them. Also the serial killers only verified murder spree took place from 1968 to 1969, so the murder of Cindy Mellin occurred slightly outside of his activity date.

Aside from Robin Graham there’s quite a few other young women that disappeared from California during that same general time frame. Like Mellin, none of their cases have been solved, however the remains of some of the victims were eventually recovered throughout the Hollywood Hills. In the fall of 1968, two young women were walking down Telegraph Avenue in Berkeley when a man pulled up alongside them and asked if they needed a ride; they declined his offer. Early in the morning on May 29, 1969, 19-year-old Rose Tashman vanished just a few miles away from where Graham’s car was found abandoned. She was a student at San Fernando Valley State College and her car was later found abandoned with a flat left tire at around 2:00 AM; she was on her way home to Hollywood after leaving a friend’s house in Van Nuys. Her vehicle was found on the Hollywood Freeway off ramp and had flares set up around it. Her naked body was found dumped in a ravine near Mulholland Drive later that same day at around 6 PM; she was strangled and her throat was bound with wire.

On October 30, 1966 Cheri Jo Bates disappeared from the campus of Riverside City College in Riverside, CA where she was a student. The next morning at around 6:30 AM a groundskeeper discovered her remains on a gravel driveway close to the school’s library. The eighteen year old had been stabbed to death, and had wounds in her back, abdomen and chest; she had also been brutally beaten and stomped in the face, head, and feet. Bates throat had been cut so severely that she was nearly decapitated. About 100 yards away from where her body was found LE discovered her VW Bug, with its keys still in the ignition and three library books on the passenger’s seat; the cars ignition coil wire and distributor had been disabled. In the beginning of the investigation, Riverside LE wondered if maybe she was a victim of the Zodiac Killer after they noticed a number of similarities between the cases, but he was eventually cleared. Bates murder remains unsolved.

In November 1967, multiple Van Nuys,CA women were approached by a man following them and flashing their lights in an attempt to get them to pull over in a way similar to the potential abduction of Kathleen Johns. On March 22, 1970 at around 11:15 PM, Johns was driving west on Highway 132 when she observed a late-model, light colored car following her, blowing its horn and flashing its lights at her in an attempt to get her to pull over. The 22 year old was traveling with her 10-month-old daughter, and when she complied the man pulled over as well. He got out of his vehicle with a tire iron in his hand, and when he approached Johns’ said, ‘your rear wheel is wobbling. I’ll tighten the lugs.’ The young mother stayed in her car as the man fixed the tire, but when he told her she was good to go it came off as she attempted to back it up. When Johns got out to inspect the damage, she saw that there was only one bolt holding the tire in place  and it wasn’t long before the mystery man returned, this time with an offer to take her to a nearby service station. Johns hesitantly accepted, and got into the man’s car with her daughter, but instead of taking her for help he drove around on side roads for about an hour and a half. On several occasions when Johns asked if he was going to stop and get help he would ‘merely elude the question and start talking about something else.’ According to a police report at first the man was not threatening and friendly, but it wasn’t long before he grew menacing and threatened her life. When he finally slowed down for a stop sign she was finally able to open the car door and jump out with her daughter, and after he managed to close the door the suspect quickly sped off. Johns ran from her abductor and hid in a neighboring field. After enough time passed and she felt like he wasn’t going to return she was able to flag down a passing car, and from there she went to the police to file an incident report. At one point, she noticed a wanted poster on the station wall with a composite sketch of the Zodiac Killer on it, and said ‘that’s the man!’ Investigators later found her car incinerated near Byrd Road and Highway 132. In a letter dated July 24, 1970, the Zodiac claimed responsibility for this incident.

Another possible victim out of California that I wrote about disappeared almost a year to the day after Mellin vanished is Christine Marie Eastin, who went missing from Hayward on January 18, 1971. She left her home at 10 PM to get her loaner car washed and from there was supposed to pick up her ex-boyfriend at a local Jack in the Box, but never showed up. The 1969 Ford Maverick was found abandoned at a Charlie’s Car Wash with her purse locked inside. She hasn’t been seen or heard from since. In 2019 an unidentified eyewitness came forward and told investigators she saw two men in a white van abduct Christine from the car wash on the evening of January 18, 1971. The witness told LE that she was only able to get a good look at the driver because his accomplice was out of her line of vision as he was busy loading Eastin into the back of the van.

On February 4, 1972 12-year-old friends Maureen Louise Sterling and Yvonne Lisa Weber disappeared around 9 PM after visiting the Redwood Empire Ice Arena. The middle school students were last seen hitchhiking on Guerneville Road, northwest of Santa Rosa. Their bodies were recovered on December 28, 1972 thrown down a steep embankment approximately 66 feet off the east side of Franz Valley Road.  A single earring, some orange beads, and a 14-carat gold necklace with a cross were found at the scene. The girls cause of death could not be determined from the skeletal remains. A little over a month later on March 4, 1972 nineteen year old Kim Wendy Allen was given a ride by two men from her POE at Larkspur Natural Foods to San Rafael. They last saw her at approximately 5:20 PM hitchhiking to school near the northbound Bell Avenue entrance to Highway 10 carrying a large wooden soy barrel with red Chinese characters on it. Allens remains were found the next day down an embankment in Santa Rosa, about 20 feet off a creek bed near Enterprise Road. She was found bound at the ankles and wrists and was strangled to death with a cord. She had also been raped. All three of these young women are considered to be victims of the Santa Rosa Hitchhiker Killer.

On April 25, 1972 20-year-old Jeannette Kamahele was last seen leaving her residence by her roommate at 9:30 AM with plans to hitchhike to Santa Rosa Junior College, where she was a student. A friend was just about to pull over and pick her up, but someone else beat him to it. According to that eyewitness, she was picked up near the Cotati on-ramp of Highway 101 by a white male with an afro hairstyle that was between 20 and 30 years old driving a faded brown Chevrolet truck. Her body has never been recovered. Bundy was at one time a suspect in her disappearance but he has since been cleared. It’s also speculated that she could be a victim of the Zodiac, although it’s a bit outside of his time frame.

Just two days later on April 28, 1972 forty-three year old Ernestine Francis Terello was on her way to do some shopping at the Topanga Plaza Centre when her yellow 1969 Plymouth got a flat tire in Agoura; it was later found locked and abandoned near Agoura Road and Chesboro Road on the Ventura freeway. Terello’s husband reported her as missing later that same day. Her remains were found about a month later on May 27 by Boy Scouts hiking off the Pacific Coast Highway, roughly six miles from where her car was found. Because of the advanced stage of decomposition, medical examiners were unable to determine her exact cause of death, but it is strongly speculated that she was sexually assaulted before she was murdered.

Thirteen year old Lori Lee Kursa ran away from her family on November 11, 1972 after a shopping trip with her mother at a U-Save Market. She reportedly went to stay with friends, and was last seen on November 30, 1972. Kursa was a frequent runaway thanks to a poor home life, and her frozen remains were found on December 14, 1972 in a ravine approximately 50 feet off Calistoga Road in Santa Rosa. On February 6, 1973 fifteen year old Carolyn Nadine Davis ran away from her home outside Anderson, CA. She hitchhiked to her sister Judy’s house in Garberville, and didn’t officially disappear until July 15, 1973 after she was dropped off near the post office by her Grandma, who lived nearby. Davis was last seen hitchhiking later that same afternoon near the Highway 101 southbound ramp and was never seen alive again. In the winter of 1973, 23 year old Theresa Diane Smith Walsh decided to take a road trip, and hitchhiked her way through Santa Rosa and Malibu, visiting friends along the way. But Christmas was quickly approaching, and Walsh grew homesick for her family and decided to start making her way home to her husband and young son for the holidays. She was last seen on December 22, 1973 trying to thumb a ride near Zuma Beach. On December 28, 1973, some kayakers were taking advantage of some high water near the Mark West Creek north of Santa Rosa and came across her body floating in the water in between a boulder and a log. She had expired within the past day or two and she was found completely nude. Her thumbs had been bound together as well as her wrists, which had then been tied to her thighs; her ankles were bound together as well. In a final gesture of cruelty, Walsh’s murderer tied a piece of rope to her ankle bindings then ran it up her back and looped it about her neck, which pulled snug at her heels and against her buttocks. The pain of being tied up in such a severe manner must have been unbearable: stretching her legs out to help relieve the strain would have only tightened the noose around her neck, causing her to slowly and painfully choke herself to death. Theresa’s remains were found within about 100 yards of the fire trail where Lori Lee Kursa had been dumped a year prior.

Mona Jean Gallegos was a twenty-two year old part-time waitress when she was murdered in the early morning hours of June 19, 1975. She had gone over to a friend’s house that sold cars in Alhambra, CA to ask him a few questions about purchasing a ‘new’ (to her, anyways) vehicle; she left his house for home at around 1 AM. Sometime shortly after leaving, Gallegos ran out of gas near Santa Anita Avenue on the eastbound San Bernardino Freeway. Her vehicle was later found locked and abandoned by Highway Patrol at about 4:45 AM, who theorized that a passing motorist may have stopped and offered the young woman a ride to a nearby 24 hour service station, then abducted her. Her skeletal remains were found almost six months later by two teenage boys that were hiking in a remote Riverside ravine. Investigators were unable to pinpoint her exact cause of death due to advanced levels of decomposition but were able to determine that there was no trauma to the bones.

Additionally, the skeletal remains of a young white female was discovered on July 2, 1979 in a ravine off Calistoga Road, roughly 100 yards from where the body of Lori Lee Kursa was discovered seven years prior. One forensics expert that was consulted by authorities determined the victim was most likely killed between 1972 and 1974 and was about 19 years old. Their remains have yet to be identified.

One thing I’ve never come across before is a column from a newspaper dated February 1970, that asked people from a variety of different age ranges, genders, races, and backgrounds how they would approach finding Cindy Mellin, and the results were interesting. Candy Teffe, a fourteen year old ninth grader from Anacape Junior High School, said: ‘two things. Go where she was seen last, and then talk to her friends.’ Ventura College freshman Craig Gottlieb said that ‘there are certain things I would attempt to do but my belief is that she has helped herself disappear. I would find out who she has been associated with and why she’d have reasons for leaving home.’ Restaurant executive Bruce Derns suggested that LE should, ‘offer a sizable reward.’

One interesting article I found while conducting my research is a ghost story that took place at the former Broadway Department Store at the Buenaventura Shopping Center (that is now a Macy’s): a one time sales girl said the building was haunted by none other than Cindy Lee Mellin, and that she heard footsteps and humming on multiple occasions when the space was supposed to be empty. She also noticed that pieces of clothing would frequently move around on their own. I also came across a comment about the haunting by Facebook user Ed Mata, who was employed there as well in the 1980’s and ‘heard the story but didn’t think much of it till I experienced cold and noisy stock rooms and someone humming in the elevator.’

Judith Mellin-Williams said that her sister was ‘quiet, obedient, hard-working, spiritual, a downright goody-two shoes.’ In an article published by The Oxnard Star on January 20, 1995, Paula Mellin-Stoddard (who was only 15 when her older sister was abducted) said that her and Cindy were ‘the little girls in the family that dreamed of growing up, getting married, and having children together. I still feel her presence today, but she’s not there. She’s nothing more than a ghost.’ Judith also said she was a ‘late bloomer, extremely introverted, conservative and definitely not a boat rocker.’ Mellin-Stoddard also said that she considers her sister’s disappearance a painful mystery for her surviving family members, and that they were all haunted by their anger and anguish. Janice Mellin said in the same Oxnard Star article that ‘the only way we’ve been able to deal with it is to assume that she was murdered. But I’ll never be at peace without a body, funeral, or grave site to mourn.’

In an article published by The Oxnard Star on January 20, 1995, former Lieutenant Brad Talbot said that they ‘ran out of leads, people to talk to, and places to investigate.’ Regarding the perp, Talbot feels that ‘he might still be around. People sometimes get a guilty conscience and turn themselves in. We’d be willing to clear it all up.’ Oddly enough, later the same year Bundy was executed investigators received a tip that California inmate Gerald Stanely claimed he knew where Mellin’s body was buried. LE went to the San Quentin’s prison where Stanley was on death row to talk to him about the disappearance, but unfortunately the twice convicted killer had a habit of claiming to know about homicides he had no involvement in and was unable to provide anything useful to detectives. Cindy’s sister Janice said ‘it was just another lost hope.’ After her daughter disappeared Mrs. Mellin began volunteering three days a week at a ‘Head Start’ education program for her local school district, and sadly died on June 9, 1975 at the age of 62 from a stroke. Mr. Mellin remarried a woman named Marian E. Guild on February 19, 1977 but died just a few years later at the age of 68 on July 24, 1981. Cindy’s sister Judith died at the age of 42 on July 4, 1979, in Brea, CA, and Janice Mellin passed away at the age of 63 on July 8, 2001. If Cindy was still alive in December 2023 she would be 74 years old. Her dental charts are available and were entered into the national database; her DNA is also on file.

A picture of Mellin from a newspaper article.
A picture of Cindy Mellin taken from The Napa Valley Register published on June 30, 1970.
A picture of Cindy Mellin taken from the Ventura County Star published on March 14, 1970.
Cindy Lee Mellin.
Cindy Lee Mellin’s sophomore year picture from the 1966 Ventura Senior High School yearbook.
Cindy Lee Mellin’s junior year picture from the 1967 Ventura Senior High School yearbook.
Cindy Lee Mellin in a group picture for the ‘Cougar Howlers’ from the 1967 Ventura Senior High School yearbook.
Cindy Lee Mellin in a group picture for the ‘ushers’ from the 1967 Ventura Senior High School yearbook.
Cindy Lee Mellin’s senior year picture from the 1968 Ventura Senior High School yearbook.
Mellin in a group picture for Modern Dance club from the 1968 Ventura Senior High School yearbook.
Cindy Lee Mellin in a group picture for the ‘ushers’ from the 1968 Ventura Senior High School yearbook.
A picture of Cindy published by The Ventura County Star on January 23, 1970,
Cindy listed in a directory from the Ojai, California City Directory in 1970.
A missing persons flier for Mellin that contains a lot of interesting and helpful details about the case.
Despire no remains ever being recoverd, the Mellins strnogly felt tat Cindu was abducted and 'undoubablted murdered. Everyone who knew her personally or has
The Mellin family’s home located at 258 North Linda Vista Avenue in Ventura, CA.
A missing persons flyer for Cindy, courtesy of the King County Sheriff’s Department in Seattle.
A letter from Cindy’s father to the law enforcement dated November 6,. 1972, courtesy of the King County Sheriff’s Department.
A letter from Cindy’s father to the Seattle Chief of Police dated September 3, 1974, courtesy of the King County Sheriff’s Department.
An envelope from a letter that Cindy’s father wrote to the Seattle Chief of Police, courtesy of the King County Sheriff’s Department.
The Broadway Department Store from an article published by The Ventura County Star-Free Press on April 5, 1963.
The Broadway Department store (located at 477 South Mills Road) where Cindy Lee Mellin worked as a sales clerk in Ventura, CA.
How ‘The Broadway’ looks today.
An article I found on Mellin on WebSleuths; I couldn’t find any information related to it’s publication.
An article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on January 22, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Press-Courier on January 22, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Valley Times on January 23, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Press-Courier on January 23, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on January 23, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Los Angeles Times on January 23, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Press-Courier on January 24, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Press-Courier on January 24, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Press-Courier on January 25, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Thousand Oaks Star on January 25, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on January 27, 1970.
She wanted to be a teacher like her older sister, that lived in Pico Rivera. The MEllisn called aroud the Cindy's frieds and none of them knew where she could be.
An article about Mellin published by The Press-Courier on January 27, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Press-Courier on January 28, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on January 28, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on January 29, 1970.
An article about a reward for any information leading to the return of Cindy Lee Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on February 2, 1970.
An short blurb about Mellin’s disappearance published by The Ventura County Star on February 4, 1970.
The picture from an article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on February 18, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on February 18, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on February 19, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on February 20, 1970.
An article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on February 21, 1970.
A blurb mentioning Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on February 22, 1970.
Part one of an article published by The Ventura County Star on March 14, 1970.
Part two of an article published by The Ventura County Star on March 14, 1970.
Part one of an article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on March 15, 1970.
Part two of an article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on March 15, 1970.
An article about Cindy Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on March 19, 1970.
A portion of an article about Cindy Mellin written by Rick Nielsen published on June 21, 1970.
An article about Cindy Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on June 25, 1970.
An article about Cindy Mellin published by The Napa Valley Register on June 30, 1970.
An article about Cindy Mellin published by The Santa Cruz Sentinel on July 1, 1970.
An newspaper clipping about Cindy Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on July 25, 1970.
An article about Cindy Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on September 3, 1970.
Mellin mentioned from ‘a year in review’ published by The Press-Courier on January 1, 1971.
An article about Cindy Mellin published by The Press-Courier on January 20, 1971.
Part one of an article about Mellin being gone for a year published by The Ventura County Star on January 21, 1971.
Part two of an article about Mellin being gone for a year published by The Ventura County Star on January 21, 1971.
Part three of an article about Mellin being gone for a year published by The Ventura County Star on January 21, 1971.
An opinion piece about how Mr. Mellin handles his daughters disappearance published by The Press-Courier on January 28, 1971.
An article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on November 21, 1971.
An ‘in-memorium’ piece for Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on January 16, 1972.
An article about Mellin being gone for three years published by The Ventura County Star on January 21, 1973.
An article mentioning Cindy Lee published by The Thousand Oaks Star on February 23, 1973.
An article about Cindy Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on January 20, 1974.
An ‘in-memorium’ piece for Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on January 20, 1974.
Part one of an article about Cindy Mellin published by The Thousand Oaks Star on February 26, 1976.
Part two of an article about Cindy Mellin published by The Thousand Oaks Star on February 26, 1976.
An article about Leonard Mellin petitioning for his daughters appointed administrator of estate published by The Ventura County Star on May 12, 1977.
An article about Cindy Lee Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on February 21, 1986.
An article about Mellin published by The Record Searchlight on February 11, 1989.
An article about Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on March 9, 1989.
Part one of an article about Mellin published by The Oxnard Star on January 20, 1995.
Part two of an article about Mellin published by The Camarillo St on February 20, 1995.
A 1960 cream blue, four door Rambler similar to the one Mellin drove.
The Mellin’s in the 1950 census.
An article about the Mellin family house being robbed published by Press-Courier on August .17, 1966
Leonard Mellin’s WW2 draft card.
Judith Williams- Mellin was born on July, 18 1936 in Hennepin, Minnesota; she married Robert Williams on June 22, 1963. She died on July 4, 1979.
An obituary for Mrs. Mellin published by The Ventura County Star on June 15, 1975.
One possible route Bundy could have take from the Rogers Rooming house in Seattle to The Broadway in Ventura, CA.
Bundy’s whereabouts in 1970 according to the’TB Multiagency Investigative Team Report 1992.’
Bundy’s whereabouts in 1970 according to the ‘TB Multiagency Investigative Team Report 1992.’
Robin Ann Graham.
Rose Tashman.
Cheri Jo Bates.
Kathleen Johns.
Christine Marie Eastin.
Maureen Louise Sterling.
Yvonne Lisa Weber.
Kim Wendy Allen.
Jeannette Kamahele.
An article about Ernestine Francis Terello.
Lori Lee Kursa.
Carolyn Nadine Davis.
Theresa Diane Smith Walsh.
Mona Jean Gallegos.

A composite sketch of the Zodiac Killer.
In an article oublished by
Mack Ray Edwards, who hung himself in his prison cell after receiving a life sentence on October 30, 1971.
Gerald Frank Stanley, who was born in 1945 and is an American murderer and suspected serial killer. Stanley killed his fourth wife, Cindy in August 1980, after completing a four-year prison term for murdering his second wife, Kathleen in 1975. He is also suspected in the disappearance of his third wife, Diana Lynn.
A comment on an article written about Mellin by a blogger by the handle ‘True Crime Guy.’ Taken from truecrimeguy.com/vulnerable-ventura-case-cindy-lee-mellin.
Another comment on an article written about Mellin by a blogger by the handle ‘True Crime Guy.’
Another comment on an article written about Mellin by a blogger by the handle ‘True Crime Guy.’
Another comment on an article written about Mellin by a blogger by the handle ‘True Crime Guy.’

Rhonda Karol Stapley.

Rhonda Stapley was born on August 19, 1953 to Rulon and Vivian Stapley in Richfield, Utah. Rulon (who seemed to go by his middle name of Floyd) was born on July 22, 1928 in Joseph, UT and Vivian was born on October 19, 1933 in Austin, UT. The couple were wed on April 11, 1948, in Coconino, Arizona and eventually settled down in the Salt Lake City area. Together they had 4 children: two boys (Rulon Dale and Michael John) and two girls (Rhonda Karol and Bonita Rae). Mr. Stapley worked as an operator of a frozen food company but passed away in a plane crash on October 3, 1967 at the age of 39. Vivian had a variety of jobs in her life, and was employed as a school lunch lady, in fast food and retail stores. She remarried Stanley Redfern in 1978 and passed away at the age of 87 on October 7, 2021. The Stapley family apparently had a small-scale ‘claim to fame’ after developing a couple patents for some potato products. Rhonda graduated from Connell High school in 1971 and went on to attend the University of Utah. After completing her degree in pharmacy, the petite 4’11” brunette married Barry Robert Godding on (either) April 23/24, 1979 in SLC (according to Ancestry). In the acknowledgments portion of her book she mentions she has ‘daughters’ but doesn’t elaborate any further .

On an unusually warm and sunny day in October 1974 Rhonda Stapley was waiting for the bus to pick her up to take her back to her dormitory when a young man in a light colored VW Bug pulled up and asked if she’d like a ride: ‘just as it passed me, it stopped and he put it in reverse and backed up. He rolled down the passenger window and he says, ‘Hey where are you going?’’ When she replied ‘the University of Utah,’ he told her that’s where he was headed as well and asked if she’d like a ride, which she happily accepted. The shy young college student had been at the dentist and her mouth was still sore from the extensive work she had just had done. He introduced himself as Ted and told her he was a first year law student. Stapley immediately noticed his striking blue eyes and told him that she was close to being done with a degree in pharmacy. In an interview for the documentary ‘Ted Bundy: The Survivors,’ she shared that it ‘didn’t feel like hitchhiking, what I did. This felt like a friendly college student helping another college student, and that seemed normal and not out of place.’ But, it didn’t take long before Rhonda realized that the handsome stranger wasn’t taking the normal route back to school. When she asked him about it he politely inquired if it would be okay if he just ran a quick errand up by the zoo, to which she said no, she didn’t. But when the zoo came and went, Rhonda quickly became concerned again, to which the man simply told her that the errand wasn’t AT the zoo but near it. And that’s when things began to get extremely uncomfortable for her: ‘the ride started to become strained, he stopped talking to me altogether, he just had both hands on the steering wheel just driving.’ Desperate to escape, when Stapley reached for the door handle she realized it was missing, and that’s when she REALLY began to panic.

At around 3-3:30 PM, the young man eventually reached Big Cottonwood Canyon and ‘suddenly he pulled over. It seemed like he was looking for a place to park. At this point I did not expect a murder attempt, I was more anticipating an attempt at a romantic parking episode, and I wasn’t afraid of that either, just not interested, and wanting to get out of that potential situation without embarrassing either of us. I still thought he was a nice and somewhat charming guy right up to the moment.’ … ‘He turned a way that wasn’t the normal route to the university. You could get there that way, but it wasn’t the normal route and I questioned him about that. I said, ‘Where are we going?’And that was when the ride started to become strange. He just had both hands firmly on the steering wheel and was just driving.’

After finding a secluded spot off the beaten track, Stapley’s abductor stopped the car and turned to face her directly. The naive young Mormon woman was certain he was going to make a move on her and lean in for a kiss: ‘in my mind, I think he’s looking for a place to pull over and park and make out.’ The thought of such casual intimacy with a complete stranger was something she wasn’t comfortable with, not only because of her devout faith but also her sore mouth. However instead of a smooch he looked at her, his bright blue eyes now black, and said completely without emotion: ‘I am going to kill you.’ … ‘Then he puts his hands ’round my throat and starts squeezing and shaking me, and I’m thinking, ‘Why? Why does he want to kill someone and why is it me?’’ After dragging her out of his VW, Rhonda’s captor proceeded to physically and sexually assault her for hours in the public canyon near a picnic table. During the assault he choked her out, repeatedly taking her to the brink of consciousness then stopping; he even slapped her across the face to wake her up. Stapley also claims that he bit her on the right breast and would yell at her, ‘you should be thanking me that you are even still alive. I can kill you anytime I want.’ She said that: ‘he was angry, more angry than I’ve ever seen anybody. His fists were clenched and his veins were bulging on his forehead and his neck, and his face was bright red. His eyes were almost black.’ Interesting fact about the bite: Rhonda said the marking reappeared roughly forty years later (which immediately made me think of the stigmata markings on Christ during his crucifixion).

When his back was briefly turned and he was ‘distracted by something near his car,’ Stapley was able to escape her captor by jumping into a ‘fast moving mountain river’ and floating to safety: ‘As soon as I jumped up and started to run, I fell into a fast-moving mountain stream, which is probably what saved my life.’ When she got far enough away (I got the impression she was at one point unconscious while in the stream and woke up land), she managed to get herself out of the water then walked the roughly ten miles back to the University of Utah. She traveled mostly through the woods, petrified that her attacker would find her if she walked along the main roadway. She credited her new boots as one of the main reasons she was able to make the long walk back, and on the CrimePiper website, user ‘Fra La’ commented that ‘she has added yet another reason why she was on foot, she had new hiking boots to break in. New details cropping up all the time, lol. Too many details.’ To this, site creator (and good friend of mine) Erin Banks replied: ‘convenient plot twist to explain why she still had her pants on when she walked back home for 6-7 hours. The boots were a brilliant idea, I’ll give her that (when Stapley jumped in the running water she claimed that her pants were still around her ankles).’ After her long journey back to the University of Utah, Rhonda took a long, hot shower then assessed her injuries: she had bruising on her face, a large ‘goose-egg’ over her eye, bruises and markings all over her body (but especially around the neck), and a few broken ribs. Somehow, no one ever questioned her about any of it, including her friends, roommates, and professors, who all saw her routinely after the incident. Despite the headlines she saw that reported other women from the Salt Lake area were vanishing at an alarming rate, Stapley kept the incident to herself and didn’t come forward with her story until 2016.

Because Rhonda left some of her personal belongings (including her drivers license) behind in her abductor’s car, she was afraid that he would somehow eventually track her down. But, thankfully she never updated the DMV with her new mailing address after she moved so he couldn’t locate her through her ID. The identity of her attacker remained a mystery until roughly a year after her assault, when she saw his face in a newspaper in August 1975 when it was reported that a local law student was arrested for the unsuccessful kidnapping of Carol DaRonch. After Bundy (who she referred to as ‘her bad guy’) was finally caught, Stapley said that his arrest brought not only relief but also a ‘wave of guilt. It was another proof that it was him. ‘That’s the guy.’ Maybe I should have done something about it.’ She rationalized her decision of not going to LE because other women had since reported him and she felt that she had nothing else of value to add. She also feared unwanted attention from those who wondered why she didn’t report the incident to police earlier.

Fearing that if her mother found out she had been assaulted she’d make her dropout of school and return home, Stapley blamed herself for accepting a ride from a stranger. Also, at the time of her abduction she was a virgin as well as a devout Mormon, and didn’t want people to think poorly or less of her if they knew she was no longer pure: ‘the teachings in the LDS church at that time was that your virtue and your chastity were the most important thing a young woman could have, and if you come to a point giving up your chastity or your life, you’re better off eternally if you die.’ … ‘I felt ashamed and embarrassed and stupid; stupid for even getting into such a dangerous situation.’ … ‘I imagined people whispering, ‘that’s that girl who was raped.’ I didn’t want attention. I still don’t.’

When enough time passed and Stapley was finally ready to date again, she left little notes all over her (shared) apartment (including underneath garbage cans) sharing where she was and who she was with. She hoped that if she ever went missing again her roommates (or the police) would eventually find them and because of them they would be able to locate her. That I do think is a little weird: were they not friendly? I have friends who are devoutly religious and they still talk openly about dating and men. It’s not forbidden, why all the secrets and weird notes? And what if the garbage can got dirty and they needed to clean it? Ever have a bag of trash leak garbage juice all over the can? It’s not pretty… personally, I would have most likely hosed it off… So what’s to say the note would have even been found?

Could you imagine how many lives Stapley could have saved if she came forward immediately after she was attacked? I stopped commenting on Facebook posts of people talking about how it was her ‘faith that forced her to keep her mouth shut and she was embarrassed and ashamed.’ I’m sorry, I just don’t buy that. Being sexually assaulted was completely out of her control, and if she went to the police right after it happened maybe Bundy would have been caught sooner, which would have prevented some of his Utah and Colorado killings as well as everything in Florida. When asked why she didn’t go to police earlier she told People magazine: ‘I thought that I just needed to put it away and make life like it was before and just pretend it never happened.’

Rhonda kept the assault to herself until 2011, when a supervisor at her POE using the same type of threatening language as Bundy did put her in an uncomfortable situation, which forced the memories of her assault to immediately come rushing back to her. The nightmares and flashbacks finally forced her to seek help: ‘I couldn’t control my tears, I couldn’t sleep, I couldn’t eat. I thought I was going crazy. But I knew it had to be related to the Bundy stuff, because that’s what my dreams and my nightmares and my panic attacks were about.’ Stapley sought mental health therapy, and like many other Americans turned to the internet for help. After an anonymous online friend shared a run-in with the serial killer she was finally able to gather the strength and tell loved ones what happened to her after almost 37 years: ‘there’s no group of Ted Bundy survivors that I could sign up and join. But there are other people who have experienced trauma. They can understand not wanting to tell, and the shame and embarrassment and all those things that go along with rape. The main thing I wanted to tell people was that they’re not alone. Even though their traumatic experience may be different than my traumatic experience, at least there’s someone who can recognize those feelings and people who can understand.’ Looking into it, Rhonda publicly came forward with her story in the spring of 2016: I see she did an interview with Dr. Phil on April 26, 2016 and published her book ‘I Survived Ted Bundy: The Attack, Escape & PTSD that Changed My Life’ (complete with forward by Bundy bff Ann Rule) on May 5, 2016. She also did an interview with People magazine roughly a week later on May 13, 2016.

Rhonda kept the assault to herself until 2011, when a supervisor using the same type of threatening language that Bundy used put her in an uncomfortable situation, forcing her past to immediately come back to haunt her. The nightmares and flashbacks finally forced Stapley to seek help: ‘I couldn’t control my tears, I couldn’t sleep, I couldn’t eat. I thought I was going crazy. But I knew it had to be related to the Bundy stuff, because that’s what my dreams and my nightmares and my panic attacks were about.’ She sought mental health therapy, and like most other Americans, turned to the internet for help. After an anonymous friend shared a run-in with the serial killer, Stapley was finally able to tell loved ones her story after almost 37 years: ‘there’s no group of Ted Bundy survivors that I could sign up and join. But there are other people who have experienced trauma. They can understand not wanting to tell, and the shame and embarrassment and all those things that go along with rape. The main thing I wanted to tell people was that they’re not alone. Even though their traumatic experience may be different than my traumatic experience, at least there’s someone who can recognize those feelings and people who can understand.’ Looking into it, she publicly came forward with her story in the spring of 2016: I see she did an interview with Dr. Phil on April 26, 2016 and published her book ‘I Survived Ted Bundy: The Attack, Escape & PTSD that Changed My Life’ (complete with forward by Bundy bff Ann Rule) on May 5, 2016. She also did an interview with People magazine roughly a week later on May 13, 2016.

Stapley stated her assault took place in the ‘autumn of 1974,’ which does line up with when Bundy was living in Utah for his second (unsuccessful) attempt at law school (he moved there from Seattle on September 2, 1974). He was living at his first SLC apartment located at 565 1st Avenue North, and from what I understand he made a decent attempt his second time around and made a point of going to most of his classes. He was in between jobs at the time, but previously worked at the Department of Emergency Services in Olympia from May 3, 1974 to August 28, 1974. He remained unemployed until June 1975, when he briefly was employed as the night manager of Bailiff Hall at the University of Utah (he was fired the next month for coming in inebriated). Bundy was still in a long distance relationship with Liz Kloepfer, even though things seemed to be strained and sort of fizzling out at that point.

In my opinion, the most damning piece of evidence against Stapley’s claims is the missing VW handle. Like Sotria Kritsonis, Rhonda claims that the passenger’s side door handle was completely missing from the car, and I’m sorry… that’s never been brought up in any other CONFIRMED Bundy case (Kritsonis does not apply). I personally don’t believe it. As Erin Banks’ points out in her book, ‘Ted Bundy: Examining the Unconfirmed Survivor Stories:’ ‘the 1968 Beetle would not open if the outside door handle was still attached to the door while the inner door handle had been dismounted, Several researchers have credibly demonstrated that in the past. If the inner latch had been discounted, the integral part of the door handle, the cylinder pin latch assembly, and mounting screws holding inside and outside of the door handles together, and only separated by the door/panel itself, would sit loosely in the door. If one now tugged on the outer latch in an attempt to open the door, one would inevitably pull out the entire door handle from the outside.’ I don’t think I need to go on, as this right here proves there really was no way she would have been able to let herself in the vehicle if it had no inside handle. The only other thing I want to touch on regarding this topic is when I was in Seattle I listened to the Phantom Prince on Audible and I remember thinking to myself how often Ted drove around in his Beetle with Liz, Molly, and other friends… if he took the door handle off his vehicle he would have the run the risk of someone in his life seeing it, and no one in his inner circle ever reported seeing it missing. We also have to remember that he was drunk and/or high a good chunk of the time he was out ‘hunting’… he could have very easily forgotten that he took it off, running the risk of getting caught by Liz (or any other woman he was sleeping with). Lets also think back to Carol DaRonch, who had no problem exiting Bundy’s car on her own and never said anything about a missing door handle when she had her own experience with him a month later in early November, 1974.

Another thing about Stapley’s story that jumps out of me is her complete lack of any sort of substantial head wound. Most of Ted’s victims (if not all of them) suffered from some sort of skull injury in order to help incapacitate them, but Rhonda said her attacker didn’t go after her in any such way. He also didn’t use any sort of medium (like a cable or rope) in his strangulation technique aside from his hands, which is unusual for him (for example, with Cheryl Thomas he used a pair of pantyhose to choke her). Also, despite the fact that Stapley said it was an unseasonably warm fall day, the water she floated away in still would have been incredibly cold: according to my research, the waterways in and around SLC in October would have been in the high-50’s to low/ mid-60’s, and experts say that you should consider any water temperature below 70 degrees Fahrenheit with extreme caution. I guess I just find it hard to believe that she would have been able to gather the energy and strength to walk the TEN MILES back to her dormitory after being submerged in freezing cold water… Especially when you throw some (self-diagnosed) broken ribs, a painful dental surgery, and hours upon hours of being brutally sexually assaulted into the equation… I mean, the journey would have taken her hours, and since she traveled through the woods instead of the main roadway the conditions would have been a bit rough and less than ideal. In her book, Banks reports that when you take her height, weight, and normal everyday level of activity into account it would have taken her at least 15-20 minutes per mile of  walking (and that was a healthy, uninjured individual). Also, when Stapley woke up after moving down the river she reported it was dark outside (meaning it was after 7 PM), which is the time of sunset in SLC in October. Don’t get me wrong, I’m sure her adrenaline was really pumping, especially at first… but her walk back would have taken hours, it would have eventually worn off.

Additionally, Ms. Banks spoke with residents of SLC that lived near the area of Cottonwood Canyon where Stapley said she was assaulted. They reported that the level of water present at that time of year would have been minimal, and the depth of a puddle: ‘just a few short inches high during fall and winter.’ Banks also said there were lots of large boulders in the water which would have further prevented Stapley from ‘floating away from her abductor.’ Something interesting Erin points out in her book is that after the assault Stapley attempted suicide but half-way through had a change of heart. She called a suicide prevention hotline for help, and the man that answered her call (named Dave) immediately dropped the phone and rushed to her address in order to save her life. I mean… I work for a health insurance company, I have a pretty good understanding of HIPAA laws and how important it is to follow them. Even in a time as unregulated as the 1970’s, I never heard of a crisis hotline employee (or ANY other mental health professional) breaking every single rule put in place so they could go and help the person that called in. Stapley and ‘Dave’ somehow ran into each other again years later (he had since earned his doctorate), and after catching up a bit and telling him her story he told her that she was his hero and that he ‘put her on a pedestal right alongside my family members who work as first responders or who have been in military combat.’ I mean, what? Why would anyone say that to her?

Stapley is one of a few women that claimed to have been kidnapped and/or assaulted by Ted Bundy and lived to tell the tale. I know one individual from my Facebook group that said she was a victim of his but requested that I respect her privacy and not pry any further (she is working on a book from what I understand)… I know of a few others that have some pretty obvious mental health issues. Please keep in mind, when I say this I’m not talking about his confirmed victims, like Karen Sparks/Carol DaRonch/Kathy Kleiner/Karen Chandler/Cheryl Thomas. Just like Sotria Kritsonis (whose abduction site was my very last stop when I went to Seattle in April 2022), Rhonda came forward later in life to tell the tale of her run in with Ted. On February 9, 2018, Kritsonis did an interview with KIRO-TV where she discussed her 1972 alleged kidnapping attempt, which was very similar to Stapley’s: it also began at a bus stop on her way to college (just minus the dental surgery) and the car she got into was also missing its passengers side door handle. Just as a side note, one thing that does irritate me is how people say Rhonda isn’t ‘attractive enough to be a Bundy victim,’ which absolutely drives me nuts because first of all, attractiveness is subjective and (in my opinion), she was a pretty girl in her younger years. I mean, I personally think the serial killer was an opportunist that took advantage of whoever he happened to stumble across… Let’s look at his younger victims, like Kimberly Leach, or Lynette Culver. This is probably borderline inappropriate to say but I don’t think Bundy looked at these TWELVE YEAR OLD GIRLS and thought, ‘ they’re attractive and totally my type, they’re going to be my next victim.’ He simply took them because they were there.

The reviews for Stapley’s book on Amazon seem to be mostly good: as of December 2023, it had 677 reviews and a rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars. Some are overwhelmingly positive, for example one was written by a private investigator that said it ‘should be mandatory reading at all police academies’ Another that said: ‘the author’s story of survival, and struggle with PTSD is incredible. This is one person’s description of how trauma influenced her decision-making process. From an outsider’s point of view, it was enlightening, terrifying, awe-inspiring and educational. I encourage all law enforcement officers to read and study this book.’ However, others completely write off her story, and say that the entire scenario never happened and was made up for attention. This is just my personal observation, but most of the people that picked up her book and believed her story seem to be true crime novices, and didn’t have a very complete understanding of Bundy’s story, where the ones that were doubtful have a stronger background in true crime and have a deeper understanding of the case.

On June 22, 2016, Rhonda went on KATU’s morning show and told the host that her alleged encounter with Bundy was more serious and relevant than Carol DaRonch’s because she was sexually assaulted but DaRonch wasn’t, saying: ‘she actually escaped as soon as she got into the car so she wasn’t really assaulted.’ It’s absurd to think that because DaRonch wasn’t raped or brutally beaten that she wasn’t ‘really assaulted.’ The woman fought off a crowbar and escaped with a handcuff around her wrist. She clearly suffered horribly at the hands of her attacker. Of course she was assaulted.

I always wondered how Stapley’s family and other loved ones felt about her story, specifically if her husband and daughters believed her. Apparently, Barry Godding didn’t fully support his wife’s decision to publicly come forward after so many years and was even less enthused at the idea of her writing a book. She said that he liked to throw temper tantrums about her ‘quest to tell her truth and often insulted her with insensitive remarks about finally getting over that pesky rape all those years ago.’ I went through Rhonda’s FB page a few times in preparation for this article and interestingly enough, Erin Banks had the same mentality that I did about a heart attack Barry suffered the same year that she came forward about what happened to her, saying: ‘in a 2016 status update on one of her Facebook profiles Stapley speaks of how relieved she is that her husband is finally recovering after his heart attack, for she can now finally get back to promoting her and selling her book. I found this statement to be incredibly tone deaf and revealing as to her own level of empathy: ‘Barry seemed to think that I was dredging up ancient history for some devious purpose. I got the impression he thought that I was competing with him, that I had decided to become upset about a long ago trauma just as he was dealing with his own health crisis.’’

When I write an article, I have a set list of resources I go through, such as Reddit, YouTube, Ancestry, MyHeritage, and so on and so forth. One of my favorites is CrimePiper, which is run by Erin Banks, who is the author of the book I mentioned earlier. When I visited the sites files section something interesting caught my eye: a professor at the University of Utah and Rhonda’s one time mentor through the LDS church named Dr. Victor B. Cline published a paper on May 24, 2009 titled ‘Pornography’s Effects on Adults & Children,’ and on page nine he mentions Bundy. Rhonda said that Dr. Cline was ‘the first man to take a personal interest in her after the attack,’ and he requested to be assigned as her home teacher. Typically this is something the church does with all of the members of a family present, however in Stapley’s case he worked with her alone. The PhD told her he was famous and that people paid good money to receive his counseling services, but because they were meeting through the church he was providing her with those services for free. A great point that Ms. Banks brings up is that when Dr. Cline reached out to Rhonda, he had no idea that she had been assaulted by Bundy, and ‘she believed he, a virtual stranger, just ‘seemed to sense’ that something was wrong with her. To take such an extensive and personal interest in a female student, considering the obvious possible connotations of the nature of his interest, is astounding for someone who has much to lose as Cline did. It’s ‘not recommended’ by the LDS that a man and a woman who are not married or not otherwise related to one another interact without witnesses present or in great frequency. Still, Cline showered young Rhonda with attention. (Banks, 19).’ So, this man that apparently had a big impact on Stapley in her post sexually assaulted years wrote a paper that mentioned Bundy, and suddenly two years later she comes forward claiming that he assaulted her in October 1974? Come on.

Stapley still lives in SLC with her husband, and in a 2016 interview with People magazine she referred to herself as ‘an inventor’ as well as a pharmacist, wife, mother, and grandmother. In January 2003 Rhonda and her sister Bonita Hunt founded SnuggleHose, which is defined on her website as ‘warm, soft, cozy covers for CPAP (Continuous Positive Airway Pressure machines for patients with sleep apnea) hoses and ventilator machines.’ Stapley came up with the idea after she was diagnosed with sleep apnea in June 2002 and started using a CPAP. She is active on multiple social media platforms and even participates in ‘Ted Bundy trivia’ on the Facebook group ‘TB: All Opinions Matter.’ About her experience of living through being raped by Bundy, she said: ‘I think my experience with Ted Bundy affected every aspect of my life. It changed my level of self-confidence, it changed my trust, even my trust in myself. I became more introverted, less outgoing.’

I want to end this article with a quote from Erin Banks’ book: ‘Mrs. Stapley’s worth as a human being is indisputable. Her story is not.’ Before I wrote this article, a (very small) part of me wondered if *maybe* the young college student was raped (even though I didn’t think it was by Bundy). But, then I remember when I had my wisdom teeth extracted: my mouth was incredibly sore and puffy, plus I was numb from the novocaine. Not to mention I was bloody and stuffed full of gauze. Was Bundy really so hell bent on sexually assaulting a woman that he did it to one in such an off putting situation? Stapley said that he even raped her orally, which surely would have not been ideal for him considering the condition of her mouth (she said he was so rough that he ripped out some of the stitches in her cheek, which would have only made her 10 mile walk home even more hellish). Oddly enough, much like the bite mark on her breast that reappeared forty years after it happened, on one occasion when Stapley was thinking about the assault and how her oral stitches were ripped out her gums began to bleed for no reason. I mean, if I were Rhonda and I had just endured hours upon hours of hell, I would have looked for the first person available for help, not wandered back to campus, probably unsure of where I was going, hoping and praying I’d make it back alive. There’s just so many parts of this story that don’t really make any sense. A small part of me does feel bad for doubting a potential rape victims story, but I can’t help it.

Vivian Stapley-Redfern with three of her four children.
The entire Stapley family.
A very young Rhonda Stapley.
A young Rhonda Stapley in elementary school.
Another picture of Rhonda Stapley in elementary school.
A young Rhonda Stapley.
Rhonda and her husband on their wedding day.
Rhonda and a friend on a camping trip.
Rhonda Stapley.
Rhonda Stapley.
Rhonda Stapley.
Rhonda Stapley.
Rhonda Stapley.
Rhonda Stapley.
Rhonda and one of her daughters.
Rhonda holding one of her daughters.
Rhonda accepting her diploma after gradating from the University of Utah with a degree in pharmacy.
Rhonda holding her diploma after gradating from the University of Utah.
Rhonda.
A picture of Rhonda and a friend.
Rhonda sitting at a computer.
Rhonda.
Rhonda.
A b&w picture of Rhonda Stapley.
Rhonda and her siblings at her Mother’s 86th birthday lunch.
Rhonda with her mother and one of her brothers.
Rhonda and her husband, Barry.
Another picture of Rhonda and her husband, Barry.
Rhonda and her dog.
Stapley posing with some of her Snugglehose products.
A screen grab of a bunch of photos of Rhonda Stapley.
A picture of Rhonda next to her book.
Rhonda holding a true crime magazine that contains an article about her.
An advertisement for a TV show featuring Stapley.
An advertisement for a podcast featuring Rhonda Stapley.
A blurb about Stapley getting a position as a pharmacist published in The Sun-Advocate on December 13, 1973.
A blurb about Stapley getting a position as a pharmacist published in The Richmond Reaper on June 26, 1975.
A blurb about Stapley standing up in a friends wedding published in The Ogden Standard-Examiner on September 28, 1975.
A picture of Stapley published in The Richfield Reaper on August 26, 1976.
A birth announcement for one of Barry and Rhonda’s daughters published in The Salt Lake Tribune on October 30, 1981.
An article mentioning Stapley’s husband Barry published in The Salt Lake Tribune on December 18, 2004.
The first portion of Bundys whereabouts in October 1974 according to the ‘Ted Bundy Multiagency Investigative Team Report 1992.’
The second portion of Bundys whereabouts in October 1974 according to the ‘Ted Bundy Multiagency Investigative Team Report 1992.’
Vivian Stapley-Redfern, Rhonda’s mother.
Rhonda’s parents, Floyd and Vivian.
Rhonda’s fathers WW2 draft card.
A picture featuring Rhonda’s father Floyd published in The Richmond Reaper on Christmas day in 1952.
Rulon Floyd Stapley.
A photo of Floyd Stapley from one of his obituaries published by The Tri-City Herald on October 10, 1967.
A picture about Rhonda’s fathers plane crash published in The Salt Lake Tribune on October 9, 1967.
An obituary for Rulon Floyd Stapley published in The Salt Lake Tribune on October 12, 1967.
An obituary for Rulon Floyd Stapley published in The South Idaho Press on October 19, 1967.
An note of gratitude from the family of Floyd Stapley published in The Richfield Reaper on October 19, 1967.
The grave site of Rhonda’s parents.
Barry Godding’s junior year picture from the 1966 East High School yearbook.
A picture of Rhonda’s mother during peak Covid she posted on Facebook. The caption read: ‘I visited Mom today. Had to stand outside 6 feet back from window that was cracked open about 3 inches. They sat her in a chair 3 feet back from the window. I shouted but she could barely hear what I was saying. We mainly just waved to each other.’ Sadly, she passed away on October 7, 2021.
Dr. Victor Cline.
The portion of Dr. Victor Cline’s paper titled ‘Pornography’s Effects on Adults & Children’ that mentions Bundy.
A picture of Big Cottonwood Canyon taken in November 2022.
A picture of a couple signs from Big Cottonwood Canyon taken in November 2022.
A picture of a sign from Big Cottonwood Canyon taken in November 2022.

Christine ‘Christy’ Marie Eastin.

Christine ‘Christy/Christie’ Marie Eastin was born to Barney and Dorothy (nee Martin) on January 4, 1952. Mrs. Eastin was born on August 15, 1918 in Whitman, Washington and Barney was born in Bowling Green, Missouri on July 26, 1920; after getting married the family briefly lived in Seattle before settling down in Hayward, California. It appears that Christine’s Dad died when she was only ten years old at the age of 42 on September 23, 1962. I couldn’t find much else about her background other than she had an older sister named Victoria that was born in 1946. The blonde haired, blue eyed homecoming queen graduated from Sunset High School in 1970. She was 5’7″ and at the time of her disappearance weighed 130 pounds. Christine had a ⅜ inch long scar in the center of her forehead and a surgical scar on her abdomen from an intestinal operation.

Christy was popular and very well liked among her peers; her friends and loved ones said she was a very sweet, beautiful young woman with a gentle spirit that was kind to everyone. In high school she participated in the drama club, was a ‘song girl’ (which was Sunset HS’s version of a cheerleading squad), and a member of Orchesis (which looks like some sort of chorus group). Judy Ruiz-Verhoek, a childhood friend of Eastin’s, said she was ‘just very sweet. Just a gentle spirit, very kind.’ Six months out of high school, in early 1971 Christy was taking classes at Chabot College and was supposed to start a new job at a bank the morning after she disappeared. The nineteen-year old had finally saved up enough money to buy a pair of black boots she had her eye on, so early in the evening on January 18, 1971 she went shopping with her friend Sandy Lemmon-McBride at Mervyn’s in nearby San Lorenzo. In a KTVU interview, Sandy said of the trip: ‘we went to Mervyn’s, we got the boots, she dropped me off at 9:30, and before she left added, ‘’I’m going to go wash the car,’ which she promised she’d do before returning it.’ After the friends were done shopping Eastin dropped Sandy off then went home, which was in a middle-class neighborhood in Hayward, California. After showering she told her family she was going to have her loaner car (a blue 1969 Maverick) washed before she picked up its owner (her ex-bf George Sponsel) from work at a Jack in the Box restaurant located at Mission & Pinedale Court. Despite their relationship technically being over, Christy reportedly still had feelings for her ex-bf and according to reports she desperately wanted to get back together with him. Her friend Sandy said: ‘I know they dated for a while, and she really, really liked him.’ … ‘It sounded like he was ready to move on, and she wasn’t.’ She left her house roughly around 10 PM and was expected to arrive at the Jack in the Box around 11 PM (giving her a little less than an hour to get the car washed when you take drive time into consideration). Christine was last seen wearing a black/brown leather coat, blue pants, her new knee-high black boots, a red/white/blue pinstripe tunic, and a bluish gold scarf.

But Eastin never showed up to pick up George. At around midnight, he called her house asking where she was, and her mother woke up the household then drove straight to the car wash. The Maverick was there, but Chris wasn’t. The car was locked and her purse and scarf were found on the front seat. Immediately after arriving on the scene LE noted several strange details: some papers were found scattered on the ground on the passenger’s side of the vehicle, almost as if there had been a struggle (I did read in two different places that the papers were found next to the drivers side versus the passengers). Despite these alarming signs, investigators initially treated her case as if she were a runaway and her disappearance was barely reported by the media: a local newspaper printed a short blurb on her but nothing more (I was unable to find it despite hours of searching). The first time her story made the TV news was over 30 years after she vanished. I mean, let’s think about her disappearance logically: Eastin was a nineteen year old woman that lived at home her entire life and completely vanished off the face of the earth. All of her worldly possessions were left behind and she had no money; her bank accounts went untouched and her social security number hasn’t had any activity associated with it as well. She had no vehicle and nowhere to go. Obviously she disappeared before the days of the internet and cell phones, so she didn’t meet some guy online then leave to go be with him. Why didn’t the police take situations like this more seriously from the beginning? There’s no reason to hold off investigating and they obviously lose valuable time when they wait like that.

Before leaving home that fateful night Christine didn’t tell any of her loved ones that she was going anywhere other than the car wash then the Jack in the Box. Her family immediately knew something was wrong: she had left everything behind and had a lot of plans for the future. She would never just up and run away. Her sister said: ‘The car was parked by the vacuum cleaners, and her purse and scarf were on the front seat, and the car was locked.’ Eastin was unaccounted for for less than 2 hours, and it’s as if she vanished off the face of the earth. After speaking to Sponsel, investigators allowed him to take his car home a few days later and it was never processed for evidence.

The weekend before she disappeared, Chris spent some time with a group of girlfriends at Charlene Cox’s home on Alice Street in Haywood. The friends gossiped, shared secrets, and even worked on a 1,200 piece puzzle (which was put away unfinished and never touched again). After she vanished Cox and the other friends searched the hills surrounding Hayward looking for Eastin but came up with nothing. Ruiz-Verhoek has made it a priority in her life to solve the mystery of what happened to her friend. Christine’s childhood classmate has looked into reports of dead bodies, looked for clues on the streets of her hometown, and even took the ‘advice’ of psychics who told her where they thought her remains might be located. Judy even dug up a skeleton that later was determined to be animal in nature.

Eastin’s loved ones feverishly searched Hayward and its surrounding areas, showing strangers her picture while pleading with them for any information they may have had on the missing young woman. Charlene Cox said that: ‘If you knew Chris Eastin, I bet you remember exactly what you were doing when you heard she’d disappeared. Her mother’s frantic call woke me up that night, something I’ll never forget, even though I reassured her Chris must be on her way home. I never imagined she’d leave us in such an abrupt and brutal fashion. Chris, Holly Pekkonen and I used to play together at Highland Elementary School in the Hayward hills. They moved, we lost touch, until years later when high school varsity games reconnected Christy and me, both song girls, she for the Sunset High Falcons, and I for the Hayward High Farmers. Later, it was great to further refresh our long-ago friendship at Chabot College, but Christy would only know the exhilaration of being a teen in college for one full session. If you sent her a card that Christmas, it still exists. She’d kept them, treasuring her friendships. So many of you were much closer friends of hers than I, who shared all those ‘growing-up’ years.’ … ‘‘She was one of those sweet people everyone seemed to like. There was never any gossip about her. She didn’t cut school, didn’t do drugs… she was very much into being rah-rah for class spirit.’

In a KTVU interview from March 7, 2019, Christine’s sister Victoria Eastin-Cordova commented about the carefree time of the 70’s and that ‘everyone was kind of footloose and fancy-free and kind of taking off in their what, Volkswagen buses.’ Because of this, the Hayward Police Department most likely suspected that she may have just taken off and didn’t take her disappearance very seriously in the beginning. Chris wasn’t involved in ‘hippie culture’ and didn’t use drugs in any capacity. She had a good group of friends and didn’t hang out with the wrong crowd. Ruiz-Verhoek speculates that on the night she disappeared Eastin may have been in a vulnerable situation to someone with sinister intentions, being alone at night, and: ‘I just always felt that she would be a sitting duck, you know? She was so pretty and striking.’ About the ex-boyfriend as being a suspect in her disappearance, former Hayward PD Captain Jason Martinez said ‘We’ve pretty much eliminated him as a suspect.’ According to Christine’s NAMUS page, George Sponsel was killed in an industrial accident about a month after she disappeared (I did see in a few articles that he died in a car accident).

Sunset High School’s 1970 Homecoming King was Simon Flores, who has always felt that it was possible someone could have seen Chris as an attractive target: ‘Christine was a beautiful young lady. She was like a Barbie doll.’ … ‘I think somebody sort of stumbled upon her, somehow.’ According to loved ones, she was a reliable young woman that would never make her family worry needlessly. She wasn’t depressed or suicidal, and was excited about her new job as a bank teller and the future in general. Victoria said that ‘the police didn’t touch it for 72 hours or take it seriously.’ Most missing persons cases are opened and closed within a week, said retired Concord Police Detective Kurt Messick. He also said that suspicious disappearances are rare but that Eastin’s case would most likely trigger an intense investigation if it happened today. Former Hayward police Captain Manuel Silva went to Sunset High School with Eastin and seemed to be on the same page as Messick: that investigators handle missing persons cases completely differently now and that when Chris disappeared it was customary to wait 72 hours to take a report (which could only be a paragraph in length). In today’s times, LE is required by the state Department of Justice to take a report immediately and policing agencies must give ‘priority to handling of the report.’

Dave Legro was the Hayward police officer that took the report at the self-operated car wash back in 1971. He saw the Ford Maverick in the parking lot, and: ‘to me, it looked like it was staged,’ and that it looked like that the scene may have tried to make it look like Christy was kidnapped, and that: ‘the papers on the ground looked like it was for dramatic appeal.’ According to Legro, he ‘learned that she might have been pregnant and wondered if that somehow played a part in her disappearance.’ To this, her sister commented: ‘very possibly, she could have maybe said, you know, ‘I’m pregnant or something, you’ve got to be with me’ or maybe things got out of hand that way.’ Legro said that the case has bothered him his entire life.

Strangely enough, another young woman I talked about in a previous article named Cindy Lee Mellin disappeared two days after Christine was last seen (I mentioned her in my article on Robin Graham, who is coincidentally also from California). The 19 year old college student was last seen in Ventura, CA at 9:40 PM on January 20, 1970 at the Buenaventura Shopping Center. She was standing by her car and was in the company of a man who appeared to be between 30 and 40 years old and was driving a light colored vehicle. He appeared to be helping Mellin change the left rear tire in her car. Her dad found her vehicle at the mall the next day with a bumper, jack, and flat tire left behind; a sharp object had perforated the side of the tire and the spare was found nearby. Cindy Mellin was never seen or heard from again, and no trace of her has ever been recovered.

At the time Eastin was murdered in January 1971, Bundy was living in Seattle at the Rogers Rooming house on 12th Avenue and was in a long term relationship with Elizabeth Kloepfer. He was also an undergraduate psychology student at the University of Washington, and something interesting I learned while researching this article is that the school follows a quarter system instead of semesters. Under normal circumstances he would have either been on winter break or in the first week or two of classes, but this may not have been the case since they were on quarters (as Bundy may have been in the middle of a semester at the time). At the time he was employed as a delivery driver for Pedline Supply Company, which was a family-owned medical supply company (he was there from June 5, 1970 to December 31, 1971). There’s been a few unconfirmed victims from 1971 I’ve written about, Joyce LePage and Rita Curran are the first two that come to mind. LePage was a 21-year-old junior taking summer classes at Washington State University and was last seen alive on the evening of July 22, 1971 when friends dropped her off at her apartment. Her remains were found nine months later on April 16, 1972 in a gully about 10-15 miles south of Pullman in remote Wawawai Canyon. Rita Curran was a schoolteacher taking summer classes in Burlington, VT that was murdered in her bed in the early morning hours of July 20, 1971. The Burlington Medical Examiner determined that she had been beaten, sexually assaulted, and asphyxiated. They also found evidence that the young woman had fiercely resisted her attacker and put up a ‘vicious struggle.’ In February 2023 it was determined that William DeRoos killed Curran.

The ‘TB Multiagency Investigative Team Report 1992’ doesn’t give much information for Bundy’s whereabouts for 1971… just that he was in school at the University of Washington and that he left his job at Pedline at the end of the year. I also referenced my copy of Dr. Robert Dielenberg’s text, ‘Ted Bundy: A Visual Timeline,’ and on page 86 it says: ‘January 1971: Ted back again at the Univ. Wash; takes up studies in psychology.’ (page 86.) Did he make the 10+ hour drive to Hayward from Seattle to abduct then kill Eastin in January 1971? During Bundy’s death row confessions he told Dr. Robert Keppell that he committed his first murder in 1972. But I mean, it’s no secret he was a compulsive liar so obviously nothing he says can really be taken as 100% truth. In a separate event, when asked when he committed his first murder the serial killer refused to answer. He did admit to killing one woman in California but they have not been identified.

Another serial killer whose name frequently comes up in relation to the disappearance of Christine Eastin is Richard Allen Davis. Davis is a serial murderer whose actions began efforts for the passage of California’s ‘three-strikes law’ for repeat offenders and the involuntary civil commitment act for sex offenders and predators; it was signed into law on March 8, 1994. By the time he was 12, Davis was placed on probation for burglary and forgery. He dropped out of school his sophomore year of high school and told a psychiatrist that stealing relieved any ‘tensions’ that were building up inside him. When Davis was in court for a motorcycle theft at 17 a judge gave him the choice of  joining the US Army or going to the California Youth Authority. He chose the Army and received a dishonorable discharge after 13 months of service. On October 12, 1973 he went to a party at the home of Marlene Voris, who was found dead of a gunshot wound later that same night. There were several notes found at the scene, and LE concluded that the 18-year-old committed suicide (although friends believe it was Davis that killed her). A few weeks after Voris’ death, he was arrested for attempting to pawn property he had stolen. He confessed to a string of burglaries in La Honda and served six months in the county jail. Five weeks after his release on May 13, 1974 he was arrested for another burglary. He was sentenced to 6 months to 15 years in prison and was released on parole after serving only a year of his sentence.

On October 1, 1993 12-year-old Polly Klaas and two friends were having a slumber party at her home in Petaluma, California. Around 10:30 PM, an intoxicated Richard Davis entered her bedroom carrying a knife he stole from the Klaases’ kitchen. He told them that he was only there for money and wouldn’t hurt them. He tied Polly’s friends up, put pillowcases over their heads, told them to count to 1,000, then left with Klaas. On the evening of December 4, 1993, Davis confessed to kidnapping and murdering Polly Klaas and told investigators they would find her remains in a shallow grave about a mile south of the city limits of Cloverdale, CA. He was diagnosed with avoidant personality disorder, antisocial personality disorder, and schizoid personality disorder. In 1977, he told a psychiatrist that Voris’ death had deeply affected him and he heard her voice in his head. In 1996, he was convicted of first-degree murder with special circumstances: burglary, robbery, kidnapping, and an attempted lewd act upon a child under the age of 14. As of December 2023, he remains on death row in the Adjustment Center at San Quentin State Prison in California. But just to be clear, I found nothing tying Richard Allen Davis to Christine Eastin’s disappearance other than a comment made by a WordPress blogger ‘whereaboutsstillunknown,’ saying that he was ‘said to have kidnapped and raped a teenage girl in Hayward in 1971.’ However when I started looking into his timeline I could verify no such fact. The only thing I could find about his whereabouts and actions in the early 1970’s is that he was arrested on September 15, 1970 for participating in a motorcycle theft and he entered the Army in July 1971.

Another name that is thrown around in Eastin’s case is The Zodiac Killer, and if I can be truthful he was the first suspect I thought of when I started my research. I mean, the timing sort of makes sense, and so does the location: as far as his confirmed victims go, he was active in California in 1968 and 1969 (well, obviously this is a bit before January 1971). If I can be honest, I’m no Zodiac expert. I probably know more than the average person but at the same time there is a LOT that I don’t know about the case. However, according to Ruiz-Verhoek, a retired San Francisco detective named Armond Pelisetti said that the MO didn’t fit, and the Zodiac left his victims in the open waiting to be found, where Eastin just vanished off the face of the earth.

Another name thrown out there regarding the disappearance of Eastin is Joseph James DeAngelo. Also dubbed ‘the Golden State Killer,’ DeAngelo is a former mechanic, former cop, burglar, rapist, and serial killer that committed at least 13 murders, 51 rapes, and 120 burglaries throughout California between 1974 and 1986. He is responsible for three separate crime sprees throughout the state, each one generating a new nickname in the press before it became obvious that the atrocities were committed by the same individual (the other two are the East Area Rapist and the Original Night Stalker). I do think we can rule out DeAngelo in Eastin’s disappearance, as the timing doesn’t quite match up.

Phillip Garrido has also been suggested as possibly being responsible for Eastin’s disappearance. I’ve never heard of this guy before, but looking into him his first crime was reported over a year after she disappeared: in 1972, he was arrested and charged with sexually assaulting a 14-year-old girl, although the case never went to trial because she declined to testify. In 1977, he was sentenced to 50 years in prison for kidnapping a woman then taking her to a storage unit in Reno to sexually assault her. Despite the long sentence, under 1970’s-era sentencing laws he was eligible for federal parole after just 10 years; he was released in 1988. In 1991, he kidnapped 11-year-old Jaycee Lee Dugard and held her captive for 18 years until his arrest in August 2009. During this time, he fathered two children with her. In my opinion, he never should have been released in 1988.

Oddly enough, one of the last things I found during my research on Eastin was a TikTok video, and in the comments section someone suggested that maybe the Toolbox Killers may have been responsible for her disappearance. Looking into them, Lawrence Sigmund Bittaker and Roy Lewis Norris were rapists and serial killers that committed the kidnapping, rape, torture, and murder of five teenage girls across the southern part of California over a five-month period in 1979. FBI Special Agent John Edward Douglas described Bittaker as the most disturbing individual for whom he has ever created a criminal profile. Despite receiving the death penalty on March 24, 1981, he died of natural causes while on death row at San Quentin State Prison in December 2019. On May 7, 1980 Norris accepted a plea deal where he agreed to testify against Bittaker in return for a life sentence with the possibility of parole after serving thirty years. He died of natural causes at the all-male California Medical Facility in Vacaville in February 2020. They became known as the ‘Tool Box Killers’ because most of instruments they used to inflict torture upon their victims were items typically found inside a household toolbox; these items included sledgehammers, ice picks, and pliers. Strangely enough, according to my research Bittaker was out of prison and unaccounted for when Eastin disappeared in January 1971: a month after he was paroled in July 1967 he was again arrested for leaving the scene of an accident and theft. He was released in April 1970 and again wasn’t out for long: less than a year later in March 1971 he was again arrested for burglary. I mean, he didn’t have any reported murders before 1979, so again I think we can count him out in Eastin’s case.

Christine’s case quickly went cold. No new information related to her case was released to the public until 1999, when LE released a photo of what she may look like at 47 years old hoping it could lead to possible answers. In early 2005, the (former) Governator of California Arnold  Schwarzenegger offered a $50,000 reward for any information that led to the recovery of Christine Eastin. After the reward was announced, a billboard was constructed in late February of 2005 near the car wash that she disappeared from. At this time, former Hayward Police Chief Lloyd Lowe said that he believed there were still people out there that had first-hand knowledge of the crime that needed an incentive to contact law enforcement, and asked that a state reward be offered to encourage these people to come forward.

Things settled down again until 2019 when an unidentified female came forward and shared with investigators that she saw two men abduct Christine from the car wash before driving off in a white van. The witness said she didn’t report it at the time because she wasn’t sure what exactly she was seeing. They were only able to get a good look at the driver, as the accomplice was out of view putting Eastin in the back of the vehicle. The witness described the van as having a very particular style of rectangular side mirrors known as ‘west coast mirrors.’ In September of 2019 a composite sketch of the suspect was released to the public. If I can be honest… I don’t know if I completely buy her story. What made her come forward after all of this time? Was it a personal decision that she made with herself in 1971 to not get involved? Perhaps she possibly thought it might have been a domestic dispute between lovers (even though this sounds like a stretch)? Or maybe she genuinely had no clue what was going on until she saw a story on the news about the case (there’s been a lot on her in recent years) and it made her realize that she saw something more than she originally thought? I don’t know, in my opinion it’s just an odd detail to remember after almost fifty years.

The latest update in Eastin’s disappearance occurred in January of 2020, when LE went to the public asking them to share any information they may have regarding the case: ‘it has been 49 years since she disappeared.  But this will remain an open investigation until we can bring long sought answers to Christine’s family. To achieve this goal, we have a dedicated detective assigned to this investigation. There is a suspicion of foul play in Christine’s disappearance.’

At the 25th Sunset High School Reunion on August 23, 1996, a classmate of Eastin’s named Tannis Krist-Janson handed out fliers that (now retired) Detective Frank Daley from the Hayward Police Department had designed that contained Christine’s picture as well as a summary of the case. When the two girls were freshman they sang in the chorus together in the school’s prodution of ‘Oliver.’ Of her friend, Krist-Janson said: ‘A lot of people remembered her and thought it was really sad. There were clusters of conversations all around and you could tell they were talking about her.’ About 90 people attended the reunion, which was for the graduating classes of 1969 through 1972.

There is a homemade, almost crude website for the 25th reunion for the Sunset High School classes of 1969 through 1972, and a good portion of it is dedicated to the memory of Christine Eastin. Posted on the page is a letter from Detective Daley to the Alumni of Sunset High School dated December 23, 1998. A portion of that correspondence states: ’I have been searching for anyone that would be willing to provide us with any facts about Chris and her activities on that day.  During the past five years I have interviewed numerous friends of Chris concerning  their thoughts on what could have happened to her.  I have interviewed her ex-boyfriend George Sponsel. He was unable to provide any information on what might have occurred to Chris. I have spoken to her friends, Rebecca Harris, Tannis Kristjanson and several other people that knew her.  All of the persons contacted said Christine would have never left the area unless she was forced to.  No one has heard from her since the day she was reported missing. I would like to talk to anyone that can tell me about other friends that Christine had that might be able to help me put this puzzle together.  If you have any knowledge of places that Christine would frequent or people that she knew I would appreciate a telephone call or a letter.’

In another portion of the website ‘25th Reunion Rekindles Death Probe,’ a letter written by Glenn Chapman dated September 2, 1996 says: ‘I knew Chris, went to Sunset with her. I wonder what the ties are to Richard Allen Davis to make people think that he may have abducted her? Was he living in Hayward at the time? Wouldn’t he have talked about it by now? Chris was intelligent but also very kind. Now if someone came up to me at a car wash, and looked like Richard Allen Davis (rough looking, tattoos, etc.) I’d lock my doors and get out. However, if someone came up to me and asked for help and looked like Phillip Garrido did back in 1971, I might be inclined to help out. (yes, shades of Ted Bundy here) Maybe Phillip Garrido did exactly what he did to Katie Calloway to Chris, asked for some help with something and then bam. Maybe that’s why the car was locked, but her purse left inside, because she went to help someone else. That would be Chris, she was a kind, giving person. Did they ever find the keys? Were they in the car or not? If not, did anyone look for them at Garrido’s place, he WAS a hoarder, you know. This sounds more like a PG scenario than a Richard Davis crime scene. She was also his ‘type’, blond with blue eyes. Where was Phillip Garrido in 1971? Can’t seem to find much on him from back then. In her police report, Katie Calloway said PG told her he had done ‘this’ (raped a woman) twice before, in the Bay Area and in Las Vegas. Where are those women now? If they are alive, why aren’t they coming forward? It is a horrible tragedy that Chris’ mom is now gone and had to go to her grave not ever knowing what happened to her beautiful daughter. None of us who knew her, will ever forget her!’

In the over 50 years since Eastin disappeared law enforcement have chased countless dead ends, leads, and rumors that have all led to nothing. Her mother died at the age of 66 in February 1985 in Boise, Idaho. Victoria shared that her sisters disappearance aged her mother 20 years, and ‘she could have looked 86 instead of 66.’ When asked in an interview what she thanks happened to her sister, Victoria sighed and said, ‘I don’t know. I have gone over, I bet you, a trillion scenarios in the last 47 years.’ … ‘Please, come forward. We just need to put this to rest. It’s been such a burden for so many years.’ … ‘When you don’t know what happened, you think of a hundred thousand scenarios of what could have happened that drive you up the wall.’ … ‘The persistent efforts by Detective Daley gives me the confidence that there will be a resolution to Christy’s disappearance.  If anyone has a tidbit of memory about someone/something please express it, as it may be the one piece that proves very important.’

Eastin-Cordova has set up a ‘gofundme’ page for donations to help in the recovery of her little sister. On it, Victoria says: ‘Chris, a Sunset High School graduate and Chabot College student, was happy and about to start a new job the next day. She had plans for her future and certainly was not a runaway. She was my only sibling. Donations will fund  a new, comprehensive effort by Tracy Olson [phone redacted]. Any funds beyond the cost of the investigation will go toward flyers and other expenses, and possibly to enhance the existing reward established by the State of California in 2005. Where previous efforts have failed, we hope this private investigation will dig deep and finally shed light on Christine’s demise. Not knowing what really happened to her; not being able to bring resolution to her life story has been and still is distressing to her family and friends, all who loved her.’

If Christine Marie Eastin was alive in December 2023 she would be 71 years old; her disappearance is currently Hayward PD’s oldest missing-persons case. Former Captain Martinez said: ‘we would love to get closure on this case.’ … ‘There are a variety of different theories behind the case, however nothing substantial that we can absolutely pinpoint and say, ‘this is what I think happened.’’ Retired Detective Daley said that maybe ‘an old friend or someone from the class might know something and decide it is time the police know about it.’ Not that I have any training in criminology or police work, but my gut tells me Eastin was abducted by an opportunistic stranger that took advantage of the beautiful, kind-hearted young woman that was by herself at night. I think her abductor was driving by the car wash and noticed her alone and in a vulnerable situation then took advantage of her. He probably pulled up next to her, maybe he asked her for directions… lulled her into a false sense of security then pounced. And unless someone comes forward, we will never know.

A close up of Christine Eastin in first grade at Hayward Elementary School in 1959. Photo courtesy of Judy Ruiz-Verhoek.
The entire group shot of Eastin in first grade at Hayward Elementary School in 1959. Photo courtesy of Judy Ruiz-Verhoek.
Christine Eastin’s freshman picture from the 1967 Sunset High School yearbook.
Christine Eastin’s sophomore picture from the 1968 Sunset High School yearbook.
Christine Eastin’s song girls photo from the 1968 Sunset High School yearbook.
Christine Eastin in a group picture for Orchesis club from the 1968 Sunset High School yearbook. She is in the top row at the far right (I cut off the picture right after her).
Christine Eastin in a song girls picture from the 1968 Sunset High School yearbook.
Christine Eastin’s junior picture from the 1969 Sunset High School yearbook.
A shot of Eastin at an event for the song girls taken for the 1969 Sunset High School yearbook.
Christine Eastin in a group picture for drama club from the 1969 Sunset High School yearbook. She is on the far right.
Christine Eastin in a group picture for french club from the 1969 Sunset High School yearbook.
Christine Eastin’s senior picture from the 1970 Sunset High School yearbook.
A picture of Eastin’s as Homecoming Queen from the 1970 Sunset High School yearbook.
A picture of Eastin with the Homecoming King Simon Flores from the 1970 Sunset High School yearbook.
A shot of Eastin in a group picture for the song girls taken for the 1970 Sunset High School yearbook.
A picture of Eastin with some members of the song girls from the 1970 Sunset High School yearbook.
Christine Marie Eastin.
Christine Marie Eastin.
Beautiful Christine, getting ready for homecoming.
Christine and Flores with friends before the homecoming dance.
Simon pinning Christine’s corsage onto her dress.
Christine and the Homecoming King, Simon Flores.
The 1970 Sunset High School Homecoming King and Queen, Simon Flores and Christine Eastin.
Christine at her 1970 Sunset High School graduation.
A candid shot of Christine talking to a friend.
I apologize for the blurry image, it was the best screen shot I could get. Christine is on the far right.
A b&w shot of Eastin.
A candid shot of Eastin in her song girls uniform.
Another candid b&w shot of Eastin.
A colored picture of Eastin in her song girls uniform.
Another colored picture of Eastin in her song girls uniform.
What Eastin might look like at the age of 47 using age-progression technology (photo released in 1999).
A screen grab of Eastin’s missing persons poster.
FBI.govs missing persons poster for Eastin.
A plea to the public from the Hayward PD for any information related to the disappearance of Christine Eastin.
A sketch of the potential suspect.
A screen grab at a memorial table for Christine Marie Eastin.
The outside of Eastin’s alma mater, Sunset High School in Hayward, CA.
The trophy case at Sunset High School in Hayward, CA.
Christine Eastin’s high school diploma.
An aerial picture of the Chabot College Campus taken in 1970. Photo courtesy of the Hayward Area Historical Society.
Vicky Eastin’s senior picture from the 1963 Sunset High School yearbook.
A second picture of Vicky Eastin from the 1963 Sunset High School yearbook.
Vicki Eastin got voted ‘best figure’ her senior year of high school in 1963.
Victoria Eastin-Cordova, Christine’s sister.
Another shot of Victoria Eastin-Cordova, Christine’s sister.
George Sponsel in the 1967 Hayward Hayward High School yearbook.
Sandy Lemmon.
Christine’s friend Judy Ruiz-Verhoek.
Christine’s friend, Simon Flores.
The Jack in the Box restaurant where Eastin’s ex-bf worked.
The Mervyn’s store in San Lorenzo that Eastin and her friend shopped at the night she disappeared in January 1971.
Another shot of Mervyn’s in San Lorenzo.
Christine’s childhood home located at 25096 Joyce Street in Hayward, CA.
A blue 1969 Ford Maverick like the one Eastin borrowed from her ex-boyfriend.
In September 2019, KTVU ran a story about an unidentified woman that had only recently come forward claiming that she believes she saw Eastin’s abduction but didn’t realize what was happening at the time. The witness recalled two men in a white van (like the ones seen above), with distinctive rectangular ‘west coast style’ side mirrors.
A up close shot of west coast style mirrors.
Charlie’s car wash.
What the site of the site of the car wash looks like today.
According to the ‘Ted Bundy Multiagency Investigative Team Report 1992,’ Bundy was active in California.
Bundy’s whereabouts in 1971 according to the ‘Ted Bundy Multiagency Investigative Team Report 1992.’
Part of a conversation between Ted Bundy and Robert Keppel about Joyce LePage and when he may have started killing. Courtesy of Tiffany Jean.
A possible route that Bundy may have taken from his rooming house on 12th Avenue in Seattle to Charlie’s Car Wash at 25400 Mission Boulevard in Haywood, CA.
Richard Allen Davis.
A People magazine featuring Richard Allen Davis victim, Polly Klass.
Phillip Garrido.
Lawrence Sigmund Bittaker on trial in 1981.
Roy Lewis Norris shortly before his arrest in 1979.
Cindy Lee Mellin.
A WebSleuths comment on Christine’s article from an old schoolmate of her’s.
A comment on a YouTube video on Eastin by a friend that knew her.
Dorothy Eastin’s birth certificate.
The Eastin’s in the 1950 census.
A picture from Victoria Eastin-Cordova’s wedding announcement published in The Daily Review on November 17, 1963.
The article from Victoria Eastin-Cordova’s wedding announcement published in The Daily Review on November 17, 1963.
Christine’s name mentioned in the list of graduates from the Hayward High School class of 1970, published in The Daily Review on June 21, 1970.
An article about Eastin published in The Oakland Tribune on May 31, 1994.
Eastin mentioned in an article published in The Oakland Tribune on February 25, 2005.

Johanna Tabitha Virginia Strong Leatherbury.

Johanna Tabitha Virginia Strong Leatherbury was born on May 17, 1953 to Jack and Gayle (nee Strong) in Cedar City, UT. Mr. Leatherbury was born on September 16, 1916 in Eureka, UT and her mother was born on July 21, 1920. The couple were wed on May 22, 1939 in Heber City and eventually settled down in Holladay outside of Salt Lake City. Jack was a graduate of Brigham Young University and worked for the Union Pacific railroad for 43 years. The couple had ten children: six boys (Jack, Charles, Paul, Christopher, Marshall, and Greg) and four girls (Roxanne, Johanna, Suzanne and Jacquine, who died the same day she was born on February 22, 1940).

Johanna stood at 5’3″ tall and weighed 135 pounds at the time of her murder. In 1971, she graduated from Olympus High School and was employed at Ballast Hall, a dormitory at the University of Utah. She was also a member of the Holladay Sixth Ward Chapel, a branch of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. The evening of August 20, 1971 was no different than any other: before she left her family home to go hang out with her friends the 17 year-old said goodbye to her parents and siblings. It would be the last time the Leatherbury’s would see her alive. The night turned into morning, and she never came home. This wasn’t like Johanna at all and her family knew right away that something was wrong. Immediately they began to search the area in hopes of finding her.

Described by one of her brothers as ‘thoughtful and kind,’ Johanna was very well liked by her peers and was deeply loved by family and friends. She always made time to visit her grandfather at the VA, who was an injured World War II veteran and loved spending time with her nieces, who said their aunt would often take them out for coffee with her friends and never treated them like children. Like most teenagers on the cusp of adulthood, Leatherbury liked going out with friends and ‘hanging out:’ on the evening of Friday August 20th, she met up with friends at a popular hangout referred to as ‘The Complex,’ which is best described as a vacant field where kids from the areas high schools went to hang out. Leatherbury had just graduated and was moving on to college (most likely the University of Utah where she worked), and it’s important to keep in mind it was the end of August, which is right before school starts up again. Of the spot, Jack Leatherbury said that it was just a normal teenage haunt, and that the areas two schools (Skyline and Olympus High) were just a five minute, 1.7 mile drive apart so many of the students knew each other from growing up in the same area: ‘the kids from Skyline and Olympus High School all hung out at this area. They played games and did what teenagers do.’

I have two different reports as to where Johanna was last seen: in an article published by The Ogden Standard-Examiner on August 24, 1971, it stated that ‘Miss Leatherbury was last seen Friday night when she drove a friend home.’ However the more frequently given account is that she was last seen getting into a car with two unidentified gentlemen containing an unknown number of people by friends near The Complex (which was located at the intersection of State Street and 2100 South Street) at roughly 11:00 PM on August 20, 1971 (I read one source that said it was as late as 11:25 PM and listed the location at 2500 South State Street and West Temple). No one caught the type of car that Johanna got into, however the public was given a description of two different makes and models that were said to be in the area where she was last seen: on August 26th just days after Leatherbury was murdered LE issued an all points bulletin on two cars and their drivers that were reported to be near The Complex. One of them was a 1959/60 black (or dark green) Chevrolet Impala with an engine that ‘sounded like a washing machine’ that was driven by an approximately 24 year-old male with ‘hair down to his ears.’ The second vehicle in question was a 1970/71 Dodge Charger with white racing stripes painted on the sides and a black stripe on the rear that was driven by a person described as ‘young and blonde.’ Unfortunately, it seems that police were unsuccessful in their search efforts.

The day after Johanna was last seen her older brother Jack heard a report on the radio that immediately alarmed him: ‘it was a bulletin on the radio that said there had been a body discovered in the surplus canal out by the Great Salt Lake.’ … ‘Good Lord, I could tell you where we were about every hour from the day to the time they discovered her.’ Per KSL, her younger sister, Roxanne said that ‘when she didn’t show up, we all began to panic.’ The Leatherbury family’s search attempts didn’t yield any answers; however her body was quickly discovered the next day.

On August 21, sometime between 4 – 4:45 PM the naked remains of Johanna Leatherbury were discovered in a marshy area near the Great Salt Lake by David Russell and Neal Draper. The men happened to be fishing in the canal, which was located about a half mile west of the west stock bridge on the Goggin’s Drain by the Great Saltaire, an abandoned entertainment complex that had been destroyed in a fire in November 1970. Goggins Drain is a bypass canal that drains water from a surplus canal and helps transport water from 21st South to the Great Salt Lake. At first the two fishermen thought they found an old department store mannequin, however after they brought it to shore and further inspected it they quickly realized that wasn’t the case at all: it was the corpse of a young woman.

Because it was 1971 and not 2023 the men had no cell phones, so they drove to the closest town of Magna, UT to inform law enforcement about their discovery. Once detectives arrived on the scene and pulled the body out of the water it was obvious to them what happened to the young woman: she had been shot in the chest and head nine times and stabbed in the chest and stomach four times (I did see it reported she was stabbed five times and another that said was shot only three times). She had also been raped and pistol whipped. In the very beginning, responding officers thought the body may have belonged to 17-year-old Sheri Martin, who disappeared from her POE of Winchells Donut House on August 12, 1971. Martin’s body was eventually found by two hikers 15 miles south of Wendover on September 6; she also died from gunshot wounds.

Captain Pete ‘ND’ Haywood of the Salt Lake County Sheriff’s Department told the public that they’re ‘looking into many leads in the killing of Leatherbury, but we have no suspects at this time.’ Strangely enough, a 20 year-old woman named Leeora Looney disappeared the same evening in August 1971 that Johanna was murdered after she was reported missing from her POE at a doughnut shop in Lakewood. According to court documents, her car and purse were also both left behind, completely untouched. Several witnesses reported seeing two men in the shop just before she disappeared that were later identified as serial killers Sherman Ramon McCrary and Carl Taylor. Three days after Looney disappeared her naked remains were found in a remote field; she had been strangled, raped, and shot in the head. It was later determined McCrary and Taylor were responsible for her death as well as Shari Martins. The McCrary family is suspected of at least 24-26 additional murders (I’ve read varying amounts) and all involved young women that were last seen alive at doughnut shops throughout Colorado, Texas, Florida, Kansas City and Utah between 1970 and 1971. In 1988, 62-year-old Sherman Ramon McCrary hung himself in his cell while serving time in prison; he would have been eligible for parole in 1997.

It wasn’t long before police identified the woman as Johanna Leatherberry. After she was found, SLC deputies thoroughly combed the marshes that bordered the Great Salt Lake for clues. Additionally, on August 22-23 two Utah National Guard helicopters helped in the search and they combed through the area where her remains were found; unfortunately, this failed to find anything of value. Detectives speculated that she was killed early in the morning after she disappeared then was transported to Goggins Drain. After arriving, her assailants dragged her body into the water, where it floated for roughly eight hours before it was discovered. Investigators found multiple tire tracks and footprints near where the remains were recovered as well. On August 26, 1971 detectives executed a search warrant to enter an undisclosed Salt Lake residence, where they confiscated a .22 caliber gun as well as a switchblade, which may have been connected with the crime. Ballistics tests were done on the weapon and comparisons were made with slugs taken from the girls remains. A total of three .22 caliber pistols as well as the knife were sent into the FBI crime lab in Washington DC; also sent in were the victim’s fingernail clippings, hair samples, her Chrysler car, and her purse as well as its contents. Captain Haywood told the media that all possible leads were being investigated and any pistol which deputies came across in their routine duties were being run through ballistics.

At first, the investigation was on a fast track and LE were certain an arrest would quickly be made, however all leads were deemed to be a ‘dead ends’ and fizzled out; the case quickly went cold. Weeks turned into months, which turned into years, then decades. Hopes for a quick arrest vanished after multiple persons of interest were questioned and cleared. In an article published on August 27, 1971, it’s reported that at one point five full time detectives were assigned to the Leatherbury case. They conducted interviews with hundreds of Johanna’s family members, friends, school/church mates, acquaintances, and coworkers, but no one could provide them with anything of value. One of Captain Haywood’s ‘hottest leads’ was a phone call from a man that wished to remain anonymous that claimed he had seen a girl abducted near the County Complex the same night Johanna was last seen. Officers asked the man to call them back and Haywood even offered to protect his identity.

Captain Haywood said that one of LE’s biggest handicaps regarding the investigation was that no one that was with the victim at The Complex the night she disappeared ever came forward to offer information. Because of this, investigators had to keep going back to find individuals to check out certain pieces of information, which took up a lot of valuable time and made their job much harder. Haywood speculated there were at least a dozen kids at The Complex the night Leatherbury disappeared (if not more), but nobody wanted to come forward and volunteer anything helpful. It also made him wonder if maybe there was some form of illegal activity going on that night that nobody wanted to get in trouble for.

According to KTSU, today the vacant lot where Leatherbury was last seen is now occupied by The Salt Lake County Clerk’s Office and an assisted living development. One odd fact about this case is that her wallet and checkbook were found on the roof of the World Motor Motel which was located at 1900 South and State Street in SLC. Eventually, two juveniles (one of them was an industrial school escapee) came forward that had items in their possession that belonged to Johanna; they were questioned, cleared, and released. The boys admitted to rifling through her Chrystler early on Saturday, August 21st and stealing her purse, which she left behind on the backseat. The two then went through the bag, throwing its contents on the roof of the motel; they threw the purse itself in some nearby bushes. LE found the belongings thanks to a breeze that blew several of Leatherbury’s papers off the roof of the motel, which alerted them to the location of the items as they combed the area for evidence. Detective Haywood said that Leatherbury’s vehicle was found a couple blocks away from The Complex parked on Westminster Avenue between State Street and 200 East near the Salt Lake County Complex in the early morning just hours after she disappeared.

A night watchman from the Morton Salt Company told LE that he saw a brown International Harvester Scout driving in the area where Johanna’s remains were recovered at around 5 AM on August 21; this is the same time that investigators suspect her remains were dumped. When detectives located the vehicle’s owner and spoke to him, he was cleared as well. Captain Haywood said of the killer, ‘there’s no doubt in the world that this is a crime committed by a local person.’ The SLC Chief of Detectives seemed to back him on his claim, saying that Leatherbury’s body was found in ‘practically an unknown spot’ and that the individual would have had to had to have known the area ‘intimately’ to find his way in and out on the three trails leading to the area. One of those three paths was useless and led directly to a muddy mess.

On September 5, 1971, Haywood announced that he saw links between Johanna’s case and the brutal murders of William Rulon Shaw and a young delivery driver named Mike Bown. Shaw was a 65 year old florist that was killed three days after Johanna on August 24, 1971 after he was shot during a robbery of his shop. Michael Preston ‘Mike’ Bown was a 23 year-old deliveryman in Provo and was shot in the back of the head on September 2, 1971 while dropping off bread at Natter’s Market on South 700 East Street. The bullet struck him in his left cheek and exited through his right eye, killing him instantly. Another employee, 33 year-old Carolyn Kingston was also shot in the head through her right temple but survived. The suspect got away with less than a hundred dollars. There was a second delivery man on the scene and I read conflicting reports that either the suspect’s gun jammed or that he ran out of ammo, but regardless as to what happened that person’s life was spared that day. According to him, the robber was between 18 to 20 years of age, had curly hair, was short and well groomed. Left behind at the crime scene was a gold Timex watch with a dark blue face and a blue and gray striped nylon band. The timepiece used Roman numerals rather than numbers and is strongly believed to have belonged to the suspect. Additionally, there were reports of a 1959 Black Chevrolet Impala four-door sedan at the scene with its engine running, much like the one seen the night Johanna disappeared. Haywood said that he saw similarities in the deaths of Bown, Leatherbury, and Shaw: they all involved a .22 caliber pistol and that the ‘mode of operation’ in the Bowe and Shaw homicides were similar.

At the time Johanna was murdered Bundy was living in Seattle at the Rogers Rooming house on 12th Avenue and was in a long term relationship with Elizabeth Kloepfer. He was also an undergraduate psychology student at the University of Washington (although he was in between semesters at the time, as it was the middle of August). At the time he was a delivery driver for Pedline Supply Company, which was a family-owned medical supply company (he was there from June 5, 1970 to December 31, 1971). One of the first things that jumped out at me regarding Johanna being a possible Bundy victim is the fact that she was shot multiple times. None of Ted’s victims were ever shot, and aside from Carol DaRonch’s claim that he pulled out a gun during her attempted kidnapping I never heard of him using such a weapon in any capacity. The only other unconfirmed victim I wrote about that suffered from gunshot wounds is Susan Wickersham. On July 11th, 1973 at 11:30 PM, the 17-year-old dropped the family car off at the restaurant her mother was working at in Bend, Oregon then left to wait across the street for some friends to pick her up. When they never showed up, she decided to walk home instead and was never seen alive again. Wickersham’s skeletal remains were found in the woods by a man collecting firewood on January 20, 1976. Examination of her skull by the state medical examiner’s office determined she had suffered from a gunshot wound to the head. Personally, I don’t think Bundy killed Susan and it seems like her family doesn’t either (I briefly spoke with one of her SIL’s on FB and she agrees with me).

Officials in charge of Leatherbury’s murder said that most of the files related to the case were damaged by flooding at the police station years ago. Despite going cold, her case is still considered ‘active’ and officials exhumed her body in 2017; the results of this examination have not been shared with the public or even her family, which deeply upsets them. Johanna’s niece Sandy said that they ‘weren’t privy to hardly anything. We appealed for the file, and we were denied.’ … ‘She deserved more. She deserved to have whoever did this to be caught.’ … ‘We just didn’t have any follow-through. There was no follow-through. It was just put up on the shelf and left.’ … ‘I am so angry and frustrated because there was a door being slammed in our face all of the time.’ However, a spokeswoman for the Unified Police Department named Melody Gray disagreed with that statement, explaining that the case is still active and that they ‘have a full-time cold case investigator and he has actively been working this case including right now.’

A newsletter for the police society VIDOCQ dated December 15, 2015 mentions a presentation the organization put on regarding the case of Johanna Leatherbury (looking through their website I couldn’t find any additional information on her). In the article, Deputy Police Commissioner Bill Gill reported that Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Todd Grey was able to secure a sample of Leatherbury’s DNA as well as her mandible for further testing. The same article mentioned that the group was going to speak with a serial killer named ‘Robert Lee Sales,’ who was serving time at the Utah State Prison for murders similar in nature to Leatherbury’s. Incarcerated since 1973, Sells raped and murdered multiple young woman around Johanna’s age in the early 1970’s. He was convicted of the murder of JoAnn Poulsen from Corinne, UT, who was recovered from the PineView Reservoir on September 26, 1971. Oddly enough she disappeared on August 21, 1971, which is the same day that the remains of Leatherbury’s were recovered.

About her sister, Roxanne Leatherby-Brough said that Johanna ‘was a good kid. She tried hard to please other people, help us all. I don’t know. I miss her a lot.’ The remaining members of the Leatherbury family haven’t gotten much information related to Johanna’s case over the years, and unfortunately both of her parents died before seeing their daughter’s killer brought to justice: Gayle passed away at the age of 64 on November 6, 1984 and Mr. Leatherbuty died at the age of 73 on May 6, 1990. Their son Jack said he watched as the gruesome details and gnawing unknown tore his parents apart, and because of the death of their daughter they both went to their graves completely changed people. A few of Johanna’s siblings have passed away as well: her brother Paul died at the age of 55 on November 23, 1997 in Murray, UT (which is coincidentally where the Fashion Place Mall is located, which is where Carol DaRonch’s attempted abduction took place). According to his obituary, he was a past President of the Utah Arabian Horse Association and he loved his horses, fishing, and traveling. He had a great zest for life and was known to those who loved him as ‘the world’s greatest salesman.’ On July 5, 2012 Greg Leatherbury died of complications from diabetes at the age of 61. He was known to loved ones as ‘the great organizer’ because he excelled at planning events and activities, including an annual Father’s Day Open Golf Tournament. Charles Leatherbury died at the age of 73 on December 27, 2018; he was in the US Army and fought in the Vietnam War.

Because of their extreme dissatisfaction with the way law enforcement handled the investigation, the Leatherbury family recently joined forces with the Utah Cold Case Coalition to help get answers in Johanna’s case. The coalition is a Utah based organization that helps to bridge the gap between police and the families of cold case murder victims. Two of Johanna’s nieces, sisters Sandy and Cindy, said they were told that information related to their aunt’s case could not be shared because it is still an open and active investigation. Cindy Leatherbury-Grange commented that: ‘we really have felt the case was solvable, but now it’s so many years past.’… ‘We’re wondering if these people are dead, what has happened. Thirty years ago, we might have had a chance.’ The coalition’s co-founder Jason Jensen is certain Johanna’s killer is local to Salt Lake City. In a post on their FB page about the Leatherbury case, the ‘Cold Case Coalition’ commented that: ‘it’s been exactly 48 years since Johanna Leatherbury was found dead in a drainage ditch near Saltair in Salt Lake County. She had been raped, shot, and stabbed. 48 YEARS.  Yet Unified P.D. won’t release any records because it’s ‘still an open case’s This is the same response we get from Unified in every case. If you haven’t solved the case in nearly half a century, can someone else have a try?’

In an article published by ABC4, Johanna’s family got an email from a Salt Lake detective in mid-February 2022 with news they’ve been waiting many, many years to receive: ‘They have identified new DNA from the crime scene and he was securing funds to send it to their lab for testing and hopefully he’ll be able to use genetic genealogy.’ Jensen commented that this new evidence could be a variety of things: ‘if it was an article of clothing or something that was handled by an investigator 30 or 40 years ago chances are great that it’s an incidental from an investigator. But if it’s something concrete like semen, then it’s going to be the bad guy.’ This technique is quickly becoming very common with law enforcement and helps to identify familial DNA, and from there authorities are able to narrow down the search in hopes of finding a possible suspect. The article said it would be months before LE got the results of the DNA analysis and considering it’s now the end of 2023, I’m leaning towards them not finding anything of value from the sample. As a side note, in early 2023 Rita Curran’s killer was found in the same manner, and it was determined that her neighbor William DeRoos killed the pretty young teacher in her bed on July 19, 1971 in Burlington, VT.

Johanna Leatherbury.
Johanna Leatherbury.
Leatherbury’s sophomore year picture from the 1969 Olympus High School yearbook.
Leatherbury in a group picture for chorus from the 1969 Olympus High School yearbook.
Johanna Leatherbury’s senior picture from the 1971 Olympus High School yearbook.
Investigators standing at the site where Leatherbury’s remains were discovered.
A screen grab of crime scene photo’s related to Johanna Leatherbury’s murder.
Another screen grab of crime scene photo’s related to Leatherbury’s murder.
Where the Leatherbury family lived, located at 2919 Ward Way in Holladay, Utah.
Where Johanna attended church, the Holladay Sixth LDS Ward Chapel (located at 3070 Nila Way in Holladay, Utah).
Johanna’s birth announcement.
An article I found on WebSleuths about Leatherbury that had no publication information..
An article about the murder of Johanna Leatherbury published by The Deseret News on August 23, 1971.
An article about Johanna Leatherbury published by The Ogden Standard-Examiner on August 23, 1971.
An article about Johanna Leatherbury published by The Herald-Journal on August 23, 1971.
An article about Johanna Leatherbury published by The Salt Lake Tribune on August 23, 1971.
An article about Johanna Leatherbury published by The Ogden Standard-Examiner on August 24, 1971.
An article about Johanna Leatherbury published by The Herald-Journal on August 24, 1971.
An newspaper blurb mentioning a service for Leatherbury published by The Daily Herald on August 24, 1971.
An article about Johanna Leatherbury published by The Deseret News on August 24, 1971.
An article about Johanna Leatherbury published by The Salt Lake Tribune on August 24, 1971.
An article about Johanna Leatherbury published by The Daily Herald on August 25, 1971.
A short listing of Utah deaths featuring Johanna Leatherbury published by The Ogden Standard-Examiner on August 25, 1971.
An article about Johanna Leatherbury published by The American Fork Citizen on August 26, 1971.
An article about Leatherbury published by The Ogden Standard-Examiner on August 26, 1971.
An article about Johanna Leatherbury published by The Daily Herald on August 27, 1971.
An article about the murder of Johanna Leatherbury published by The Herald-Journal on August 27, 1971.
An article about Johanna Leatherbury published by The Salt Lake Tribune on August 27, 1971.
Her belongings were discovere after a breeze blew several papers off the roof of the World motel as they combed the area nearby for eidence.
An article about the murder of Johanna Leatherbury published by The Deseret News on August 27, 1971.
An article about the investigation on the murder of Johanna Leatherbury published by The Ogden Standard-Examiner on August 28, 1971.
An article about the investigation on the murder of Johanna Leatherbury published by The Deseret News on August 31, 1971.
An article mentioning Leatherbury published by The Deseret News on September 2, 1971.
About two weeks after Leatherbury's murder two more people were murdered over a robbery gone wrong. The assailant ot away with less than $100 and  two peopkle lost their lives: Michael P. Bone and
An article mentioning Leatherbury published by The Deseret News on September 4, 1971.
An article mentioning Leatherbury published by The Ogden Standard-Examiner on September 4, 1971.
An article mentioning Leatherbury published by The Ogden Standard-Examiner on September 5, 1971.
An article mentioning Leatherbury published by The Herald-Journal on September 6, 1971.
An article mentioning Leatherbury published by The Ogden Standard-Examiner on September 8, 1971.
An article mentioning Leatherbury published by The Deseret News on September 8, 1971.
Leatherbury mentioned in an article published in The Salt Lake Tribune on November 22, 1971.
An advertisement for ‘secret witnesses’ that mentions Leatherbury published by The Salt Lake Tribune on December 2, 1971.
An opinion piece about secret witnesses that mentions Leatherbury published by The Salt Lake Tribune on December 6, 1971.
An article mentioning Leatherbury published by The Salt Lake Tribune on December 30, 1971.
An newspaper blurb about secret witnesses mentioning Leatherbury published by The Salt Lake Tribune on January 15, 1972.
An article mentioning Leatherbury published by The Salt Lake Tribune on August 1, 1972.
An article mentioning Leatherbury published by The Salt Lake Tribune on September 10, 1972.
An article about unsolved crimes mentioning Leatherbury published by The Deseret News on January 1, 1973.
An article mentioning Leatherbury published by The Deseret News on January 1, 1974.
The second page of an article mentioning Leatherbury published by The Deseret News on September 16, 1985.
An article after Bundy was executed that mentions his possible link to Leatherbury’s death published by The Salt Lake Tribune on January 24, 1989.
An article after Bundy was executed that mentions his possible link to Leatherbury’s death published by The Salt Lake Tribune on January 25, 1989.
A picture mentioning Leatherbury possibly being a victim of Bundy published by The Salt Lake Tribune on January 25, 1989.
An article about a website featuring true crime sites mentioning Leatherbury published by The Daily Herald on October 30, 2000.
An article about a website featuring unsolved crimes mentioning Leatherbury published by The Toole Transcript-Bulletin on November 9, 2000.
Jack Leatherbury in his senior year of high school.
Jack Leatherbury’s World War II draft card.
Jack Leatherbury’s freshman picture from the 1937 Brigham Young University yearbook.
Jack Leatherbury’s senior picture from the 1941 Brigham Young University yearbook.
Jack and Gayle’s marriage announcement published in The Pleasant Grove Review on June 16, 1939.
Jack and Gayle in the 1940 census.
The birth announcement for Johanna’s oldest brother Jack, who was born on Valentine’s Day in 1941.
A newspaper blurb mentioning the Leatherbury’s visiting Gayle’s parents. There’s a lot of weird little things like this in newspapers I’ve noticed. This was published in The American Fork Citizen on October 1, 1943.
It looks like at one point the Leatherbury’s thought about divorcing. This was published in The Salt Lake Tribune on February 12, 1947.
Gayle Kathryn Strong Leatherbury.
Jack Leatherbury’s photo from the 1957 Olympus High School yearbook.
Paul Leatherbury’s photo from the 1958 Olympus High School yearbook.
Charles Leatherbury’s photo from the 1964 Olympus High School yearbook.
Paul Leatherbury’s photo from the 1965 Olympus High School yearbook.
Greg Leatherbury’s photo from the 1965 Olympus High School yearbook.
Marshall S. Leatherbury’s photo from the 1965 Olympus High School yearbook.
Roxanne (l) and Suzanne (r) Leatherbury’s junior year pictures from the 1971 Olympus High School yearbook.
Greg Leatherbury’s wedding announcement published in The Salt Lake Tribune on February 3, 1974.
A photo from Greg Leatherbury’s 2012 Obituary.
Johanna’s brother Jack in a screen grab from a news clip about his sisters death that aired on August 22, 2022.
Johanna’s nieces.
An obituary for Johanna published by The Salt Lake Tribune on August 24, 1971.
An announcement for funeral services for Johanna published by The Salt Lake Tribune on August 24, 1971.
An obituary for Gayle Leatherbury published by The Daily Herald on November 9, 1984.
An obituary for Gayle Leatherbury published by The Pleasant Grove Review on November 14, 1984.
An obituary for Johanna’s father Jack Leatherbury published by The Salt Lake Tribune on May 8, 1990.
An obituary for Paul Leatherbury published by The Salt Lake Tribune on November 25, 1997.
Johanna’s grave site; she is buried next to her little sister, who sadly died the same day she was born in 1940.
Gayle and Jack Leatherbury’s grave stone.
Paul Leatherbury’s grave stone.
Charles Leatherbury’s grave stone.
Jack Leatherbury’s pedigree. I know it’s cut off on the right side, I was unable to find the rest of it.
The Leatherbury’s are mentioned in a document I found on Ancestry titled: ‘Remington’s of Utah: with their ancestors and descendants from ‘Section IV. Descendants of Jerome N. and Lydia RB Remington.’
Bundy’s whereabouts in 1971 when Leatherbury was murdered according to the ‘TB Multiagency Investigative Team Report 1992.’
A Google maps route from the Rogers Rooming house in Seattle where Bundy was living at the time to where Johanna was last seen in Utah.
A picture of a car similar to Johanna’s white Chrysler.
Where the ‘Complex’ once was located, which was where Leatherbury was last seen before she was murdered on August 20, 1971.
The intersection where the ‘Complex’ once was located, which was where Leatherbury was last seen before she was murdered on August 20, 1971.
The intersection where the ‘Complex’ once was located, which was where Leatherbury was last seen before she was murdered on August 20, 1971.
The town of Magna, which is where the two fishermen that discovered Johanna’s body had to travel to in order to report their discovery to police.
An aerial view of the Goggins Drain outside of SLC in Utah where Johanna’s remains were found.
The World Motor Hotel.
The former site of ‘The Complex.’
The Great Saltair.
 A brown International Harvester scout.
A 1960 black Chevrolet Impala like the one that was reportedly seen the night Johanna was killed.
A Timex watch much like the one found left behind at Michael Bowe’s murder.
In a letter dated December 15, 2015 Deputy commissioner Bill Gill said that Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Todd Grey said they were able to secure a sample of Leatherbury's DNA  as well as er jaw for further testing. He also said they had an interview with Robert Sales, who is serving time at the Utah State Prison for a murder similar in nature to Leatherbury's.
A brief mentioning of Johanna Leatherbury VIDOCQ Society newsletter. According to their website, ‘for more than 25 years, the VIDOCQ Society has provided pro bono expert assistance to law enforcement agencies across the United States as they work to solve their cold case homicides.  The Society does not conduct independent investigations; we act as a catalyst and assist law enforcement agencies only at their invitation.’
William Rulon Shaw.
Michael Preston Bown.
Acccordingg to
A picture of Robert Lee Sales published in The Ogden Standard-Examiner on January 18, 1974.
Robert Sales victim, Joann Poulsen.
Roylene ‘Roydie’ Alexander, who was murdered by Robert Sales at the age of 17 on June 15, 1972.
An article about Robert Sales being charged for the murder of Roylene Alexander that was published by The Salt Lake Tribune on February 22, 2003.
An obituary for Sheri Martin published by The Deseret News on September 11, 1971.
Leeora Looney.
Raymond Carl Taylor (l) and Sherman McCrary (r). Carolyn Elizabeth McCrary is being escorted in background. Photo courtesy of Oxygen.
Pictures of the McCrary family and Raymond Taylor after they were arrested.
An article about the McCrary family published by Deseret News on December 6, 1973.
Norman Daniel ‘Pete’ Hayward, who served as the Salt Lake County Sheriff for 12 years and was employed with the Sheriff’s Office for over 44 years. 
A distant cousin of Johanna’s left a comment on her ‘findagrave’ page.

Carol Louise Platt-Valenzuela.*

Carol Louise was born on December 30, 1955 to William and Barbara (nee Johnson) Platt in Bemidji, Minnesota. The couple had five children: Carol, David, Gary, Robert, and Gail. After high school Bill Platt attended Bemidji State University and worked in general construction before entering the US Navy during World War II. He returned to the Turtle River area of Minnesota after he was discharged and married Barbara on April 10, 1950. After the couple got hitched, Mr. Platt worked in the local mines, on the iron range, and was self-employed in his later years; Mrs. Platt was a trained cook and worked various jobs including at the Lake Julia Nursing Home, Markham Hotel, Viking Supper Club, and the Turtle Club. Carol eventually relocated to Camas, Washington. Like so many of the other unconfirmed victims I wasn’t able to find much about her background.

Seventeen-year-old Carol married Robert Valenzuela on August 17, 1973 and shortly after the couple became the parents of twins (they were ten months old when she was murdered). The couple were only married for about a year when on August 2, 1974 Carol disappeared after hitchhiking from Camas to Vancouver: she apparently made it to her intended destination and was last seen at a welfare office in Vancouver. At 11:00 AM a case worker told her to come back later that same afternoon at 1 PM to receive food stamps, however she never returned to the office and was never seen from again. Robert reported her missing two days later on August 4; she was eighteen years old. Ms. Valenzuela was not known to be involved in prostitution and had no criminal record. The case quickly went dry.

On the morning of October 12, 1974 a deer hunter stumbled upon a mass of hair in a heavily wooded area roughly fourteen miles northeast of Vancouver not far from the Oregon border. He thought it was an unusual place to find a wig and after investigating the mass with the shank of his gun quickly realized it was attached to a skull and that it wasn’t a wig at all. After law enforcement arrived they quickly realized there wasa second victim and their skeletal remains were scattered throughout the area. According to lab reports, the bones had not completely oxidized and it was determined that their deaths most likely did not occur suddenly, and possibly took place as a result of suffocation. Thebodies were discovered within a mile or so of where 16-year-old Jamie Grissim’s ID was found (she vanished on December 7, 1971 and to this day her remains have never been recovered). It was determined that the second woman’s death took place roughly six weeks before Valenzuela’s. Former Clark County Sheriff Gene Cotton reported that Robert Valenzuela was initially held as a ‘material witness’ although no charges were ever filed against him.

Eventually it was determined that the physical characteristics of the first skeleton matched those of Valenzuela. Former Curator of the Physical Anthropology department at the Smithsonian J. Lawrence Angel said that the second victim was ‘white, between 17 and 23 years old, and was of slender build, weighing about 125 or 130 pounds.’ … he also said that ‘the woman probably had a small face and long, dark brown hair which was coarse, thick and probably with a natural curl.’ He also commented that her upper teeth were ‘noticeably decayed’ and she had a ‘splayed back, protruding buttocks and had apparently given birth.’ When the two bodies were initially found their dental charts were sent to Bemidji, Minnesota as part of a routine check of missing persons in the area, which resulted in the identification of Mrs. Valenzuela. The remains of the second victim were sent to the FBI laboratory in Washington, DC but went unidentified for many years.

Martha Morrison resided in Portland, Oregon and vanished without a trace on September 1, 1974. She grew up in foster care while living in Lane County, Oregon and had a history of substance abuse and running away from home (both her biological and foster families). Morrison was last seen leaving the apartment she rented with a boyfriend; they had reportedly gotten into an argument. DNA was obtained from Morrison’s sister and half-brother, which helped develop a genetic profile to compare to potential matches. After the testing was complete, it was compared to the currently unidentified remains, whose DNA profile was developed in 2012. Similarities in the genetic material were noted, however a definite match was not immediately established. It didn’t help that Morrison’s skull and some other bones were mislabeled as Valenzuela’s while they were sitting in storage (which was one of the reasons why the remains were unidentified for so long). The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children paid to have Morrison’s Fathers body exhumed so they could obtain his DNA to compare it to the unidentified remains, which resulted in a positive identification that the remains were those of Martha Morrison on July 17, 2015. After her body was successfully ID’d, police went to the public, encouraging them to submit tips to help solve the case. In August 2017, law enforcement matched her blood with remnants on a pistol owned by Warren Leslie Forrest, who was a longtime suspect. Before Forrest was named as their killer both Ted Bundy and Randall Woodfield (the I-5 Killer) were both considered as ‘people of interest’ in both women’s murders. Forrest was officially charged with Morrison’s homicide in 2020.

At the time Valenzuela disappeared in the summer of 1974 Bundy was still in a long term relationship with Liz Kloepfer and was residing in the Rogers Rooming House on 12th Avenue in Seattle. He was getting ready to move to Salt Lake City to begin his second attempt at law school and was employed with The Department of Emergency Services in Olympia (he worked there just for a few months from May 3, 1974 until August 28). Bundy told law enforcement that he wasn’t responsible for the death of Valenzuela, which is one of the only murders from the Pacific Northwest that he was suspected of that he denied. Most likely because Ted was a habitual liar he remained a suspect of Valenzuela’s murder for quite a few years, as he told investigators before he was executed he may or may not be responsible for additional murders other than the ones he was convicted of.

Enter Warren Leslie Forrest. Forrest apparently liked to pose as a Seattle University photography student and liked to approach women asking if they’d like to pose for pictures for a fee of thirty to forty dollars. The victims would leave with him in his blue murder van where he quickly subdued them and bound them with rope at the ankles and wrists. Forrest was a government employee with the Parks Department which gave him access to a lot of restricted areas in local recreation areas. One of his victims managed to escape after he kidnapped and brutally raped her, and thankfully she was able to get away and flag down a passing motorist who took her to the police. Forrest was eventually tracked down and although law enforcement couldn’t place him in the area at the time of Valenzuela’s disappearance detectives were intrigued by the recurring pattern of victims that were dumped in the woods. They were also struck by the testimony of Forrest’s friends, who were shocked at his actions and claimed he was just a normal, regular guy (which is similar to the way psychologists predicted Bundy acted with his friends).

Warren Leslie Forrest has been in prison on a single murder count since 1974, when he was charged with the murder of nineteen year old Krista Kay Blake. In 2014, detectives began taking another look at physical evidence related to Forrest’s criminal history to help link him to any possible unsolved crimes, but it wasn’t until 2019 that DNA evidence helped link him to the murder of Morrison. Forensic experts from the Washington State Police Crime Lab isolated a partial DNA profile from bloodstains found on Forrest’s dart gun and cross-referenced it with Morrison’s DNA, which led to the positive identification of her remains. As a result, Forrest was identified as her killer. In January 2020 Forrest was extradited to Clark County to await charges in Martha Morrison’s murder. For the first time in 40 years he appeared in court on February 7, 2020, pleading not guilty. The trial was originally scheduled to begin on April 6 2020, but was delayed several times due to the COVID pandemic. The trial finally resumed in early 2023 and on February 1, 2023 a jury found him guilty of the murder of Martha Morrison. Sixteen days later, Forrest was given another life sentence. During the proceedings, he was still apprehensive about admitting his guilt, but freely gave his opinion that ‘girls from socially disadvantaged environments should not hitchhike or get into cars with strangers due to their vulnerable disposition.’

Sadly, Carols father Bill and her brother David died on January 2, 1986 in a car accident north of Bemidji; Bill was 58 and David was 28. Barbara Platt passed away on February 9, 1993 at the age of 61 in Fargo, ND. It does seem that Robert Valenzuela did eventually remarry. I’m respecting Carols family and will not disclose anything about her twins.

* In October 2024 one of Carol’s grandchildren reached out to me to not only point out some things that were incorrect in my piece but to also voice concern that her grandmothers article didn’t belong on a website about Ted Bundy. After a bit of back and forth I told her I would not remove the article but would add a disclaimer that Carol was not a victim of the serial murderer and more likely was killed by the hands of Warren Leslie Forrest. This blog may have Ted Bundy in the title but it’s turned into so much more than that. And I also want to add that I didn’t pay someone to go find me secret files about Ms. Valenzuela: everything I found was in the public domain and was literally at my fingertips. Where I do understand that it must be incredibly invasive to do a Google search and find an entire article written about your grandmother that was murdered in an incredibly brutal way, but everything I found was either in a newspaper article or from some sort of historical website, like Ancestry/MyHeritage. Also, if something is misspelled (like a name), that is information I pulled from another source, so if it’s not correct in my article it’s also incorrect in the original. I didn’t pull it out of thin air, it came from somewhere. Instead of Googling someone and having to go through 7-8 websites to get everything you need, I’m trying my hardest to be a complete resource. All of this information was easily found, and was free.

Carol Valenzuela.
Carol (middle).
Carol with her twins; they were ten months old when she disappeared.
William Platts WW2 draft card.
Carol Valenzuela’s death certificate.
An announcement about Robert and Carol published by The Pioneer on April 24, 1974.
Robert Valenzuela
A clipping about the murder of Carol. Published by The Ellensburg Daily Record on October 24, 1974.
A clipping about the murder of Carol published by The Corvallis Gazette-Times on October 24, 1974.
An article about the identification of Carol Valenzuela published by the Eugene Register-Guard on October 23, 1974.
An article about the identification of Carol Valenzuela published by The Columbian on October 23, 1974.
An article about the identification of Carol Valenzuela published by The Albany Democrat-Herald on October 23, 1974.
An article about the identification of Carol Valenzuela published by The Longview Daily News on October 23, 1974.
An article about the identification of Carol Valenzuela published by The Spokesman-Review on October 24, 1974.
An article about the identification of Carol Valenzuela published by The Capital Journal on October 24, 1974.
An article about the identification of Carol Valenzuela published by The Capital Journal on November 30, 1974.
An article about the identification of Carol Valenzuela published by The News Tribune on November 30, 1974.
A picture about of the unidentified victim (that turned out to be Martha Morrison) in an article about the identification of Carol Valenzuela published by the Eugene Register-Guard on November 30, 1974.
An article about Carol published by The Columbian on November 29, 1974.
An article about the identification of Carol Valenzuela published by the Eugene Register-Guard on November 30, 1974.
An article about the identification of Carol Valenzuela published by the Columbian on December 2, 1974.
An article about Bundy’s King County victims and their possible relation to Valenzuela’s published by The Columbian on March 12, 1975.
An article mentioning Valenzuela published by The Columbian on July 20, 1975.
An article mentionong Carol published by The Columbian on July 30, 1978.
An article about the possible finding of the remains of plane hijacker DB Cooper that mentions Carol Valenzuela published by the Eugene Register-Guard on February 27, 1980.
An article about Bundy’s victims that mentions Carol, published by The Ellensburg Daily Record on January 19, 1989.
An article about Bundy’s WA state victims that mentions Carol Valenzuela, published by The Telegraph on January 23, 1989.
Part two of an article about a possible stay for Bundy’s January 1989 execution that mentions Carol Valenzuela, published by The Ellensburg Daily Record on January 23, 1989.
An article about Bundy’s victims that mentions Carol, published by The Gainesville Sun on January 23, 1989.
An article about Bundy’s suspected victims that mentions Carol, published by The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on January 24, 1989.
An article about Bundy’s suspected victims that mentions Carol, published by The Gainesville Sun on January 25, 1989.
An article that mentions Carol, published by The Columbian on January 27, 1994.
An article mentioning Valenzuela published by The Statesman Journal on August 25, 2017.
An article mentioning Valenzuela published by The Longview Daily News on January 20, 2020.
The house where Carol was living at the time she was abducted, located at 825 Northwest Ivy Street in Camas, Washington.
Carol’s grave stone.
Ted’s whereabouts on August 2, 1974 when Carol Valenzuela disappeared according to the ‘TB Multiagency Investigative Team Report 1992.’
Bundy’s possible route from his room at the Rogers Boarding House to Vancouver, where Carol was last seen.
It’s important to keep in mind that Warren Leslie Forrest didn’t always look like the old, ragged dirtbag he is today: at one time he was young and handsome.
Some mugshots of a younger Warren Leslie Forrest.
A more recent picture of Warren Leslie Forrest.
Warren Leslie Forrest’s blue murder van. 
Bundy told law enforcement that he wasn't responsible for the death of Valenzuela, whhich is the only murder out of the PacficNorthwest that Bundy wassuspecterd of that he denied.
A picture of Warren Leslie Forrest victim Martha Morrison.
Jamie Grissim.
Some suspected victims of Warren Leslie Forrest.
Randall Woodfield, an American serial killer nicknamed the I-5 Killer after the highway he hunted his prey (which ran from Washington to California). Originally from Oregon, Woodfield was convicted of three murders and is suspected of killing up to eighteen people. He is currently incarcerated at the Oregon State Penitentiary.